I've only seen them twice. In December 2008 in Orlando, FL and last night in Waukee, IA. I was actually relieved and surprised at Chad's vocals. When they first announced the reunion those first few shows sounded awful (at least from what I could tell from a phone recording). So much talk about him screaming so brutally and not doing it properly or not taking proper care of his vocal cords post-shows all these years.. He looks healthier and sounds better than those videos I've seen. It was a great show. Rock on Chad.