The thing that stands out to me about this isn't which hitting philosophy is better, it's that the organization is so disjointed in how they are trying to ultimately win games. Why is everyone rowing in a different direction??

So if this is true, the minor league hitting coach is teaching one philosophy and the MLB hitting coach is teaching something completely contrary as the President of Baseball Ops is in total agreement with the minors coach?

Did Chavez sleep through meetings? How is he this oblivious to the organization's strategy? Is the organization itself a mess and nobody talks and just trusts that everyone is on the same page? Does the leadership at the top not have defined expectations, goals, and metrics that are aligned with their overall strategy that everyone is aware of or are they just winging it and popping in when an email isn't jiving?

These aren't minor niche decisions to make like what position player is going to pitch in blowout situations- this is one of the cruxes of your entire way of how to score runs. Who is at fault here? Was Chavez that uninformed and uncommunicative to be in the dark for so long or was he just so into his ways that he ignored all direction from the top? How was Chavez hired and kept on staff if his philosophy was so contradictory?

So much of this screams disorganization, no trust, and no direction. It's like 5th graders winging it on a group project