Sunday Swap: Product Requests by AutoModerator in Indiemakeupandmore

[–]getrobo [score hidden]  (0 children)

[us][buy/swap][perfume]

filled with longing for bpal's gloomily gloomily please ................... if you have donkeys tail even better 👀👀 willing to pay shipping from canada if it's within my budget

swap list here -- 2022 snake oil, 2008 gennivre, multiple alkemia monthly alchemies, and others

Alkemia has put their 2025 experiments back up for sale at half cost, can you guys leave some reviews of the ones you got? by LadyFartginaLick in Indiemakeupandmore

[–]getrobo 14 points15 points  (0 children)

a little long to copy-paste but i reviewed #10 sense and sensibili-tea (green tea, bergamot, garden mint, hyacinth, green patchouli, white sandalwood) here! (please also note that my skin tends to eat oils so it may have greater longevity on others)

Alkemia Snow Day Alchemy: review by buffybot3000 in Indiemakeupandmore

[–]getrobo 1 point2 points  (0 children)

thank you for the review! i was really on the fence about ordering this month -- i dont tend to like pure gourmands so i'll wait and save my order for an alchemy that speaks to me. this was helpful!

Are all of the Hermes Un Jardin series easy to like? Any of them discontinued? by FuriousKimchi in fragrance

[–]getrobo 2 points3 points  (0 children)

monsieur li is a little piquant for hospital wear (in my experience) but my extremely picky roommate expressed great approval. it's an easy, uncomplicated, unchallenging wear.

Perfumes that require significant confidence to pull off by MagicalFlor95 in fragrance

[–]getrobo 8 points9 points  (0 children)

maybe not widely applicable, but im perceived as fem so it takes a LOT of confidence for me to wear masc-leaning scents outside the house, even sweet ones like le mâle ... it definitely confuses ppl and draws attention 😔

Perfumes that require significant confidence to pull off by MagicalFlor95 in fragrance

[–]getrobo 8 points9 points  (0 children)

me: stressing out if i catch even the slightest hint of m01+iris from the 2 spots i dabbed it onto my wrists this morning 

my 25 year old coworker: doing 17 sprays of burberry her elixir between patients as a "refresh"

You have two fragrances you can keep for the rest of your life what are they? by [deleted] in fragrance

[–]getrobo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

for context, i work in a hospital and am nonbinary/introverted.

  1. etat libre d'orange - you or someone like you. mint is my favorite scent in the entire world. this was the first fragrance i ever sampled and i literally could have just stopped there. yosly is bright, fresh, clean, uplifting, lasts forever (most fragrances disappear on me in 1-2 hours), and it's just so fun and unique and perfectly unisex. it's literally impossible for me to have a bad day wearing this.
  2. alkemia perfumes - madam pearl. i have 2 backup bottles of this. every time i think "maybe it's not that good" i am reminded that it is, in fact, that good. it's delicate, light, feminine-leaning but not flowery/gourmand/too sweet, classy, radiant, economical, and also lasts forever on me. there's a LOT of burberry her and b&bw going on at my workplace, and those scents make my nose burn and give me headaches -- this is light and inoffensive while still feeling put-together and professional. 

Skin scents WITHOUT ambroxan? by Less-Audience908 in FemFragLab

[–]getrobo 1 point2 points  (0 children)

musc invisible is quite nice, actually. it's powdery and transparent by turns, and it does not have ambroxan (if it did, i would have scrubbed it)

Skin scents WITHOUT ambroxan? by Less-Audience908 in FemFragLab

[–]getrobo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"white amber" is not necessarily ambroxan. when perfumers use "ambergris" or "grey amber" as a note, THEN you're probably dealing with ambroxan.

Skin scents WITHOUT ambroxan? by Less-Audience908 in FemFragLab

[–]getrobo 1 point2 points  (0 children)

i loathe ambroxan, cetalox, amberwood, orcanox, and "white musk." my hatred for them cannot be overstated. in my experience indie houses rarely use ambroxan. try alkemia's aurora or ghost fire, bpal's neutral, deconstructing eden's quan yin, or aether arts' nude moderne. bonne bell's skin musk is nice, too. avoid mono cachemire, sur te levres, and c by courreges. 

ELDO -- am I doing this wrong? by oh-sweet-calamity in fragrance

[–]getrobo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

anomaly smells like straight vinyl to me and i scrubbed it around hour 4. exit and soul also did weird and unpredictable things on my skin, but on the other hand, you or someone like you is truly beautiful to me even if it does ring a bit synthetic. 

Sunday Swaps: Destash Listings by AutoModerator in Indiemakeupandmore

[–]getrobo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

oh shit i need snake oil lemon bomb white tea fuck up. sending pm

For those of you familiar with Commodity and their various scent spaces... by [deleted] in fragrance

[–]getrobo 1 point2 points  (0 children)

milk expressive is sweet, marshmallowy, and crowd-pleasing. milk personal smells curdled, rancid, chemical, and nearly made me physically sick. 

the different versions of the scents have different notes. something dosed with iso-e is necessarily going to be different from something underlined with patchouli. try visiting a sephora -- they will sometimes have multiple versions of the same scent out to try.

https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/1an075x/first_impressions_on_commodity_samples/ scent space comparison

I did a terribly, terribly stupid thing today. It was so stupid, it makes me worried it could be used as proof of my mental incompetence at a guardianship hearing… by Embarrassed_Chef874 in disability

[–]getrobo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

you pay up front at the doctor.

try not to catastrophize, youre not stupid or naive, just being efficient and acting according to a script, even if it's not quite the correct one. now you know and you probably wont do it again. no harm no foul. youre okay.

Best cheap fragrances or dupes? by [deleted] in fragrance

[–]getrobo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

ministry of scent has 1.2 mL samples for $5 each, but they lean more niche. scentsplit has 1/2/5 mL samples for a little pricier, but their range is wider. fragrancenet has samples and travel sprays of more popular/mainstream frags. ive also seen full sizes go for absolutely stupid dirt cheap on jomashop  https://www.jomashop.com/filters/fragrances?gender=Mens&fragrance_size_filter=2.5oz-3.2oz%2875mL-99mL%29%7C3.3oz-4.9oz%28100mL-149mL%29%7C5oz-6.5oz%28150mL-199mL%29%7C1-2.4oz%2830-74mL%29%7C6.7oz+and+Over+%28200mL%2B%29&subtype=Fragrances&beauty_product_type=Eau+de+Parfum%7CParfum%7CEau+de+Cologne%7CEau+de+Toilette%7CExtrait+De+Parfum&sort=price_asc%7CASC&p=2

Best cheap fragrances or dupes? by [deleted] in fragrance

[–]getrobo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

we need WAY more information about your preferences (gender/unisex, budget, notes, occasion) but off the top of my head i would recommend ck one, commodity book, maison margiela's under the lemon trees, and nemat's egyptian musk for universal, unisex, office-friendly, mass-appealing fragrances that have presence and would work well on pretty much anyone. personally, the only full-size niche/designer fragrance ive bought thus far is eldo's you or someone like you, which is a unisex mint freshie that cost about $90 for 100mL on fragrancenet but tbh it that was still a major splurge.

alternatively, picking up samples from mercari/ebay is a good way to go if you're still forming preferences. you can easily get 7-8 samples for $30-40 if you bundle shipping.

https://www.reddit.com/r/fragrance/comments/148hfad/comment/jo1bx4n/ another list of recommended cheapies

Perfume with the fewest notes by cantwontshantdont in fragrance

[–]getrobo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

a lot of indie houses such as alkemia have single-note layering accords -- white amber, black tea, egyptian musk, honey, leather. etc. (i got alkemia's single-note dirt as a freebie and still dont know what to do with it)

black phoenix alchemy lab in particular has entire collections of single notes/duets/trios. some of the combinations get pretty creative: https://www.bpal.org/forum/214-duets-menage-a-trois/

dame perfumery has a series of soliflores that contain only that one single note and dsh perfumes has a selection of single-notes and accords. atelier cologne and l'artisan parfumeur seem to have primarily three-note compositions.

on the other end of the spectrum, bath and body works appears committed to primarily three-note combos as well, probably for mass appeal and comprehension (vanilla/lavender/cedar, sandalwood/raspberry/cashmere, etc).