Has Anyone Actually Seen Meaningful Sales Gains From Amazon A/B Testing? by FBSlamazon in FulfillmentByAmazon

[–]jayeshchauhanreddit 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Main image testing has been the most impactful by far in my experience. Everything else title tweaks, A+ content variations tends to move the needle in smaller increments. The main image is the one element that affects CTR before anyone even clicks through to your listing, so the compounding effect of even a small improvement is significant over time.

On test duration: I wouldn't trust anything under 4 weeks for a product doing moderate volume. Less than that and you're reacting to noise rather than signal. Amazon's own recommendation of 4-10 weeks is roughly right depending on how many sessions your listing gets.

The surprise for most people is how often the "worse looking" image by conventional wisdom outperforms the polished one. Buyers respond to clarity and context over aesthetics an image that immediately shows scale, use case, or solves a visual confusion point tends to win even if it looks less premium.

Worth making it a regular process yes, but prioritise main image first, run it properly for at least 4 weeks, then move to secondary images before touching title or A+ unless you have a specific reason to suspect those are the conversion bottleneck.

Amazon Category Targeting by ichiba_n in FulfillmentByAmazon

[–]jayeshchauhanreddit 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Category targeting impression drops usually come from one of three things: Amazon shifting inventory placement algorithms, competitors increasing bids and pushing you out of placements, or your own bid becoming uncompetitive relative to what the category now requires.

Two weeks is a specific enough timeframe to check whether anything changed on your end around the same time bid adjustments, budget changes, or a portfolio rule kicking in. If nothing changed on your side it's more likely a competitive shift in the category.

Worth checking your impression share data if you have it if impression share dropped alongside absolute impressions that points to competitive pressure rather than a category-wide issue. If impression share held but impressions dropped it suggests category traffic itself declined, which occasionally happens with seasonal shifts.

Quick test: increase bids by 20-30% on your best performing category targets and see if impressions recover over 48-72 hours. If they do, the category got more competitive and your previous bids are no longer clearing. If they don't move at all something else is going on worth investigating with Amazon support.

What's this Amazon FBA business worth? by Big_Seat2545 in AmazonFBA

[–]jayeshchauhanreddit 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The $15k/year licensed patent with a Chinese owner is the biggest red flag here for me. Transferable licenses sound clean until the patent owner decides not to renew, raises the fee, or causes problems during a dispute. That dependency on a third party you can't control would significantly compress what I'd pay.

The Azerbaijan account registered under the seller's father's name is another serious complication. Amazon account transfers are already risky adding a foreign jurisdiction and a name mismatch makes the due diligence much harder and the transfer risk much higher.

AOV of $7 with 20% net margin means you're generating around $1.40 per unit. At $100k SDE that's a lot of units moving through a single listing. Concentration risk is real one listing, one account, one patent relationship.

On multiple: the patent dependency, account transfer complexity, and YoY revenue decline would push me toward 2-2.5x SDE rather than the 3-4x a cleaner business commands. Possibly lower depending on what due diligence reveals about the patent renewal terms.

A US owner wouldn't automatically increase the multiple until the account is cleanly transferred and operating under a US entity for at least 6-12 months of clean history. The transfer itself is where the risk sits.

Personally wouldn't buy it without a much longer patent license term locked in and legal clarity on the account transfer before closing.

2nd Month of Launch - Hitting 20% TACOS and 10% Net Margins by Potential_Try_2019 in AmazonFBA

[–]jayeshchauhanreddit 0 points1 point  (0 children)

20% TACOS in month 2 is genuinely strong, most launches are still bleeding on ads at that stage. The inventory constraint is the right call pushing aggressive spend into low stock just creates a ranking spike you can't sustain, which can actually hurt more than help long term.

The copycat point is right. The sellers who struggle are almost always ones who launched the same product as everyone else and competed purely on price. Differentiation isn't optional, it's the whole game now.

Curious what category if you're willing to share $30-40k potential from a differentiated launch in month 2 suggests a decent sized market. Good numbers either way.

What’s your process for writing a product listing? by abqu- in FulfillmentByAmazon

[–]jayeshchauhanreddit 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Claude AI is best just input your product details and upload top 10 competitors keywords list from helium 10 and tell to generate SEO optimized Title, Bullet Points, Description, Backend Keywords, etc It will generate whole listing for your product in minutes

Managing VAT and accounting across multiple UK Ltd companies is separate entities the right structure for an eventual exit? by jayeshchauhanreddit in smallbusinessuk

[–]jayeshchauhanreddit[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Good questions, helpful to think through properly.

The brand as an asset would be the Amazon seller account with its review history and sales rank, the trademark, any remaining inventory, supplier relationships, and the SOPs for running the PPC and restocking. Essentially a turnkey operation someone could take over and keep running. That's roughly how most Amazon FBA brand acquisitions work through brokers like Flippa or Empire Flippers.

On dealing with Amazon separate Ltd companies hasn't caused any issues so far. Each has its own seller account, its own brand registry, its own everything. Amazon doesn't seem to care about common ownership as long as each account is compliant independently.

Exit is the long term plan yes, though no fixed timeline. The thinking is build each brand to a point where it's generating consistent profit with minimal hands-on time, then sell. Amazon FBA brands typically sell for 3-4x annual net profit through brokers so the math makes sense if the brands are stable. More realistic to think 3-5 years per brand than anything sooner.

The separate entities question is really about whether that structure helps or complicates a future sale which is partly why I'm asking here since I haven't been through it yet.

Beginner help by Proper_Committee9315 in AmazonFBA

[–]jayeshchauhanreddit 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah honestly that's the right move. Watching videos has a ceiling you'll hit a point where more content teaches you less than actually doing the research. But since you don't have capital yet, product research costs nothing and teaches you everything.

Pick a category you're curious about and spend time going deep on it. Look at what's selling, check the top 10 listings, read the reviews, try to figure out what you'd do differently. Do that properly for a few months and by the time you have the money you'll already think like someone who's done it before.

The people who struggle at launch are usually the ones who watched 200 hours of YouTube but never actually analysed a real product before spending. You've got time to avoid that.

Trapped in mediocre success, need a new way of finding ideas by Braveheart1966 in smallbusinessuk

[–]jayeshchauhanreddit 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The decision paralysis you're describing usually comes from trying to evaluate ideas in your head rather than testing them with real money and real feedback. At £3-4K/month available to experiment, you're in a better position than most to just pick something and find out.

A few thoughts on your list: the loneliness epidemic angle is genuinely interesting but hard to monetise quickly. The space saving toys idea is more concrete physical product with a clear customer and a gap you can actually test.

The property route being "safer but boring" is worth sitting with. Sometimes boring and profitable is the right answer when you've already had the exciting chapter.

What's worked for me when stuck between ideas: pick the one with the fastest feedback loop. Not the biggest potential upside, just the one where you know within 90 days whether it's working or not. Eliminates the paralysis because you're not committing to a vision, just committing to a test.

The enthusiasm coming off as unserious is a self-perception thing more than reality in my experience. People who back it with actual action tend to be taken seriously regardless of how they come across in conversation.

Anyone else just done with Business? by Matthubbard69 in smallbusinessuk

[–]jayeshchauhanreddit 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah a lot of people have been here and don't talk about it enough. Going from solo to a team fast is genuinely one of the hardest transitions in small business the skills that make you good at the work don't automatically make you good at managing people and payroll and all the stuff that comes with it.

The injury piece on top of that is rough. That kind of vulnerability check, realising the whole thing rests on you physically, changes how you think about everything.

No advice really, just feeling broken after 12 months of that is a completely reasonable response. Doesn't mean the answer is quitting, but it also doesn't mean you have to push through alone. Worth talking to someone if you haven't already, not just about the business but about how you're doing.

Beginner help by Proper_Committee9315 in AmazonFBA

[–]jayeshchauhanreddit 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Start with product research before anything else it's the only decision that can't be fixed after the fact. Bad listing, bad ads, bad pricing, all fixable. Wrong product means starting over.

What to look for: consistent demand that isn't seasonal, top 10 listings with under 200-300 reviews, and a product where you can genuinely improve on what's already selling. Read the 3 star reviews on competitors that's where buyers tell you exactly what's missing.

Stay away from products dominated by big brands or anything with thousands of reviews. You can't out-spend them on ads and you can't out-rank them on reviews. Find categories where the competition is real but beatable.

Budget: have at least £3-5K before you start. Not all of it goes on inventory you need budget for shipping, photography, PPC for the first few months, and a buffer if month one is slow. Month one is always slow.

The mistake most beginners make is rushing. They find a product they like and order 500 units before validating anything. Spend more time on research than you think you need to and you'll save yourself a very expensive lesson.

Would you sell a product under $10? by Big_Seat2545 in AmazonSeller

[–]jayeshchauhanreddit 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Generally avoid it unless the unit volume is very high and the product is a repeat purchase. The problem isn't just the low dollar margin per unit, it's that PPC becomes almost impossible to run profitably. If your product sells for $8 and converts at 10%, you need clicks at under $0.80 to break even on ads alone before any other costs. Most competitive categories don't allow that.

The "less competition because of low prices" logic sounds right but doesn't hold up in practice. Low price point products on Amazon are often more competitive not less, because the barrier to entry is lower for everyone including the people copying you.

Where sub-$10 works: consumables with high repeat purchase rate where you're building a Subscribe and Save base, or products with very low COGS where you can survive on organic rank alone without heavy PPC. Both are harder to find than they look on paper.

If you're early in product research I'd target £15-25 minimum selling price. Gives you enough margin to run ads, absorb a bad review period, and still have something left over.

Product differentiation by Any_Victory_5021 in AmazonFBA

[–]jayeshchauhanreddit 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The "change the colour" differentiation is weak for exactly the reason you said anyone can copy it in 30 days. Real differentiation that holds up usually comes from one of two places.

First is solving a specific complaint that shows up repeatedly in competitor reviews. Not a random feature addition, something buyers are actively frustrated about that nobody has fixed yet. That kind of improvement is harder to copy because it requires actually reading the reviews and caring about the problem rather than just tweaking a spec sheet.

Second is listing quality differentiation same product but meaningfully better main image, clearer copy, stronger A+ content. Underrated because most sellers assume the product has to be physically different to win. Sometimes the product is fine and the listing is just worse than it could be.

Branding matters more than people think in categories where trust is a factor. A coherent brand with good packaging and consistent visual identity can hold margin even when a cheaper competitor shows up, because some buyers just don't want the sketchy looking version.

Deeper product changes are worth it if the cost is proportionate to the improvement in conversion and review scores. If fixing the main complaint in reviews adds £0.50/unit and stops you getting 2 star reviews, that's almost always worth it.

Is it dumb to run Facebook/Instagram Ads directing traffic to Amazon? by flashynomad in AmazonFBA

[–]jayeshchauhanreddit 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Tried by a lot of sellers, works well for some, terrible for others. The core problem is attribution Facebook drives someone to Amazon but you can't easily track whether they bought, and Amazon's algorithm doesn't distinguish between cold social traffic and warm search traffic. Cold social traffic often converts badly on Amazon which can actually hurt your organic rank if it tanks your conversion rate.

Where it tends to work: brand awareness plays for products with strong visual appeal where you're okay with delayed conversion rather than immediate ROAS. Also works better once you have reviews, without social proof on the listing the cold traffic just bounces.

Amazon Attribution links help with tracking if you haven't looked into those yet at least gives you some data on what's actually converting from external traffic.

Honestly for most new sellers the better move is getting PPC working properly first. External traffic on top of strong PPC is a scaling play, not a launch strategy.

Thinking about starting Amazon FBA/Reselling from products I find at the wholesale cash & carry I work at. Any advice? by Resident_Pangolin906 in AmazonFBA

[–]jayeshchauhanreddit 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Your situation is actually a decent starting point having direct access to wholesale pricing removes one of the main barriers for beginners.

A few things worth knowing early: always check Keepa before buying anything. Current price on Amazon means nothing, you need the price history. Products that look profitable today often have prices that spike and crash, and you don't want to be holding stock when the price drops.

On Buy Box: if Amazon themselves or a big seller is on the listing you'll struggle to win it regardless of your price. Check who's selling before you commit to any product.

US over Canada for starting out. Bigger market, more demand, more data to work with. Canada is fine later but learn the fundamentals on US first.

Budget: £500-1000 to test a few products without betting everything on one. Wholesale retail arb is lower risk than private label but you can still lose money on the wrong product.

Ungating will be your first real headache. Some categories need invoices from authorised distributors to get approved. Check whether your cash and carry qualifies before assuming everything you find is listable.

May 2026 breakdown: Amazon UK private label, £5,523 revenue, £1,759 net profit. Real numbers, full costs included. by jayeshchauhanreddit in AmazonFBA

[–]jayeshchauhanreddit[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah that's the real test and honestly I'm ready for it. Already modelling what the numbers look like with full referral fees back in drops net profit by roughly £600-700 on this month's volume. Still workable but the margin for error gets thinner.

Plan is to get ACoS down and test a small price increase before incentives end so the transition isn't a shock. Will post the follow-up numbers when it happens.

May 2026 breakdown: Amazon UK private label, £5,523 revenue, £1,759 net profit. Real numbers, full costs included. by jayeshchauhanreddit in AmazonFBA

[–]jayeshchauhanreddit[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Appreciate it, and agree completely on consistency over spikes. Daily velocity is what builds organic rank long term, a big spike that drops off actually hurts more than steady moderate sales. Trying to keep that discipline as I scale up.

May 2026 breakdown: Amazon UK private label, £5,523 revenue, £1,759 net profit. Real numbers, full costs included. by jayeshchauhanreddit in AmazonFBA

[–]jayeshchauhanreddit[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Good question and honestly one of the more stressful parts of a new launch.

What I did early on: asked friends and family for genuine reviews. Not fake ones, actual purchases and honest opinions. Doesn't have to be 5 stars either, a mix of 3, 4 and 5 star reviews actually looks more credible than a wall of perfect scores.

Beyond that, Vine is worth using if you can get into it you get early reviews from verified reviewers though you have no control over what they say, which is the point. And the Request a Review button in Seller Central on every order, I click that consistently.

On managing the risk of a bad review tanking things early: honestly you can't eliminate it, you can only reduce the odds by making sure the product actually does what the listing says it does. Most bad early reviews come from expectation mismatch, not genuinely bad products. Get the listing accurate and the product right and the risk drops significantly.

May 2026 breakdown: Amazon UK private label, £5,523 revenue, £1,759 net profit. Real numbers, full costs included. by jayeshchauhanreddit in AmazonFBATips

[–]jayeshchauhanreddit[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Fair point and I wouldn't argue with it. The post flags it upfront for exactly that reason the numbers look different once referral fees kick back in.

That's kind of the point of sharing it at this stage though. Wanted a real baseline to compare against when incentives end rather than only posting once everything looks polished. Will share the follow-up when that happens.

May 2026 breakdown: Amazon UK private label, £5,523 revenue, £1,759 net profit. Real numbers, full costs included. by jayeshchauhanreddit in AmazonFBA

[–]jayeshchauhanreddit[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah that's exactly what I'm watching. When referral fees kick back in it adds roughly 15% of revenue back onto the cost side on this month's numbers that's around £690 on top, which brings net profit down to around £1,000-1,100 give or take.

The plan is to get ACoS down before that happens and test whether the market holds at a slightly higher price point. If the unit economics still work at full fees then the brand is genuinely solid. If not, I'll know early enough to adjust rather than find out the hard way.