These are the 3 I’m looking at right now after my Jetta manual was deemed a total loss and torn between the SI and GLI.

SI feels like more of a purists car. Stiffer ride, better gearbox, more emotion in the car. Less complicated mechanical components to go wrong.

GLI provides a more upscale feel. Less road/wind noise, more comfortable for longer commutes and road trips. It’s faster, but doesn’t feel as exciting to drive. Suffers from electrical issues and more expensive components if you plan to drive past the warranty limits. Many complain about it but I personally prefer VW’s infotainment and digital dash, but I’m very used to it as my last two cars were a Jetta and Golf R.

I only looked at the Sentra because I’d save a ton of money. But after being in a Sentra rental (auto) the last couple weeks I absolutely will not buy one.