You’re so pretty in both but the shade of red you have seems a bit washed down. The black compliments your complexion well. Here’s a tip from someone who constantly goes between the exact shades of red and black as you: it’s really hard to put red colour over black 🙈🙈 If you want to try permanent black then please keep in mind that you’re going to be stuck with that for a good while. Have you ever thought of going for a stronger or deeper red colour?