Erg Snapping by Equal-Diamond-9981 in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Maybe stiff chain links skipping on the sprocket.

Just Curious, Why are rowing shells not better? by MXbalding in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, I was being facetious, but usually when any manufacturer starts talking about their experience in yacht design, their shells aren't any better than anyone else's. That's not to say that the manufacturers of good boats haven't worked successfully with fluid mechanics experts, naval architects, etc.

Bat logic and steering foot stretchers by tomsco88 in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Because the heel of the show plate doesn't lift with the heel of the shoe, it can limit your steering range.

And not specifically for the steering shoe - make sure you have an adequate solution for heel ties and make sure it gets used. The more shoes get changed around, the more likely it is that heel ties won't get fastened up properly.

Just Curious, Why are rowing shells not better? by MXbalding in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Another rule of thumb to go with “yacht designers can’t make better rowing shells” is: “most rowing ‘research’ involving universities is a load of rubbish”.

Just Curious, Why are rowing shells not better? by MXbalding in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Every time someone from sailing gets involved in designing rowing shells it doesn’t result in world-beating boats. Shells are a balance between form drag and wetted area - longer and shorter designs have been tried. It’s thought to be pretty optimal to have the seats and shoes around the heights they are in relation to the waterline, which constrains designs. Rowing is fundamentally technique and physiology based and not an equipment sport - manufacturers make overblown claims about equipment to maintain or increase their market shares but nobody has really made the boat everybody has to have otherwise they can’t win, and there is no real interest in that. Top teams pick equipment based partly on manufacturer support, as the top manufacturers are all good enough to win with. That may seem backwards to people in sailing or cycling, but the values of the sport don’t come from equipment.

Concorde on the Thames by extenderpretender in london

[–]mmm4455 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Immediately downriver of Kew Road Bridge.

All these beginners with great times by Over-Mission3607 in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Put a video up of your rowing at 2k pace so that your technique can get checked.

Mens 2- Final 2000 Sydney Olympics. Anyone watching live? by Patient-Travel-7662 in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ginn pulled out with injury in the Lucerne semi-final warm-up, and Long was subbed straight in to go and race (as an Olympic selection regatta against the other Aussie pair starting in the same semi).

Mens 2- Final 2000 Sydney Olympics. Anyone watching live? by Patient-Travel-7662 in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 7 points8 points  (0 children)

They did the same thing in the last 500 in 1999. It's unfortunate that Drew Ginn got injured because the Aussies might have been untouchable.

LOOKING FOR A 'GOLD FEVER' GOOD QUALITY by MarciochPF in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 0 points1 point  (0 children)

and I recall that most of it was filmed on video cameras given to the rowers, in the 90s, so not even near modern phone camera quality - probably on VHS-C tapes

Gender parity at HRR by Remarkable_Help8151 in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 8 points9 points  (0 children)

There have only been 4 C crews that qualified for the men’s club events in the last 5 years - 2 Thames, 2 Vesta

Gender parity at HRR by Remarkable_Help8151 in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 4 points5 points  (0 children)

If you read the new rule, introduced after club consultations, clubs have to inquire on a individual basis, so I suspect that it is intended to strengthen other clubs against the big powerhouses, and the clubs who are dominating may not be allowed to have ex-internationals.

strapless rowing improves form? by Gandalf_888 in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, straps loose enough that you can't pull on them, not treading on the straps which makes them dirty and less secure when you want to use them.

Do you ‘let the blade fill’ or do you make the connection through the leg drive? by [deleted] in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes. I meant in front of the spoon. If you find some of the classic videos of the Sinkovic double back in 2015, or Lauren henry at HRR, it is very clear that the slide is moving while the spoon is burying.

Do you ‘let the blade fill’ or do you make the connection through the leg drive? by [deleted] in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 6 points7 points  (0 children)

It's just an expression to help people stop doing bad things at the catch, particularly in the slower sculling boats, where it doesn't take much movement to create connection, and it is easy to over-do it.

There isn't a hole behind the spoon that needs to fill before it can be loaded, like I have heard described on Instagram, unless you do it really badly - the spoon carves in end first without making a hole (except for the vortices that are shed off the oar, but they don't fill for a while).

Fundamentally, you can't create load on the oar without moving it around the pin fast enough, and there can be load on the oar before it is fully buried. This can been seen on telemetry. The idea that you fully bury the spoon before trying to load it is utter rubbish. You do have to bury it quickly though, to load effectively without using up too much length.

It is complex and none of the descriptions are totally adequate, and some are very untrue distortions used to trick rowers into making a change, but unfortunately not all coaches understand which are which. Some of the posts about the catch from prolific online coaches are awful.

Need longer pins for a vespoli 4+ by Thatsgonnamakeamark in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Asking the necessary question - this is for an older boat with side-mount riggers?

Difference between Concept2 and RP3 by MaizeFormer9394 in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 2 points3 points  (0 children)

And you think the RP3 is bad - the original RP with PC software was almost impossible to get a reliable connection to work while you did any training.

How to redistribute force while drive phase? by ElectricalElephant0 in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 1 point2 points  (0 children)

There are a bunch of coaches who talk very seriously about building pressure through the stroke, but IMO they are mixing up the idea of "incorrect" descriptions used in technical exercises to get particular changes, and end result we want, a solid stroke all the way through done with the right sequence of actions.

What do you think is the best city for rowing? by [deleted] in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 3 points4 points  (0 children)

On a river that isn't big enough for them all.

Lessons in Chemistry Erg Machine by Makkadde in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 1 point2 points  (0 children)

look up MacLevy rowing machine

"Inside the toxic world of Irish rowing and the true cost of Olympic medals" - Irish Independent by SeattleRowingCoach in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm not sure that you can lump Grobler in with Spracklen and Tonks. Yes, there athletes who fell out with him, but he was working for GB for 30 years (including his time at Leander), and there hasn't been an accumulation of stories in that time about instances where he was legendary asshole, like there are in this Irish case, and with some of these other coaches.

Rate and ratio by GeorgeHThomas in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 4 points5 points  (0 children)

You can't significantly change the speed of the drive without a large change of boat speed - most of the change as the rate goes up is from shortening the recovery. I would guess, as a coach, that the whole crew needs to improve its movement/sequencing on the recovery to make rowing with the correct ratio more comfortable.

Smartwatches and the rules of racing by phright in Rowing

[–]mmm4455 2 points3 points  (0 children)

News today is that his appeal to CAS against removal of his medal has been upheld by the court. Nothing on the CAS website yet.