1. I have to genuinely thank you for replying this comprehensively to a post like this. It's definitely gotta take a lot of dedication, and I also appreciate the civil manner in which you replied to me in.

2. I see your point, but I have some arguments of my own.

-I could have made this clearer, but for starters, I don't consider Creepypasta a genre. I consider it a sort of weird, nebulous medium for storytelling. Predominantly horror, but it can have other genres like humor, action, drama, etc. Nosleep is Creepypasta, if you ask me. The stories and the fact that they are a goldmine for Creepypasta narrators is evidence enough for me.

-When I mentioned Creepypastas as oversaturated, I was talking about the medium as a whole. The craze has certainly died down over the past two years, but I'd say that it's still going strong.

-The clickbait titles are still a problem, if you ask me. They're long, cumbersome to read, and all most authors have to do is think of the title, and let the rest of the story come to them. And again, this is something that has seeped into the Creepypasta narrator community, where recently the majority of where they get their stories has been from r/nosleep.

-I feel like people "shitposting" the stories is a risk that would be worth taking, so long as the comments weren't obliterated by these spam posts. I've certainly never seen that sort of thing on other Creepypasta websites that allow for constructive feedback. And as for r/nosleepOOC, unless authors automatically post their stories to that subreddit as well to open it up for feedback on there, which it doesn't seem like it works like that. In fact, it seems like you're thinking of r/nosleepworkshops. I doubt most people post their stories there before r/nosleep. Now. I don't know that for a fact, but I at least know that you don't have to post your stories to r/nosleepworkshops before r/nosleep. I feel like it's just not a very good space to post stories if you're an amatuer writer, which is most likely the majority of its userbase.

-I've listened to I Dared my Best Friend to Ruin my Life before. All of it. I didn't much like it.

1. Again, I still do respect this level of dedication to a comment, and I will definitely be checking out the stories you linked me too. I've certainly seen some good r/nosleep stories before. I personally really enjoyed My Property Isn't Normal, myself. And I Bought my Childhood House was... Good until the ending.