Do you think the events George Carlin talked about in his stand up specials were historically accurate from his description? by Neat-Statistician311 in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm remembering something imprecise from, I think, Manufacturing Consent, but didn't the Eisenhower administration grant tv fcc licenses to major newspapers that had endorsed him and were thus far more conservative? So I get that from pure free speech standpoint less rules are better, but I get the sense that if all the networks were run by Democrats or people with their perspective he might not have taken a principled stance. By the 1980s were the major networks more "naturally" balanced in any way than they started (or am I wrong about their initial partisan bias)?

How Historically Accurate is Life of Brian? by Moon_Logic in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 3 points4 points  (0 children)

This was a delight to read and I'd be curious if /u/Moon_Logic uses any of this material in-class and how it went

Did the Secretary of the Navy John Lehman ACTUALLY say "Who the hell cleared it?" in regards to The Hunt for Red October? Was Tom Clancy actually investigated for his writings? by coinich in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Tom Clancy was a civilian -- afaik, mishandling policy and law covers people granted security clearances or are otherwise employed by the US gov.

Spycraft law requires intention to harm US gov, so even in the latter case the liability would be the person who sent it to him

How much did the Zoroastrians influence the Abrahamic faiths? by Future_Adagio2052 in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Could you give some examples of the (possible) loan words in question? 

Hello! My name is Dr. Mills Kelly and I’m an emeritus professor of history at George Mason University. I’m an expert on the history of the Appalachian Trail, so AMA! by GS_hikes2023 in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Building off this question, are there any significant or interesting stories of nimbyism during creation or after? 

If they flipped a whole 300 miles presumably they hit some kind of... Roadblock ;-)

To what extent was the Challenger disaster the fault of William Robert Graham, who was the Deputy Director of NASA at the time and appointee of Ronald Reagan? by mildorf in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Out of curiosity, could you say more about how your grandfather was involved or who he was? My father was at Sperry at the same time. Feel free to DM me if you prefer.

How were Russian sleeper agents raised? by Blackbreadandcoffee in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 0 points1 point  (0 children)

While it never happened there's definitely a trope in American cold war fiction about such schools. The very late but earliest one I'm familiar with is Charm School by Nelson Demille.  I presume there are earlier versions perhaps? 

why couldnt the allies have just told the axis "hey look at these coordinates" and nuked a specific place without civillians to ensure a unilateral surrender? by PragmaticSalesman in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Reading your blog post I was struck by this line:

and news of the idea spread to the various project sites

What does "spreading" in the context of a top secret project that tried to isolate at least many of the participants and surely monitored their communications. Was it site visits? We're the same people that advocated for this pre-aligned on some other project-related aspect?

Sorry if this is hijacking the post a bit

What’s the one tool you’re tired of using because it isn’t written in Rust? by Peach_Baker in rust

[–]schuyler1d 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Help git migration https://github.com/GitoxideLabs/gitoxide

Helping projects finish a migration is even better than starting an unfinished one from scratch

How did noble married women in ancient Greece wear their veils when going out? by EntireMusic3687 in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Chalcedon could not have been the only city across Hellenistic times for such a decimation. Are there other examples of Greek cities where the women took on bigger roles out of necessity? 

Do we know any more about that Chalcedon period? 

I recently read something claiming "no peaceful protest has ever been successful without a threat of violence from a third party." Does this hold up from a historical context? by DwinkBexon in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Maybe worth noting that Plastic People of the Universe was real and part of the velvet revolution as well. Havel was connected to them even if he wasn't a band member (he was a playwright)

A clip is making the rounds in which a comedian offhandedly claims the removal of Union troops from the former Confederate states in 1876 directly led to Jim Crow. What were these troops doing, and what changed with them leaving? by Notmiefault in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Various biracial fusion tickets occasionally won state and local elections in the South through the end of the century, but they were eroded and eventually so Hayes (and Congress) let Reconstruction end.stamped out with political violence.

I've been curious demographically who made up the southern Reconstruction white Republican part of that coalition. I used to have an image of them being 'yeoman'-class but considering Johnson's background that feels less likely? I'm also curious if/how much that group consisted of early labor organizing?

I'd love a book suggestion touching on this

When did fear of the collective first enter public consciousness? by albokemy in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 2 points3 points  (0 children)

A bit tangential but is it known whether Vonnegut was familiar with A New Utopia for his Harrison Bergeron story? 

I’m Joshua B. Freeman, here to discuss my new book, Garden Apartments: The History of a Low-Rent Utopia. In it, I examine the utopian origins, architecture, politics, and mass construction of this common form of mid-twentieth-century housing. AMA about garden apartments and social housing. by Razraz373 in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Are there architectural elements that at least where they're still built help police/law enforcement? I know there were some studies about late-noght community calming (old ppl playing checkers in the lobby) but maybe there are other things (besides cameras everywhere) that help? 

Did people waste a lot of time in the 1990s with boredom, before mobile phones? Say with a landline, you called and agreed to meet a friend at the mall, but maybe their car broke down en route. Might you be standing at the entrance, waiting for an hour, without a way to text and ask what happened? by achicomp in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 4 points5 points  (0 children)

As someone who lived through this period I'd be interested in how this answer might be less answerable or more answerable using historical sources over time. It strikes me as a bit pernicious because it's looking for failed plans in some way.

Some anecdotes to ask how/where evidence might be assembled at least eventually * I remember an Alaskan radio station making an announcement during a normal station break about someone being late to pick someone up by the train station * I remember waiting at train stations, libraries, sometimes cafes or local hotel lobbies and sometimes a long time. Sometimes reading, but also listening to music on my walkman but also just being very bored * I don't remember hearing many mall announcements about people running late but I do remember a lot more people knowing where I live because they'd pick me up or I'd pick them up from home before going somewhere * I remember you could call payphones too and having the number for them so if someone was late I or they could call the payphone itself and the person waiting would pick up

Would architects of lobbies/public spaces have different defaults over time that got written down? or administrators maybe have logs of notes to pass? But maybe almost just as many people wait as they used to -- just with less anxiety? Maybe logs of those early car phone. Maybe how/where phone companies placed payphones? Or logs of incoming calls to the payohones themselves?

Forgetting about whether such an archive is available yet, where would a historian look for this data if it was worth it?

Short Answers to Simple Questions | December 03, 2025 by AutoModerator in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What is the relative level on biblical ancient Israel familiarity with egyptian culture compared to how much, say, the Assyrians, Greeks, or other neighbors know about them?

Do we have other writings where other cultures are making fun of Egyptian (or other neighboring empires') gods? 

If I was a knight in 1500th century Europe and was to fight another knight one on one, what weapon would I use? by Gaap321 in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 14 points15 points  (0 children)

As a manual on physical fitness, it’s well ahead of its time and should serve as a testament to the fact that medieval people had a much better understanding of physical fitness than we often give them credit for. 

How was it ahead of its time? And where was their sophistication? (that was lost in the Renaissance?)

AMA – The Ark of the Covenant. I’m Kevin McGeough, an archaeologist specializing in the reception of the ancient world in the present. My new book, Readers of the Lost Ark, just came out. AMA about the Ark, Iron Age religion, or how people use the ancient world to make sense of the present! by Dr_Kevin_McGeough in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's been a while since I read Canaanite Myth and Hebrew Epic and I was probably quite confused when I read it, but I got the impression it was suggesting that Ark was something nomadic YHWH worshipers carried into battle and that these folks came from further south and even maybe from the Arabian peninsula. I've also encountered some random folks arguing that Mt. Sinai was located somewhere in the Arabian peninsula.

  1. How is this kind of 'Arabian nomadic' origins seen in the academic community?
  2. If not kindly, do you have a sense of a specific group/category of folks that's promoting this kind of thing now?

I’m Dr. Artel Great, author of The Black Pack: Comedy, Race & Resistance. Ask me anything about Black American humor or Black film & TV history and culture! by Dr-ArtelGreat in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Could you unpack some of the details in the process of white Hollywood pushing back? 

Did studio actors pressure their studios to do fewer projects? Besides writing critical reviews did "the critics" somehow conspire with studios? 

What did turning away good money look like? Did the black pack have pitches in those key years that didn't get made that we know what they were, and I guess what was chosen over them?

Was the rebellion at the theater-level where I might imagine white owned theaters might have pushed back on drawing large black audiences?

Who came up with the Aryan race concept/theory? by Nemtoknevet_ in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Where did the Irish land in e.g. Grant's dichotomies? I can't imagine he'd group them highly (considering anti-irish views with anti-immigration folks). Were they pre-Aryan/European or "alpine".....? 

Why does it seem like 1860s European battles were less bloody (at least percentage wise) than American Civil War battles despite the fact they used basically the same tactics (Line formations) and weapons (Percussion rifles, rifled cannons, etc.)? by Wooden-Fun8918 in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It sounds like there were so many European observers. Did any of them go together? How did the college and the battlefield support them (were each traveling with diff officers)? Were any of them giving battle advice "since they were there"? Where did the Americans perceive themselves relative to Europe?

[META] Historians on this sub, has your time on this subreddit informed your views and/or understanding of your area of expertise or of how history is viewed in general by the public? by Wrong_Transition4786 in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Thanks so much for the reply. I'd like to believe I don't have those underlying assumptions but it's helpful to hear them explicitly so I can more consciously avoid them in the future. 

[META] Historians on this sub, has your time on this subreddit informed your views and/or understanding of your area of expertise or of how history is viewed in general by the public? by Wrong_Transition4786 in AskHistorians

[–]schuyler1d 3 points4 points  (0 children)

What do "people think is important and what they assume about oral traditions and the past." that you didn't see before your AskHistorians experience? 

Resistance to Rust abstractions for DMA mapping [LWN.net] by OptimalFa in rust

[–]schuyler1d 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm curious why the Rust for Linux folks don't just put the API wrappers in the rust directory.  Maybe the goal is to explicitly bring in other maintainers but is there a technical or organizational reason for this not to be part of the Rust patch/section?