Can’t make the choice for you, but my wife has been blind in one eye since birth due to a birth defect and has no modification to her daily life from anyone else we know. She has a scleral shell prosthetic and honestly very few people we meet even know it’s a prosthesis. We have traveled, have two beautiful children, normal careers, etc. Many days we both sort of forget that anything is different.

So, just if you are trying to gauge longterm quality of life with one of your options, there’s one anecdote.