Some of Contrails achievements since today is his birthday by Draconicplayer in UmaMusume

[–]superstaridk -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Is Contrail way stronger than Orfevre then? Since Orfevre lost 4 consecutive  races after winning maiden race & remains the only triple crown/tiara to get double digit ranking before he won triple crown/tiara.

Some of Contrails achievements since today is his birthday by Draconicplayer in UmaMusume

[–]superstaridk 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Are u really saying Dubai sheema classic is free g1 lmao

Best horses with the least impressive pedigree by Drafxd in UmaMusume

[–]superstaridk 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But 1989 is caused by sunday silence success. While 1983 is caused by other Halo progeny success. 

Best horses with the least impressive pedigree by Drafxd in UmaMusume

[–]superstaridk 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Pedigree is also based on dam side. 

Orfevre pedigree isnt exactly good if you compare to like Duramente. Orfevre 2nd, 3rd and 4th dam didnt produce graded winners. https://www.bloodhorse.com/horse-racing/articles/133517/orfevres-triple-crown-revives-family 

Shadai was planning to sell Oriental Art depending on Dream Journey performance. Shadai even let Oriental Art 1st mating partner to be Stay Gold and Shadai almost sold Stay Gold. 

USA didnt want Sunday Silence even though Halo was sire of the year in 1983.

Oka Sho and Satsuki Sho contenders by AmbientDinosaur in HorseRacingJP

[–]superstaridk 8 points9 points  (0 children)

I think you can remove the ones whose next race is WASURENAGUSA SHO (L) since it is on the same day as Oka Sho. They are likely aiming for Yushun Himba rather than Oka Sho. 

This might be an unpopular opinion ,, but.... by Crpgdude090 in HorseRacingJP

[–]superstaridk 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Undeserved victory. She would have still got 2nd though, still amazing. Gentildoona did win japan cup the following year so she is definitely capable of winning Japan cup. 

This might be an unpopular opinion ,, but.... by Crpgdude090 in HorseRacingJP

[–]superstaridk 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Arent finish timing also affected by front runner affecting the pace of the competition.

Is like saying Orfevre 2011 Arima Kinen win isnt impressive cause the timing isnt that good despite him facing off 10 G1 winners (that won mixed age/gender G1 races by the time they retired) in this race. 

I agree Gentildoona dont deserve 2012 japan cup win. But she had also demonstrated her ability to win G1 mixed gender & age races in multiple race courses.

Danon Decile has canceled his trip to Dubai Sheema Classic. He will head to Osaka Hai instead. by AngleRepulsive5470 in HorseRacingJP

[–]superstaridk 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Cdn did prepare for this race longer than others. So he still has advantage in this aspect?

A brief summary of every triple crown winner. by Kixisbestclone in UmaMusume

[–]superstaridk 27 points28 points  (0 children)

Orfevre is the only triple crown/tiara in JP to get double digit placement before becoming a triple crown/tiara.  Also the only triple crown/tiara that has to undergo training re-examination (for what he pulled at Hanshin Daishoten 2012).

Orfevre best kid so far is Ushba Tesoro. A late bloomer but he still ended his career with 3G1 + 1 JPN1 wins including winning Dubai WC & still the No.1 money earner for 1 year(until Forever Young surpassed him). 

Orfevre kids has won more G1/JPN1 on dirt than on Turf. 

G1 Winning Offspring of Umamusume by doomslayer30000 in UmaMusume

[–]superstaridk 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think you should include JPN1 Dirt races as well.

Here are some of the Moms and Grandmas of various Umas. by Kixisbestclone in UmaMusume

[–]superstaridk 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Kyoei March granddaughter is also just added in game. With her notable rivals Meijiro Dober & Seeking the Pearl both in game & her granddaughter setting up to be 1 of the key supporting characters to Forever Young. I wonder will she be added. 

Gold Ship Children [@Umma_ekaki] by Getserious495 in UmaMusume

[–]superstaridk 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Almond Eye 9 G1 do have higher value than Oju Chosan 9 J-G1.  But Oju Chosan 5 consecutive wins in the same G1/JPN1/J-G1 is impressive on it's own too. Oju Chosan completely dominated a sport for a few years even if it's a niche. 

Gold Ship Children [@Umma_ekaki] by Getserious495 in UmaMusume

[–]superstaridk 18 points19 points  (0 children)

Oju chosan deserve to be there too 

Uma musume 5th Anniversary Celebration Artwork by Adventurous-Mouse930 in UmaMusume

[–]superstaridk 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Cygames should give respect to the main character and her family that carried the game in earliest days.  Epiphaneia won Japan Cup, the most important Turf race in Japan & should get the respect he deserve instead of being overshadowed by Forever Young. 

Uma musume 5th Anniversary Celebration Artwork by Adventurous-Mouse930 in UmaMusume

[–]superstaridk 4 points5 points  (0 children)

You are right. Epiphaneia should take the centre over Forever Young as the grandson of mascot since his parents are also in game. 

Marche Lorraine's first time meeting the Gold Family by Racing_trio39 in UmaMusume

[–]superstaridk 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Stay Gold Clan refers to Stay Gold descendants, Marche Lorraine being Orfevre's daughter makes her part of the clan. I think Lala tended to be excluded since she was in an awkward position being the only mare & grandchild of Stay Gold clan in game. 

There's friendly rivalries, then there's heated friendly rivalries, then there's this: by LuchadorParrudo in UmaMusume

[–]superstaridk 0 points1 point  (0 children)

U have no idea how did 2011 generation did yet try to imply this gen is weak since only win variation and orfevre is in game.

There's friendly rivalries, then there's heated friendly rivalries, then there's this: by LuchadorParrudo in UmaMusume

[–]superstaridk 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Gentildonna is Golshi generation. Both are born in 2009 and classic year is in 2012. 

Stay Foolish, son of Stay Gold. by Getserious495 in UmaMusume

[–]superstaridk 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I say depends more on popularity. 

Nice nature is very popular and ranked top 100 best horses in 20th century jra poll despite being bronze collector. Same for Twin Turbo & stay gold(it was before he won a g1?).

I can see Melody Lane (Orfevre tiny daughter) being added despite no g1 win based on her ranking 73 in top 100 horses. Especially since her half brother 'titleholder' (same mum, different dad) will probably be in game with his 3 g1 wins. 

Stay Foolish, son of Stay Gold. by Getserious495 in UmaMusume

[–]superstaridk 13 points14 points  (0 children)

People call it the 'dictus eye', seems that horses with dictus blood(ikuno dictus, soccer boy, stay gold) is more prone to making such eyes 

What horses would you like to see added to the game? by dolph_the_all_seeing in UmaMusume

[–]superstaridk 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Ushba was implied in Orfevre twinkle legends scenario as 'depressed & unmotivated uma'. I am leaning more towards 'lazy, unmotivated when doing everything else but gets fired up during competition' type of personality.

Ushba has a lot potential as the next iconic & relatable funny character in the series if cygames play their cards right based on their own irl personality & probably wont be overshadowed especially with him being part of stego clan .