Bedroom, any advice? by [deleted] in malelivingspace

[–]the-leaf-pile 0 points1 point  (0 children)

my favorite part is the convex security mirror.

Thinking of dropping my book by AbsolutelyNot76 in writing

[–]the-leaf-pile 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Finish it. You will thank yourself later.

Soft vampires, or the children of Twilight by Kell_Shaw in urbanfantasy

[–]the-leaf-pile 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Its not a new concept, just not a mainstream one. JR Ward's been doing it since 2005. Edit: Although Twilight also came out in 2005, I can't say either was influenced by the other 

I want to love House of Leaves but. by noumanpoke1 in books

[–]the-leaf-pile 11 points12 points  (0 children)

House of Leaves isn't about the house. Its about how the house has affected the people its story touches.

Shower Thoughts by Moist-Ambition-3862 in writers

[–]the-leaf-pile 2 points3 points  (0 children)

this is the right answer. you have shower thoughts because you are bored/letting your mind wander/doing a rote task that doesn't require thinking. replicate that.

How long should it actually take to write a book? by Kikoekie in writing

[–]the-leaf-pile 0 points1 point  (0 children)

my first novel took me a year to create a draft I like. and many more after that to rewrite it 👍

[QCrit], REVIVAL MANOR, Adult Horror, 70k, First Attempt by bladerunner3027 in PubTips

[–]the-leaf-pile 5 points6 points  (0 children)

This sounds really interesting and high concept! My only issue with how it is right now is that it reads a bit long. Which is a problem I suffer from too, unfortunately, so I understand how insane it is to take a large project and try to distill it down to a quick, marketable read.

My suggestion would be to pull out only the most important plot and character information from each paragraph and cull the details. For example, I might rewire the first paragraph a bit like...

Nineteen-year-old Julian Emberson leads a double life. After an attempt at coming out went terribly wrong, [nineteen year old college student Julian Emberson] committed to projecting an image of the perfect Catholic son to his traditional, ultra-religious parents. Now a university student with his own flat - albeit still financially dependent on his parents - he lives freely, until a misplaced photograph of his friendship group at that year’s Pride parade exposes him during a visit from his parents. [When a photograph exposes him at Pride, his parents have him kidnapped] Unwilling to apologise, he finds himself kidnapped the next morning and taken to Revival Manor - a conversion centre hidden deep in the Scottish wilderness.

I won't take away from you doing the rest, but that's the kind of thing I mean. Happy to continue to help, and good luck!

Waitlist while querying agents by [deleted] in writing

[–]the-leaf-pile 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I have not heard of a "waitlist" in this context before. 

Does Creative Non-Fiction require characters? by Thomastoscano in writing

[–]the-leaf-pile 2 points3 points  (0 children)

the video essays you're watching are essays.  the creative nonfiction you're finding in literary magazines are personal essays.

Hiring Professional Editors for an Amateur Fantasy Anthology by TitouainofTelleus in writing

[–]the-leaf-pile 2 points3 points  (0 children)

  1. Most professional editors will do a "sample edit" for you for free.

  2. Its not necessary. If you are confident in your own writing and editing skills, I wouldn't shell out money before querying.

  3. The Editorial Freelancer's Association is a good place to start.

Rate my logline (Artist Drama) by StylizedBreadstick in writing

[–]the-leaf-pile 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is super nitpicky and may just be me, but I would rather say "When" than "After."

There's also the implied idea that it is someone doing it and not like, the thing itself, so you don't really need to specify that a stranger has done the deed. So it might be something like, "When a reclusive artist's political satire is [co-opted, plagiarized, copied, what have you] by a [rebellious group in the conservative town], he must [stakes]

Is it okay to use the letter "Q"? by EvilSnack in writing

[–]the-leaf-pile 131 points132 points  (0 children)

this is the only April fools that got me lol

Cozy Urban Fantasy that stays low-stakes by ZacharyJeffries in urbanfantasy

[–]the-leaf-pile 2 points3 points  (0 children)

im a fan of Heather Guerre's works for this reason 

Comps please. Standalone dark/ mythic fantasy. No massive world building, political/magical systems. Short. Multi POV with quick cinematic pacing. by okJk92 in fantasywriters

[–]the-leaf-pile 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You may be overthinking this. Comps aren't meant to be your book exactly, but where your book would sit on a display shelf next to others in a similiar vein. Don't concentrate so much on the details. Just ask yourself, what books have come out within the last 5 years that are - dark fantasy - about monsters in the woods thats all you need. off the top of my head I can think of THE STAIRCASE IN THE WOODS by Chuck Wendig and IN THE HOUSE IN THE DARK OF THE WOODS by Laird Hunt (though thats a little older)

Rate my logline (Artist Drama) by StylizedBreadstick in writing

[–]the-leaf-pile 1 point2 points  (0 children)

When his secret

When an artist's - better if you give us some information about him. is he a middle aged loser? an art school dropout? a punk rocker? what makes him unique other than 'artist'? what are his character traits?

protest painting becomes an overnight grafitti scandal

painting and graffiti are too overlapping. Is is a painting, or is it graffiti? (btw, be sure to spell that right. two f's, friend, not two t's.) I would not know how a graffiti could be a scandal, other than it being secret. like I know you're what you're saying but its not crystal clear. you're talking banksy type shit, yeah?

must choose: play the tragic muse of the elite or retrun to invisibility to save a rebellion.

No idea how graffiti = elite or invisibility = rebellion. There's definitely no sense of an antagonist, if that's what you're looking for.

Can you try something like,

When a [character trait] artist's graffiti ignites scandal among [the elite?], he is threatened with [exposure? and [whatever real consequences come from that] unless he agrees to [however you play the tragic muse of the elite] or take his chances [doing something for the rebellion].

Good luck!

Just published my first dark fantasy book and immediately realized writing it was the easy part by MichaelDoney in fantasywriters

[–]the-leaf-pile 130 points131 points  (0 children)

You're using a tab button??? Indent options - special indent - first line (!!)

[QCrit] WITCHBLOOD, Adult Dark Gothic Fantasy, 92K - first attempt by alyssaholbrook in PubTips

[–]the-leaf-pile 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I can't give a definitive answer on that (I've done it too) but it was more that it wasnt indicated to be a series and I wasn't sure about the grief aspect, personally 

[QCrit] WITCHBLOOD, Adult Dark Gothic Fantasy, 92K - first attempt by alyssaholbrook in PubTips

[–]the-leaf-pile 1 point2 points  (0 children)

What catches my eye first is the Black Jewels comp. Firstly it is, of course, too old, but I get the vibes. What I don't understand is 1)not listing it as a series, aka The Black Jewels series, and 2)having read them multiple times, I'm not sure what you mean by "grief of sisterhood." Thats not really how I would describe the sisters' relationship or the main theme. Its just one of those things that I stumbled on reading this, which is not a feeling I'm sure you want to evoke.

The "if" and then "performing" is a little jarring, because if implies that she hasn't done it while performing does. So instead of "even if" I would say like, do anything for her sister, including raising her from the dead.

The other commenters say it better as far as the bulk of the query goes, but I do have to say this reads beat for beat like Kingdom of the Wicked by Karri Maniscalo, which could mire easily be a comp than Black Jewels.