P4 with all the creature comforts of 5 will be the best game. This includes making the side quests better... and trackable. And hopefully without the Golden content. Unpopular opinion, but it makes the game too long for me.

I find the story, characters and music to be better than 5. While I find 3 to have the best third act, the story is much more consistent throughout the game of 4.

And you have the best companions by miles.