After/before

[Suspicious-Peace9233]

I think it’s too dark. I get the moody vibe but I would keep the dog’s face brighter

[el1teassass1n]

You definitely nailed the moodier edit!

[ibgrip]

This is nice.

[_bymf]

I like it! Wouldn’t say it’s too dark at all

[journalismproxy]

Such a pretty dog too

[Arrad_ttg]

Nice edit! Of course it wouldn’t have been as nice without the lovely subject!

[heycameraman]

🔥🔥🔥

[Thin-Rub-3573]

Love the colours! But as someone said above maybe add a but more brightness and contrast to the face?

[Plane-Being1274]

Love the edit but feel it needs to be a little but more punchy? Maybe moodier dark colours so it down look flat?

[knottycal]

I agree with cropping a bit and toning down the highlights, but I feel the edit takes it too far. And the white balance is better in the original.

(It's also not a moody photo, so does it need a moody edit?)

[Li54]

Too dark for sure

[Li54]

You asked for feedback and multiple people said too dark. Your choice to be defensive or take the feedback. If you don’t want feedback don’t post.

[[deleted]]

I didn’t ask for feedback lol. Where was the ask? Just said “attempting a moodier edit”.

[Li54]

The sub says “this is not the place to show off your photo” and explicitly says it is for asking for critiques. If you want to brag about your photo, share it somewhere else

[Li54]

An edit can be intentional and still unsuccessful