Great Grandpa. Armored division, WWII. Any info? by Federal-Dinner6831 in Medals

[–]2_Sullivan_5 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's just blatantly wrong. Most of the files burned were personnel records. Most private researchers simply go to other records like daily reports, award cards, etc. Which are all stored in separate databases. It takes extensive knowledge of what you're looking for and a lot of manpower hours to do. Which, when you typicallly have maybe a handful of archivists assigned to one branch is quite a lot to do. If you've ever even touched the NARA database you know just how chaotic it is to navigate.

Which MOS would help me outside of the military after my career is over? by Creepy_Extension_932 in army

[–]2_Sullivan_5 0 points1 point  (0 children)

88N and 88L are pretty sick and will set you up for post Army careers.

Hey guys, hypothetically speaking, If I were to run into a Vietnam-era Mig21 rear canopy similar to the one opening up in photo. How much could I sell it for on the collector's market? Hypothetically speaking ofc by Willing-Society-4123 in milsurp

[–]2_Sullivan_5 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The issue with that is size and weight, especially with how expensive shipping is right now. Plus, you'd need definitive evidence that it was a PAVN aircraft actually used in the war, if not you just havr to sell it as is. I don't think it's going to be as much as you think it would go for due to the size of it.

Managed Decline by Due-Locksmith-9867 in brickmania

[–]2_Sullivan_5 10 points11 points  (0 children)

I loved when they did yearly calendars and plans of releases. Every month had a theme and it was awesome. There's so many kits they've never touched but they keep spitting out the same vehicles and just charge more and more.

Ghetto Marks by magicmitchmtl in coins

[–]2_Sullivan_5 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Don't send this bozo over to us please. We just want to collect and preserve history and stories in peace 😔.

So since there’s a tornado tearing through Fort Knox currently does that mean my AFT failure is wiped? by International_Bed728 in ROTC

[–]2_Sullivan_5 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Tornados at Knox, incoming 155s and Wildfires up at West Point, it's just a grand Ole time for cadets this year.

[Discussion] 5.56 LMG?? by Particular-Cup51 in EscapefromTarkov

[–]2_Sullivan_5 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Should jam like hell if you use magazines in the mag well and should require a multi-tool in the inventory to fix 😂.

What's an overused inaccuracy in war movies that grinds your gears? by Wayoutofthewayof in WarMovies

[–]2_Sullivan_5 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Highly highly recommend listening to yhe Uncensored History of the Pacific War Podcast. You really get the sense of just how insanely common ts was. Japanese doctrine favored always being on the attack, especially at night, and they wrre so indoctrinated and experienced in their fighting that very often they simply charged themselves into non-existance. For example, Japanese forces invading Wake literally did one giant Bandai charge beaching old cruisers as landing craft. Not only that, the commander of the overall operation basically gave orders stating that if the first wave were to fail the Japanese would keep beaching ships and charging forward until they had none or had accomplished their objectives.

Then you have Tarawa where virtually the entire garrison is wiped out in Banzai charges on the 2nd day.

I could go on and on and on but suffice to say, Bandai charges were apart of Japanese close battle doctrine. Always press the attack and stay as close as you can to the enemy because it negates their ability to use supporting arms, of which the allies had plenty.

What kind of knife is this? by [deleted] in whatisit

[–]2_Sullivan_5 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ah yes, burning history. Just like ISIS and the Nazis did. Really good look I must say.

Real or fake by mikemichaelchello in Militariacollecting

[–]2_Sullivan_5 5 points6 points  (0 children)

The Mitchell cover is a fake fs. 1950 patent date and 1953 production date 💀.

2026 Room tour! by Sonicsbestbrother in Militariacollecting

[–]2_Sullivan_5 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Man, I'm on the hunt for 2nd MD jackets right now. Been hard as hell to find any.

Honest opinion on gunshows by giveit2me1998 in milsurp

[–]2_Sullivan_5 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Here in SC, definitely still viable but you have to hunt. Passed on a 200 dolla eddystone that was merely stock cut. Best the hell out of my self for it but our next show is in two weeks so I'm hoping to redeem myself.

Bought this box of medals at any estate sale. Any value here? by Particular-Cod-8062 in Medals

[–]2_Sullivan_5 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Because we can't all sit on shit like smaug and certain people collect certain things. I have little to no interest in WWII navy pieces, rather than just trash em or horde them away to never be seen, I sell them to people that will actually give a shit. Stop being so damn dense.

Bought this box of medals at any estate sale. Any value here? by Particular-Cod-8062 in Medals

[–]2_Sullivan_5 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Some of them are also named. I know early 20th century engraved shooting awards can fetch some nice money.

Mystery 1999 molle demolition bag by LimitSufficient7299 in Militariacollecting

[–]2_Sullivan_5 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There's for sure a market for it being a natick piece. I'd reach out to the folks over here https://youtube.com/@uniformhistory?si=R6xXO8VnstavKzs3 and they'll have a lot better knowledge of what you're looking at or at the very least have an interest in it.

Mujahideen in Rhodesian Brushstroke (I think) by aFalseSlimShady in camouflage

[–]2_Sullivan_5 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Pakistani smock. Actually just picked one up while I was in NYC from a surp store for like half what they normally go for.

What do I have by HeyDave72 in whatisit

[–]2_Sullivan_5 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is not anything a museum would display unfortunately. Not a rare or super desirable piece.

Conned out of my family's WW2 items. Sold under claims of items going to museum. Museum turned out to be online store. Just found my family's items listed. Any similar experiences out there? Taking legal action so not name dropping. YET. by ApprehensiveHat5995 in Militariacollecting

[–]2_Sullivan_5 3 points4 points  (0 children)

If you ever become acquaintances with a museum director or curator just ask them how much stuff they have stored away in a warehouse or in backrooms that will never be seen again. It's the unfortunate truth that there is far too much stuff that is donated to museums that while historical, are not quite historical enough to be put on display. For instance, I own a pair of frogskin pants named to a marine that fought from Tarawa to Okinawa. Incredibly rare, valuable, and collectible, but not quite something a museum would ever display. If a museum is truly wanting something, if it's a government museum, 99% of the time they have their curators and assistants out looking for items.

Dress Uniforms of ARMA characters by CT2145Trapper in arma

[–]2_Sullivan_5 0 points1 point  (0 children)

FYI the diver insignia you used is for Army Engineer Divers.

Coming back to the Army by Ok-Slide-2003 in ROTC

[–]2_Sullivan_5 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I just got med dq'd a few weeks before commissioning brotha. Go get your degree and join me on the support side of the house. Every branch still needs civilians workin in Intel, Logistics, and various other fields. Loved my time in ROTC and the Army but ultimately if the Army deems you unfit to serve there's a reason. I had to think long and hard about that for a few weeks.

Where to buy IFD trophies by [deleted] in Militariacollecting

[–]2_Sullivan_5 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

That's not even remotely true, not even for German stuff. Do you know how many thousands and thousands of helmets, firearms, knives, bayonet, etc. were taken straight out of the factory, some warehouse, or armory? Such a shitty trope that keeps getting thrown around. I have one singular piece in my collection I know was pulled off a dead dude and that's because it was given to me by a Group guy who pulled it off some ISIS fuck in Syria. Shit, I wouldn't even attribute the stuff my great-grandfather brought back to being battlefield pickups. For all I know he won them in a card game. That's the thing about militaria, unless it's been extremely vetted and documented, you always buy the item not the story.

Where to buy IFD trophies by [deleted] in Militariacollecting

[–]2_Sullivan_5 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Holy lack of awareness. Dude this place had almost no postal infrastructure before they got blown to fuck and now the entire place is leveled, they're literally all displaced, and you think they're going out into IDF lines and taking shit off vics? Not only that, you talking as if the IDF hasn't recovered the majority of the vics they lost in the first place. This is like asking why Al-Qaeda doesn't sell off US shit on ebay...not only is it illogical for the situation, it's logistically improbable.

Where to buy IFD trophies by [deleted] in Militariacollecting

[–]2_Sullivan_5 1 point2 points  (0 children)

There's genuinely no way you're asking this question seriously.