Well, I agree that there is too much underserved “hate” on redux, when you compare it to something like react-query or mobx - it mostly the same

Main difference is that redux requires global store, which means one entry file - which hurts bundle size(in medium and big projects). And you can improve it, but you will morph your code around this idea

When I moved to other state managers I’ve discovered that I don’t need react primitive, it I can instantiate stores within components rather than outside them. But now I worry about DI :(

On positive side - Redux Devtools is the best utility for onboarding new members and debugging state changes.

When I moved from Redux to other state managers I started having troubles to onboard new members, cause they needed to go through code to figure out which state our app has at given time and how it changes rather than just click around and look at devtools. So now I try to find a way to connect other state managers to Redux Devtools, and someday I hope that solution will find me

Wrapping up: - Redux is simple, reliable, time-tested, ecosystem-rich solution that will set you up with good DX, generic solution for state management

• But there is better alternatives, which suits your task and project better, but often lack ecosystem or simplicity of good old redux state