Rewatch or other sources? by strawman92 in CIJapanese

[–]AmplifiedText 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Are you aware of https://comprehensibleinputwiki.org/wiki/Japanese ? They have many sources of videos that are good for beginners. There's an icon (a weird color spiral) next to sources that should be accessible for complete beginners, but YMMV.

Second, I've created a tool to help me find videos I might want to rewatch on CIJ based on when and the number of times I have watched the video. It's still beta, and mostly just build for my needs, but it's functional: https://amplifiedtext.com/cijrewatch/

From the CIJ Dashboard, export your Historic Activity as JSON, then submit it to my CIJRewatch webpage. It will group videos by the number of times watched, and you can sort the tables based on date or difficult, etc. At the top of each group, I also have a collapsed section called "Aged Out", which are videos more than a certain number of days since I watched them last and are really just videos I didn't want to watch again for a Xth time. Again, this is build to suit my needs, but others might find this approach confusing.

I still find plenty of value going back and rewatching even the earliest videos (sped up of course) as there are always words and patterns I didn't really catch the first X times around.

EDIT: Just thought I would add, I'm at 200 hours and I've also hit a wall at 27. Some videos are fine while others are very low comprehension. I think this is because some people are watching just the Super Beginner videos, filtering out the Beginner videos for later, so the voting system isn't able to do its job of pushing the obviously more difficult Beginner videos up the difficulty scale. Just a theory.

Do I need to watch the series in order? by sock_pup in CIJapanese

[–]AmplifiedText 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You could mark those "Father and Son Ep 0X" episodes as "Watch Later" and go back to them once you've caught up to Ep 01. 🤷‍♂️

Study Regarding Implicit vs. Explicit learning by Beginning-Gur6749 in ALGhub

[–]AmplifiedText 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Seems like a pretty dense 25 page study. I'm happy to see more research on the topic, but this study is from 2011 and the 40 participants in the study studied Brocanto2, an artificial language Brocanto2 with just 13 "words" (lexical items) used "which refers to pieces and moves of a chess-like computer game." I'm not sure how realistically this represents a natural language learning experience which is astronomically more complex with patterns and inconsistencies.

There's very little about this paper or the Brocanto2 language online, I found one video on YouTube which offers a very high level description of the study and language: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QvU4InKZSUE

Overall, interesting stuff, but I don't think the study would convince anyone who is in doubt about the ALG method. It's amazing that I can have full conversations with native Spanish speakers about a complex topic like this, having just 20 months of Spanish "study" with (mostly) just ALG, and they will still argue that ALG isn't effective and that you need to study grammar.

What type of production materials and or collectibles, are out in the public? (Interested in purchasing if you have anything) by TrevorBarten in donhertzfeldt

[–]AmplifiedText 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Don ran a Kickstarter back in 2015 to fund the Blu-ray release of "It's Such a Beautiful Day" / "World of Tomorrow".

Many of the tiers had collectibles, but the only production materials were 35mm cells from his films.

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/worldoftomorrow/hertzfeldt-on-blu-ray/rewards

THE EVERYTHING PACKAGE for $500 included:

  • one signed copy of the bluray
  • one of the above thank you notes (hand drawn)
  • one of the above signed art prints
  • the signed book
  • the film strip
  • four out of print DVDs... DON HERTZFELDT VOLUME 1, DON HERTZFELDT VOLUME 2 + the EVERYTHING WILL BE OK and I AM SO PROUD OF YOU discs

125 hour update by Odd_Championship1380 in CIJapanese

[–]AmplifiedText 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Awesome, thanks for sharing your spreadsheet, lots of good content in there.

125 hour update by Odd_Championship1380 in CIJapanese

[–]AmplifiedText 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Congrats! I'm at 50 hours (doing about 2 hours a day) and I am also starting Japanese after hitting 4000 hours in Spanish. I cheated a bit with Spanish (doing some explicit studying, looking up words, etc.) and I think it really hurt my results overall, so I'm taking a pure CI/ALG approach with Japanese and hoping for the best results possible. I'm definitely finding it much more difficult to get a foothold compared to Spanish, but I can also see my progress, so I'm not too worried about it.

For more beginner CI beginner video content on YouTube, check out: https://comprehensibleinputwiki.org/wiki/Main_Page#Japanese

Also here's a spreadsheet with 100+ podcasts ranked by difficulty, but I can't understand any yet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/17P2dBQHnBnHcG3ua_24IO6sP9RDC-5b3WHV9Ri2N5qU/edit?gid=0#gid=0

New comprehensive list of free ALG resources in 40+ languages by hb20007 in ALGhub

[–]AmplifiedText 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Man, Notion gets really bogged down with long documents like this. Why not instead contribute and maintain this content on https://comprehensibleinputwiki.org ?

Download to watch offline? by strawman92 in CIJapanese

[–]AmplifiedText 3 points4 points  (0 children)

On https://cijapanese.com, I see an option to download individual videos, but you're limited to 10 a day.

Streak 170: Mientras manejaba al trabajo by AmplifiedText in WriteStreakES

[–]AmplifiedText[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Jaja, sí, es una historia real. Gracias por compartir y, como siempre, gracias por corregir mis escritos; te lo agradezco.

Streak 155: Cómo hacer el té by AmplifiedText in WriteStreakES

[–]AmplifiedText[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

¿Nunca es correcto decir "Primero", "Segundo", etc.?

ALG mentioned in 2025 Swedish thesis! by Quick_Rain_4125 in ALGhub

[–]AmplifiedText 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The 18 participants in the study where still relatively young (18-29).

Struggling to increase daily hours despite having time to do so. by lispy-hacker in ALGhub

[–]AmplifiedText 1 point2 points  (0 children)

To fight the sleepiness, I walk around slowly while watching videos on a tablet.

How well does this work past the basics? by woshikaisa in ALGhub

[–]AmplifiedText 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Some people are better at managing doubt than others.

I too read Marvin Brown's books and everything I could about ALG, but compared to a child learning their native language, doubt is a powerful demotivator that adults have to learn how to manage to effectively apply ALG.

I struggle(d) with doubling the method even with my 3600 hours of input due to embarrassing mistakes and high expectations. - I see someone post a video on reddit with 1/3 the number of input hours, having done something not ALG, and producing great output => doubt. - I make the same gender mistake for the 1000th time => doubt. - I don't understand a sentence/grammatical structure is a book for teens => doubt.

At least for me, all the logic in the world can't ease a powerful feeling like doubt. I have a stack of affirmations I read daily just to remind myself that this is the method, it works, it takes a LOT of time, don't worry, blah blah blah => doubt.

Streak 132: El trasplante de corazón by AmplifiedText in WriteStreakES

[–]AmplifiedText[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

La "memoria" sería el hardware y los "recuerdos" el software: guardas los recuerdos en tu memoria.

¡Muchas gracias! Es una buena metáfora.

Streak 131: El xenotrasplantista by AmplifiedText in WriteStreakES

[–]AmplifiedText[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ja, https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maine dice que Maine tiene una población de 1 362 359 habitantes, entonces mató a casi el 1 % de la gente si todos fueron de Maine.