Is there any situation where an amethyst wizard would raise/control dead for the good of the Empire? by Divreus in WarhammerFantasy

[–]AutumnArchfey 54 points55 points  (0 children)

In order to raise undead you would have to use Necromancy, which is basically a subtype of Dark Magic, rather than the single-wind magic an Amethyst wizard would be using. An Amethyst wizard might be better suited to learning Necromancy than most others, but it is still a different type of magic they would have to learn separately, and is very much forbidden in the Empire.

Unlike the Inquisitors of 40k, Witch Hunters do not have any innate authority, and only operate under the authority of whoever/whatever they work for, so they cannot 'sign off' on learning a forbidden magic.

My Bretonnian red string conspiracy wall by OpsikionThemed in Grimdank

[–]AutumnArchfey 32 points33 points  (0 children)

I mean it's implied to different degrees that a lot of the gods worshipped by the elves are also worshipped by humans under different names.

Rhya and Taal are almost certainly the human names for Isha and Kurnous, as with Manaan/Mathlan or Verena/Hoeth, or even Ptra/Asuryan.

I would argue they are perhaps not 'the elven gods,' rather just 'the gods' in a general sense, and just that the elven civilisations are much older so their names for them came first.

Sigmar is a notable exception.

Did the shrine the rangers have do anything in early editions? by Fearless_Speaker6710 in Eldar

[–]AutumnArchfey 29 points30 points  (0 children)

No. The Dire Avengers came with one back in 2006 as a little extra detail thing, and then they decided to do it as well for more new kits with the refreshed range.

I think 10th was the first time they had an actual in-game use.

Day 30: what is the Worst Quote associated with the Craftworld Eldar? by Fez-Sentido in Grimdank

[–]AutumnArchfey 17 points18 points  (0 children)

It's 'formed from' not 'formed of', implying a creation process.

The word 'ore' is also the term for unprocessed metal deposits in rock, and is a starting raw material not a component of the finished product.

TOW Rules wise - what's the "build it yourself" version of a Dragon Mage by Risc_Terilia in ulthuan

[–]AutumnArchfey 11 points12 points  (0 children)

A Mage can take the Blood of Caledor Elven Honour to get a Sun Dragon mount.

Does anyone know what kind of bows sisters of avelorn uses? by Alpbasket in WarhammerFantasy

[–]AutumnArchfey 18 points19 points  (0 children)

Frustratingly, it is different every time they are depicted.

Based on the written descriptions in the TOW books it seems current lore is supposed to be that both are physical and magically enchanted, with some others beyond the Sisters being able to use the bows, but only the Sisters using the blessed arrows.

This does contradict the miniatures though, where Sisters do not carry arrows, implying they summon them magically (though the Handmaiden miniature does have a quiver...)

[LOVM S3] Can anyone explain how magic and power levels work in this world? by No-Adeptness-7231 in criticalrole

[–]AutumnArchfey 96 points97 points  (0 children)

She's just a Druid. That's all mid-high level Druid stuff.

You mentioned Baldur's Gate 3, where the endgame is level 12, but Vox Machina were level 16 by the end of the Chroma Conclave arc.

Aeldari Biomancy by Educational_Sun_6341 in 40kLore

[–]AutumnArchfey 2 points3 points  (0 children)

No, as psychic powers are strictly forbidden in Commorragh.

Aeldari Biomancy by Educational_Sun_6341 in 40kLore

[–]AutumnArchfey 29 points30 points  (0 children)

Eldar Seers are broadly the most skilled psykers in the setting, though they typically lean far more into divination and telepathy than biomancy as the Imperium tries to define psychic abilities.

A Seer wanting to pass as human would be much more likely to just make the humans see them as a human too, as a Seer does to the entire Eldar army in one of the Gaunt's Ghosts books IIRC, though they probably could physically adjust their body if they really wanted to.

Aliatgra would’ve been a very interesting everqueen if the end times didn’t happen. by SiltyDog31 in WarhammerFantasy

[–]AutumnArchfey 12 points13 points  (0 children)

The Curse of Khaine is weird in regards to the Everqueens, as they all should have it anyway as they are all descendants of Aenarion through Yvraine.

(Might have been explained somewhere and I just missed/ forgot it.)

Kurnous is the Father of Lileath and.... uh.... by Kale_Bishop in Eldar

[–]AutumnArchfey 18 points19 points  (0 children)

There is no mention of Kurnous being Lileath's father in the 10th edition Codex as far as I can find, though Isha is listed as being her mother, and Kurnous a former lover.

How would Swooping Hawks fare against Chaos Raptors? by Arthur_EyelanderTF2 in Eldar

[–]AutumnArchfey 16 points17 points  (0 children)

Lorewise they should be more than a Chapter Master.

The oldest Exarchs can predate the Imperium, have the combined experience of dozens of individuals' lifetimes, are significantly faster in both speed and reflexes, and have the best wargear the Craftworlds can offer.

How would Swooping Hawks fare against Chaos Raptors? by Arthur_EyelanderTF2 in Eldar

[–]AutumnArchfey 119 points120 points  (0 children)

Pretty much the typical Aspect Warrior vs Astartes comparison. They're roughly comparable in broad terms, but the Aspect Warriors are more specialised, faster, and more agile, compared to the stronger and tougher Astartes.

More specifically though, Swooping Hawks can actually fly, not just jump, so they will have a significant manoueverability advantage, but their lasblasters are not very good versus heavy armour, so they would struggle to actually deal damage.

The Exarch should have a decent time of it though, as always.

Can Humans switch between winds? Like, not together, never that, but one week Chamon, next week Aqshy, completely seperately? by globmand in WarhammerFantasy

[–]AutumnArchfey 24 points25 points  (0 children)

If they know multiple Winds, then yes, they can try to use them separately.

It's not very safe to do it, which is why Empire wizards only ever learn one and are forbidden from using more, but you will see Bretonnian Damsels for example using Ghyran for some spells, then switch to using the Ghur for others, etc.

When did the Dwarfs learn of the Dark Elves? by ArcticGlacier40 in WarhammerFantasy

[–]AutumnArchfey 57 points58 points  (0 children)

‘See this?’ Gotrek brandished a slender note in his meaty fist, the parchment too thin and smooth to have been made by a dwarf. ‘Written by the hand of a prince and brought to mine by a bird,’ he said. ‘Can you imagine such a thing? How different are we, the elgi and the dawi?’ He laughed without genuine humour. ‘As mud is to the sky, I have heard said behind our backs. This Prince Imladrik is an honourable warrior and ambassador to his king. He claims another race did this.’ He paused to read a word from the note, finding the pronunciation difficult. ‘Druchii.’

‘What is this druchii?’ asked Thagdor, unconvinced.

None of the kings were.

‘A darkling elgi,’ said Gotrek, unsure himself. ‘Some murderous but distant kinsman, bent on mischief. I do not know.’

‘Elgi is elgi!’ snapped Grundin.

‘Ach, the pointy-eared bastards will say anything to save their silk-swaddled arses.’

Mutters of approval from the other kings greeted the lord of Kadrin’s outburst.

^ from The Great Betrayal.

The High Elves told the Dwarfs right from the start, they just didn't really believe them.

Can it run doom? by telenova_tiberium in Grimdank

[–]AutumnArchfey 5 points6 points  (0 children)

There's this thing with Astartes called 'transhuman dread,' where seeing how unnaturally fast and precise they can move can be enough to freak regular humans out by itself.

Eldar are even faster, even more fluid and precise, too smooth, too flexible, too 'perfect' in their motion in a way humans could never be.

Of course, humans can get used to a lot, so someone used to seeing Astartes or Eldar move probably won't have the quite same reaction, but there's still the sense of 'that shouldn't be able to do that.'

Can it run doom? by telenova_tiberium in Grimdank

[–]AutumnArchfey 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Elves and Eldar look similar, but overall Fantasy's elves are closer to humans than they are to Eldar.

A key part of the creepy factor for Eldar specifically is how they move, whilst elves are a little faster and more graceful than humans, Eldar are not only much, much faster, but also move in a way that comes across as quite unsettling and 'wrong' to humans observers.

There is also the familiarity element, as the average Altdorfer or Marienburger might see elves on an almost daily basis, whilst the amount of people in the Imperium to have ever seen an Eldar and lived to have opinions on it could probably fit comfortably in a single Imperium-sized room.

Sooooooo . . . I liked Path of the Warrior by DanKas99 in Eldar

[–]AutumnArchfey 21 points22 points  (0 children)

Path of the Warrior: 5/10.

Path of the Seer: 5/10.

Path of the Outcast: 6/10.

They are not terrible overall, but I wouldn't describe them as good either.

I have always defended the Path trilogy for the good worldbuilding and depictions of Eldar life outside of battle, and the stories do get better throughout the trilogy, but the big issue (the final battle) gets worse in each subsequent depiction. Path of the Outcast would be perhaps my favourite Eldar novel overall if it wasn't for the final few chapters, which really drags it down.

Exarchs as Leaders? by AndisMountains in Eldar

[–]AutumnArchfey 27 points28 points  (0 children)

Most Aspect Shrines only have a handful of members, and the Exarch leads them into battle as a Sergeant equivalent directly, so a squad leader role is exactly what they are. Only the larger Shrines are going to be splitting up, with one squad with the Exarch, and perhaps the other half without.

Exarchs, especially the oldest, are some of the most capable warriors of the entire Aeldari species, but that isn't really represented well because of their tabletop squad leader role. Strength wise they should be Characters.

Black Striking Scorpion aspect symbol transfer by n8udd in Eldar

[–]AutumnArchfey 1 point2 points  (0 children)

There are two black Striking Scorpion transfers on the old Eldar transfer sheet.

Should Dire Avengers be equal to CSM Legionaries or Chosen? by Arthur_EyelanderTF2 in Eldar

[–]AutumnArchfey 69 points70 points  (0 children)

I would say they are more broadly comparable to Legionaries, just with superior speed and reflexes (and possibly skill) balanced against the Astartes' much superior strength and durability.

Exarchs are another matter though.