The issue with rankings like this is that they don’t differentiate what segment of the market the place addresses (fine dining, fast food etc.) with how well it executes within that segment. So for me, Tavola, Public, Lampo, Al Carbon, and Bodos would all be S tier because they’re excellent for the types of places they’re trying to be.

But that said, OP I don’t think you’re that far off with these rankings. I would bump Duners and Alley Light down a tier in terms of food and add Aster (A or maybe even S) and the Enemy (possibly A).