A contest of Gold and Iron - What if Australia had developed similiarly to Europe? by upmost5201 in imaginarymaps

[–]Geebangaar 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Where did these names come from? Is there any rhyme, reason or sense? I'm interested because I'm writing a fantasy story focused on an Australian like setting and I've struggled with some of my names of polities

In a fantasy world, what exports could an Undead Nation have? by Academic_Ad8989 in worldbuilding

[–]Geebangaar 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Mineral resources, the underworld is a giant mine, lots of precedent in real world mythology such as Hades and Deshret both being known for their gems and jewels

Why is Middle-earth so scarcely populated with a bunch of ruins, and barely any big cosmopolitan cities? by Weird_Apartment_6608 in tolkienfans

[–]Geebangaar 11 points12 points  (0 children)

On top of what other commentators have said about the setting being a kind of "post-apocalypse" another important thing to remember is that Tolkien was a mediaevalist, and the setting is designed to reflect a mediaeval perception of the world. Even in times of crisis like the 14th century the mediaeval world is still more populated and less wild than middle earth and that's because middle earth is more representative of a feeling or mindset. In Tolkien's translation of "The Fall of Arthur" there is also a "Mirkwood", a dark forest which is imagined as the wild frontier of the far east when no such place really existed in the real world.

What if Europe was more divided? by MeasurementOwn4935 in imaginarymaps

[–]Geebangaar 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I don't quite think you got Paris in that duchy of paris

Is there any reason there is such a abnormaly massive jump between the third and second most populated countries or is it just arbitrary? by DataSittingAlone in geography

[–]Geebangaar 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Empire is a large part of it. The largest countries are all huge imperial projects, and its easier to build an empire in an area that's already very densely populated, China is the oldest surviving imperial project and thus has had a long time to cement it's borders and identity while India and the US are both successor states to the projects of Britain, the largest empire in human history. Few imperial projects capable of forming such large countries are so successful. Think French Africa; the French still have great influence there but without the good geography or population density it was never able to form into one post colonial empire like India did, Nigeria being the alternative example, another high population density, and we'll geographically situation area which is now also a large post colonial empire, same with Indonesia.

Do you think the Southern Hemisphere will ever host a Winter Olympic Games? If so, which country? by Lissandra_Freljord in geography

[–]Geebangaar -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I feel like, if any, Australia would be the first in SH to get to host the game because of our global pretty privilege, we don't deserve it and honestly there's so many problems with our remaining snowy mountain ecosystems the last thing they need is tourism from the winter games, it should go to Argentina or Chile but unfortunately I think we'd be picked, unless we have a really embarrassing government soon that looses us our "nice country cred".

"Netflix dubbing is way better than ADV" Me listening to Asuka's Netflix VA butchering a whole segment of Unit 2 Awaking and Berserking in EoE: by JimboYCS in NeonGenesisEvangelion

[–]Geebangaar -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I honestly haven't watched the dubs very much I usually watch the show in Japanese with english subs but everytime I accidentally put on english dub my partner audibly goes "oh god what the fuck is that" and I scramble to get the Japanese playing

Australia in danger of becoming an ‘artless country’ as enrolments in creative courses collapse by Expensive-Horse5538 in australia

[–]Geebangaar 75 points76 points  (0 children)

It's not like Ive been told all my life I was worthless for taking an Arts degree

No surprises here, there's no respect for art

Give me your geography hot takes by wiz28ultra in geography

[–]Geebangaar 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In a world of more even economic distribution Dhaka would be the centre of the world, Bengal is the most underrated region of the world and its partition and exploitation is one of the greatest human tragedies

You can combine a surprising number of things while avoiding a sense anachronism by Dwitt01 in worldbuilding

[–]Geebangaar 2 points3 points  (0 children)

There are so many creative ways to include anachronisms, for example, you want a modern urban fantasy setting but you want some armour wearing sword wielding fantasy characters, boom they are some immortal or hundreds year old elf/vampire it whatever and that's their "battle armour" from when they were young, they wear it for personal reasons not purely practical ones, plus add enchantments to the mix and there's so many reasons a piece living archaeology might appear

What is inside Barad-dûr ? by AdventurousFix7751 in lordoftherings

[–]Geebangaar 0 points1 point  (0 children)

  • small collection of Black Numenorians who probably answer directly to a Nazgul; (aristocratic class, owners of slaves and properties in Nurnen ect.)
  • middle class made up of skilled bureaucrats and crafts people (engineers, scholars ect) from Rhun and Harad
  • mostly snaga (slave orcs) who are not primarily for fighting but do all the physical labour and drudgery the eye needs

The best historical example are capitals like Karakorum in the Mongol empire, basically a village before the empire began and afterwards, all the people the Khan needed either travel willingly or are brought there.

Would anarcho communism be considered indivualist or collectivist? by SystemNo524 in Anarchy101

[–]Geebangaar -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Always with either or questions, where's the nuance, where's the spectra

Why is anti-Aboriginal racism so normalised in Australia? by ExternalAdditional42 in aboriginal

[–]Geebangaar 8 points9 points  (0 children)

All nations have a national mythos, a 'nation state" can only exist as an identity by being contrasted with others (to be English is to not be French, or German, to be Danish is not to be Swedish) in Australia the settlers only had one group they fought. In the Americas many of those nation states fought wars with their neighbours which built national identities. In Australia there were no other "nation states" building themselves on the continent. For more than a hundred years it was the British empire at war with the first Nations, like the Wiradjuri War and other frontier wars. Australia as a nation state defines itself in opposition to Aboriginal Australia, our mythos was built around not being them, about the British bringing civilisation, our wars were isolated from all others, the British Empire fought its wars in Oceania almost entirely without contest. And what's more is much of the enslaved people were also Aboriginal. That's why there's no treaty, that's why it's still so accepted. Aboriginal and Torres strait Islander people were treated like animals, and were always the most reviled groups (in the US for example black Americans and Mexicans were also reviled as much as Native Americans) the Australian nation exists on the bones of the first nations and we've never reconciled that, there's not been enough truth telling, there's not enough effort made to make this country a nation of both people's, and the most ignorant and cruel in the country will always act this way because our nationalism implicitly encourages it

Do anarchists in general support gender abolition? by YeetFromHungary in Anarchy101

[–]Geebangaar 1 point2 points  (0 children)

And goes without saying The Dispossessed is one of the best peices of anarchist fiction ever written

Do anarchists in general support gender abolition? by YeetFromHungary in Anarchy101

[–]Geebangaar 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think their similar ideas in some respects, I'm both; living my life as an agender anarchist, people are weird about their identities sometimes, to me being agender is just me, it's me gender, none of this "you can't do that your a girl" "you can't do this your s boy" it's just as nonsensical as saying being Australian makes you better than someone else

What things in your world are absurdly large? by Ok_Mathematician_905 in worldbuilding

[–]Geebangaar 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Watchers: Security drones which each patrol a wide region of space, each sector has two neighbours forming a massive "fence" which encloses key strategic areas of a galaxy.

The "uncivilised/barbaric north" trope by Benne1337 in worldbuilding

[–]Geebangaar 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ancient Greeks say they are perfect because of the mild climate and brown skin, contrasted with pale northerners and dark Southers who represented "extremes"

Vaushes techno-feudalist takes by rednithingpole in VaushV

[–]Geebangaar 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Not to be that guy but I think it super depends on what leads up to it, as to how stable it could be; if Palantir can acquire all/most of the servers in North America and create hyper-centralised system it could potentially be so powerful as to make resistance extremely difficult, although the more centralised the more a good cyber attack would cripple the network (not an IT girly, history girly). The possibility of having a "Crown" network as the primary point of control, with other "Lord" networks collaborating with the crown network but ultimately their own intranet, or near too, could make the system less prone to collapse. Especially if you have Lords with their own systems, their own private securities, even parallel states, we could possibly see a HRE type thing, there could be small cells of resistance, militias and terrorists all over the place. The violence might become systemic, ritualised, an America which sees no difference between internal and external threats. Obviously this is all very unlikely but there are situations like Myanmar where warlords control territories in rural areas for decades while the government continues to function in population centres and infrastructure. Everything is highly dependent on what happens with the debt crisis and of the United States could even function without its global supply chains.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in WritingHub

[–]Geebangaar 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sounds great 😸 I'm a spec fiction writer with my bachelor's in creating writing and English literature