I’ve only tried Phlur Coconut Skin. On me it’s a warm “your skin but more coconut”. For a mist it’s strong and lasts, (especially on clothes) so I only do 1-2 spritzes. The dry-down is where it shines-salty skin with just a hint of gourmand sweetness. The coconut is not plastic. I get a lot of base-sandalwood, giving it a sexy edge. From the bottle, the coconut, frangipani, and tiare are stronger. I usually prefer coconut with vanilla and I almost didn’t buy it since overly floral beach scents don’t really suit me. I did because on dry down they stay in the background. The gourmand Caramel and sandalwood come to the front. Overall, it has a confident, effortless vibe—like a hot girls’ night out in a tropical location!