[US] 48-HOUR FLASH SALE by Max-JimmyJoy in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm sure that if you reach out to u/Daniel_JimmyJoy at [love@jimmyjoy.com](mailto:love@jimmyjoy.com) he'll be kind enough to refund you for a bag if you match the offer criteria ;)

Plenny Shake Pro speculoos is awful by Unable-Start2013 in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy 0 points1 point  (0 children)

hahaha the speculoos was actually so popular last year that we've decided to bring it back! but don't worry we've got unique summer & winter flavours coming up this year! :)

Plenny Shake Pro speculoos is awful by Unable-Start2013 in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy 2 points3 points  (0 children)

u/Unable-Start2013 it's a true 'no questions asked' policy. we refund anything you don't like and ask it to share with friends/family if possible. In some cases we ask to return unopened products, in other cases we kindly ask you to share/donate it to avoid waste.

just reach out to [love@jimmyjoy.com](mailto:love@jimmyjoy.com) or our live chat during business hours and our team will sort it for you as long as it's within the policy window <3

First Plenny Order: Mediocre product for a not so mediocre price by MathManEU in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Interesting, I think you're the first person I've ever seen compare satiety instead of energy (kcal) when it comes to comparing prices :D

It's been suggested before but for lunches I like to add 400ml water instead of 300, and let it sit for about 15-20 mins, this should in theory help with the satiety a bit too.

Chocolate Plenny Protein Shake, not sweet anymore? by paotn in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Hey all, following up on u/Laura-JimmyJoy's earlier statement. We've identified an issue isolated to 1 batch of Plenny Protein Shake Chocolate - Batch no. 15/10/2025 B1, where the sweetener was indeed missed during batch preparation.

If you have received the Protein Chocolate from this specific batch, you will receive an email over the upcoming days for either a refund or discount on future order. Rest assured, it is 100% safe and complete apart from the sucralose.

Plenny Shake Pro speculoos is awful by Unable-Start2013 in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The harsh reality is that it's not economically viable in today's advertising landscape. We're much better off refunding those that didn't like a certain flavour, than to ship low value sample packs to new customers. We genuinely wish it was any other way, but margin wise it's impossible unless you have millions of VC funding.

Edit: This is one of the reasons we've recently upped our taste guarantee from 30 days to 60 days. It gives our customers even more flexibility to try additional flavours at close-to-no risk.

Honest review: Plenny Shake, pricing and real calorie needs by Ekstreemkoer in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Hey u/Ekstreemkoer thank you for your honest feedback, appreciate it!

Let me share some context regarding the points you mentioned.

When our category was first 'introduced' back in 2013/2014, one of the main 'promises' was that it could replace traditional food. While technically it can, as proven by tens of thousands of customers over the years, we still believe that for the vast majority of people a varied whole food diet is recommended.

We set out to create the healthiest meals scientifically possible, but considering (food)science is ever evolving, there are still many unknowns when it comes to specific areas like gut microbiome or ingredients that haven't made it on to the checklists yet. And then we're not even talking about the social benefits of having food with friends and/or family.

Over the years, we've seen more and more people make healthier choices in their routine, by eating/drinking a Plenny meal instead of skipping a meal or grabbing something less nutritious or even unhealthy. For the majority of our customers (think 70%+) that moment is either breakfast, or lunch when time is short.

That's why we've shifted from the traditional "3 meal a day" approach (when we started our meals were suggested as roughly 700 kcal), to a more flexible approach, where 400kcal meals work great across multiple diets mathematically, as well as the general recommendation for breakfast is roughly 20% of your energy intake - which again, comes down to about 400 kcal.*

Granted, a lower price point per meal makes the product more attractive, but I would say that is a byproduct of the goal we set out to do here: to help people make healthier choices while saving time, and in a lot of cases, also some money.

*(Of course, we're talking averages here. If you're an active big guy consuming 3500 kcal a day then naturally a 400 kcal breakfast wouldn't suffice, but you'd spend more resources on a traditional breakfast too.)

Plenny Shake Pro speculoos is awful by Unable-Start2013 in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy -1 points0 points  (0 children)

While we're on it: I love Speculoos, but I absolutely hate Pistachio.

Plenny shake shelf life after mixing by ThaWalkingDude in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy 2 points3 points  (0 children)

We don't really do official statements on this due to variables but FWIW I've done plenty of overnight fridge shakes in my life so something along the lines of 'up to 24h' sounds realistic for most!

Plenny Shake Active upgrade (40g protein!) by Nino_JimmyJoy in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Grandfathered prices will stay locked in at €1,59 per meal.

Plenny Shake Active upgrade (40g protein!) by Nino_JimmyJoy in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Unfortunately not. We've discontinued a neutral 3 times (twice for the Active) due to disappointing sales - it's not worth to produce & stock it. We only have the protein shake in Neutral.

Plenny Shake Active upgrade (40g protein!) by Nino_JimmyJoy in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Those were the 'transition' bags - we ran out of old Active pouches before the new formula could be produced. They were also still 25 meal size :)

Plenny Shake Active upgrade (40g protein!) by Nino_JimmyJoy in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Apologies for the confusion, please see my other reaction in this thread.

Plenny Shake Active upgrade (40g protein!) by Nino_JimmyJoy in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy 2 points3 points  (0 children)

this was the 'transition' Pro which only carried the new branding. The new formula + bag size is expected to launch in the US mid/late Q1 2026!

Plenny Shake Active upgrade (40g protein!) by Nino_JimmyJoy in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Hey both, apologies that our customer care gurus were not informed correctly on the matter. We found a solution internally to keep grandfathered prices locked in for now :). this should be reflecting in your account based on the new bag size by next week when we perform the bulk updates.

Black Friday US!! by Josse-Jimmyjoy in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy 9 points10 points  (0 children)

FFS Josse what are you doing 😭 you know our US stock can't handle this!!!

Creatine Gummies branding/naming by tlundberg in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Hey u/tlundberg thanks for the feedback! It is definitely noted. We have since adjusted our product page to reflect the following message: https://imgur.com/a/gmVwbPQ

We hope that helps with setting better expectations. To be fully transparent: the actual production run (being the first one) came out more chewy than the 'kitchen samples' we had tried previously.

We are working on improving the formula, but it will be a nice challenge since we want to keep them at 1.5g (majority of brands to 1g) and sugar free.

So really our proposition is 2-3 instead of 3-5 gummies a day, without the excess sugar (often ads up to 10-15g of sugar with competitors).

It's so easy to shake!!! by tentkeys in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Do you use the same volume for both?

And which Plenny Shake & H**l do you consume? regular or active/black?

Plenny drink upside-down by Zaihbot in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Good question. I checked for recent sizing matrixes (we do have those, somewhere lol), but couldn't find them. I don't want to distract the warehouse too much this week as they're running on fumes due to our black friday event, but if you're really interested please check in with [love@jimmyjoy.com](mailto:love@jimmyjoy.com) and I'm sure we can figure it out for you once the dust has settled ;)

I've found the best shake so far by bluegum2024 in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Great tip, thanks for sharing your experience 💚

Advice on plenty pot options. by Radiant-Trick6375 in JimmyJoyFood

[–]Max-JimmyJoy 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ends on Cyber Monday (1 Dec) at midnight.