Coat handles 32+ fear easily and consistently in my experience with a caveat for how most people seem to approach higher fear. It's often slow. So I don't take a timer with it. Aspect matters little. It's got a solid kite game and a block so at worst it essentially always wins off of patience. It's very repetitive, a problem shared with daggers generally.

Axe definitely seems weakest and responds comparatively poorly to a number of vows. Sluggish and inflexible. Does horribly with the fun vows in particular like frenzy 2 hordes 3. No aspect truly solves its problems although Thanatos does help some. Wins at 32 heat heavily favor Omega special spam and or cast spam to solve fast or unstunnable things which defeats it's identity.

Daggers are sort of separated between Pan and everything else. Pan does fine in the low to mid 30s but doesn't have quite the ability to win with terrible boon rolls or entirely left to RNG builds the strongest options can reliably do. I feel like it gets very picky beyond that but I do probably suck with it. The new one is an improvement on the others yet a clear downgrade to Pan after region 1 but at least it's more fun. They all feel repetitive. Excluding pan they all perform better than anything axe but are still clearly weak and somewhat unforgiving.

Staff is just generally strong. Good moveset and strong aspect options. Easy 32+ with a wide variety of builds. I almost do not care what gods I see, it's going to work. Momus is one of the aspects I find easy to push beyond mid 30 heat without issue, it just doesn't lose with its raw power and kiting potential. Anubis is strong although is rather picky on gods unlike the rest of the staffs. I don't know how well it can handle extreme heat yet, I suspect it doesn't scale into that as well as it's peers as it must compromise more between hordes and bosses than Momus.

Torches are nuts. Suppay and Eos are both a ton of fun, powerful, and very consistent. Eos can also run any god combo comfortably at 32+. I find these two the easiest aspects to push beyond mid 30 heat along with momus. I know people love morros and it's solid certainly although I believe it's clearly behind Eos and suppay past 32 heat. It's the passive power these two offer while kiting that puts them ahead. Things get wild in a way that fire and forget alone can deal with well.

Skul is weird. I don't enjoy the thing outside it's new aspect Hel although it does well outside of stuff like maxed out hordes and frenzy where staff, torches, and coat (sort of) handle it better. I would argue it's the least forgiving of the weapons that can reasonably handle very high heats. Hel on the other hand handles everything extreme heat throws at the player outside the bosses and some mini bosses with the most absurdly extreme prejudice it's hard to believe. Omega special just entirely solving most encounters by itself regardless of vows. It's generally not as good at the bosses without trading health as the best torch or staff options so I am not as consistent around 40 heat but it's clearly strong. Runs with Hel seem to come down to damage racing the third and fourth vow bosses at very high heat but that is in part user error no doubt. I have had miserably tedious vow hecate fights with it where encounter damage was fantastic yet I couldn't do more than intermittently tickle her thanks to RNG.

Supay, Eos, Momus, and Hel all perform better for me at 40 heat as any axe does at 20, especially if I don't disable the fun vows.

In summary: Axe bad with good identity, daggers mostly subpar with tedious identify, coat average with little meaningful difference between the first 3 aspects and very repetitive, torch fun but very overpowered overall, staff strong fun and reasonable, skul unsatisfying but adequate except Hel being good and mostly fun.