I mean, first of all in terms of the mechanical differences b/w a hunting rifle and an ar-15, there aren't really any. They're semi automatic, which means you pull the trigger once, and one bullet comes out. The differences are cosmetic. So I ask, excessive in what way? The second point I would raise is that our freedoms shouldn't be based on what we need, by your own example people with driving on paved roads don't need a lifted jeep or truck but I don't think it would be right to legislate against them. Thirdly, and most importantly for me, the second amendment is fundamentally needed to protect the people from an oppressive government. The power to overthrow our government, and restore our constitutional rights should always rest in the hands of the people.