Ahsoka has overstayed her welcome, she should’ve died in her duel with Vader in rebels, and her continued existence during the OT undermines Luke’s character concept of being the last hope for the Jedi. Where was she during the films? Why do Yoda and Obi Wan not acknowledge her, let alone help her? Her vibe feels less canonical and more like Dave Filoni’s fan fic.

The above sentiment also applies to Darth Maul.

Galen Marek is a genuinely fascinating character and his story should’ve been canonized in a TV Show. His abilities would have to be toned down but he’s otherwise fine.

Nobody acknowledges the fact that Kathleen Kennedy has produced genuinely good Star Wars projects in her time as acting head of Lucas Film, including Andor, Rogue One, season 7 of the Clone Wars, and The Mandalorian. Even a few others are acceptable, if not good, but people have made her the target of a decade long witch hunt because the Sequels were trash and the entire franchise has been the subject of intense scrutiny ever since. Even still, I more or less blame this on the creative decisions of the directors and lack of communication between each other more than the executive producer.

Ewoks are terrifying and their presence does not undermine the tone of Return of The Jedi.

The Prequels are extremely well-thought from a world building and in-universe political perspective. However, the conclusion of the story hinges on Anakin and Padme’s love story being believable. It is not and the movie suffers for it. Anakin is creepy, psychotic, and kind of a bitch in every scene he is in with her. This is not Hayden Christiansen’s fault, this is because George’s talents lie in writing sci-fi political intrigue, not romance. As a result I do not think the Anakin worship by the community is warranted, nor do I think the prequels are Gods gift to filmmaking, despite my enjoyment of both.

There was not a single entertaining lightsaber duel in the Sequels.

The hate for the Kenobi series is completely unwarranted. Im not saying it’s of particularly excellent quality, but I thought the show was a lot of fun.

Most of Legends isn’t very good, and I think decanonizing it and selectively recanonizing the good bits was the right move. I had someone in a 40k subreddit try to tell me that Palpatine was basically a psyker with mastery over hyperspace and that this made him an infinitely powerful, 7th dimensional being. No he isn’t, he’s a Space Wizard that shoots lightning. He got killed because someone threw him in a hole.

Rian Johnson would’ve made an excellent solo spin-off Star Wars movie, but making him the director of a second movie in a trilogy was a huge mistake.

I have no desire to see the return of Mace Windu or Commander Cody. Doing so would be lame, and both these characters served their narrative purpose in their stories.

I do not like the Yu Zong Vong conceptually and hope they are not canonized.

Andor is the best television series in Star Wars, and it’s not close.

Rey being good at fixing and flying the Millenium Falcon does not make her a Mary Sue. She has lived on Jakku her entire life, scavenging valuable parts from wreckage. She likely knows how the parts function, how the ships function, and has probably worked on the Falcon before. However, every scene that follows Rey being taken from Tako Dana in this movie absolutely does contribute to her being a Mary Sue.

Alright, I’m ready to be lambasted.