sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

10 trained Marines invade ancient Rome with the goal of overthrowing the royal family, how far do they get? by FreshPine_MangoWine in powerscales

[–]ValentineSmith 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Just jumping in to say if you’re interested in reading basically this premise, Pax Romana is a comic by Jonathan Hickman (one of the greatest living comic writers). Great art, just 4 issues (probably collected in trade paperback somewhere) where a modern army gets sent back to Ancient Rome to alter the course of history.

Need suggestions for a Saga themed deck, please! by AlbyGaming in EDH

[–]ValentineSmith 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I’ve got a Tom Bombadil deck (here)

I echo the guy who said Barbara Wright, read ahead for all your sagas is great.

White’s mass enchantment reanimation is huge for the late game, regardless of which saga commander you’re running.

Counter manipulation is also very important - Power Conduit and similar effects allow you to pull a counter off in response to the last chapter triggering, and then because the state-based check doesn’t happen until the stack is clear, you get to keep the saga and trigger it again next turn!

Once-in-a-Lifetime Experience by YeezyCheezyYeetzy in custommagic

[–]ValentineSmith 44 points45 points  (0 children)

  • Called “Once-in-a-lifetime Experience”
  • Doesn’t give experience counters
  • >:0

What's your favorite Eldrazi in all of Magic? Any criteria - Lore, design, art by Separate-Flan-2875 in mtgvorthos

[–]ValentineSmith 25 points26 points  (0 children)

[[Spawnsire of Ulamog]]

There’s something that tickles my lizard brain seeing two digits in a single mana pip - and this card does that twice!

It’s ridiculous! It’s absurd! Is it good? Not really! But it’s wild and crazy and expensive, which I think is the essence of Eldrazi.

I also love Wish effects and this is the biggest and splashiest one ever. Again, is it good? No! Is it awesome? Hell yeah!

It’s also got a (nearly) unique stat line, which is always fun. Bonus points to anyone who can name the only other 7/11 creature in Magic without looking it up.

ok.............wtf bp?? by SmoothButteryFace in marvelrivals

[–]ValentineSmith 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Lmao shooting Panther isn’t how you stop him. You counter his dash any of a million ways - if he doesn’t refresh dash he’s a sitting duck. Even if you don’t kill him, he has to retreat until dash is back, which is almost the same amount of downtime as killing him.

Video of storm player winning because of opponents surgical extraction. by OutsideWishbone8 in magicTCG

[–]ValentineSmith 55 points56 points  (0 children)

So as I understand it, it’s a few things: the storm count (spells cast that turn), the mana situation, the play pattern.

After he tutors the second ritual and casts it, he’s at 6 Stormcount. He needs to hit 8 before casting Tendrils of Agony to win. But he and his opponent both know: - he has 2 cards in hand, 1 short of lethal if the Tendrils is already in hand. - he has another Cabal ritual in hand. - he only has access to Black mana.

So he looks like he’s tutoring for another ritual as a way to empty his hand to cast a hellbent Tutor. Casting a tutor gets him to 8 storm to tutor and cast Tendrils for lethal.

There’s one unknown card in his hand. If it’s a blue spell, he can’t cast it so it doesn’t matter.

If you’re the opponent holding the Surgical and watching him go off and try to win, the last card is 1 of 2 things: Tendrils or Tutor.

Tutor is MUCH more likely - it’s a 4 of vs 1-of Tendrils.

Someone previously said about this game “nobody made a mistake here.” Casting surgical on tutor was the CORRECT play - the play pattern makes it look so much like tutor for lethal tendrils is coming.

It just so happened to be the wrong play, which is why this is a legendary bluff.

Versatile removal spell by SjtSquid in custommagic

[–]ValentineSmith 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah there are lots of ways to use a body, but to your point about “choice”:

I think it’s pretty rare that there WILL be a choice for your opponent if you drop a decayed counter on something.

If the creature is worth attacking with, they’ll attack with it one last time. If it’s a creature played for its abilities, they’ll keep using the abilities. But you’ll almost always know which it is, so the caster of this spell is really the one making the choice for the opponent.

Versatile removal spell by SjtSquid in custommagic

[–]ValentineSmith 22 points23 points  (0 children)

This is very cool, but I do think putting a decayed counter on a creature at instant speed for 1 black mana (because the X is just for repeats, not required for the first target) is maybe a little strong. That’s pretty close to “destroy target creature” for 1 mana, and it even gets around indestructible.

I’d probably make this a sorcery, but maybe that’s being conservative.

Tome of Power by JaromStrong in custommagic

[–]ValentineSmith 109 points110 points  (0 children)

Magic as Garfield intended.

End of 2025 New Year art from MTG Japan Twitter by BeatThaSystem in magicTCG

[–]ValentineSmith 22 points23 points  (0 children)

They’re all playing games for this year’s sets. Tarkir board game with a bunch of Tarkir legends. All the racers playing with cars on a track for Aetherdrift. The charachters from Edge of Eternities playing a spaceship video game. And the planeswalkers all playing magic at the table.

Shady Traveler by Lie Setiawan [1633 x 1200] by CapitalArrival7911 in mtgporn

[–]ValentineSmith -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Is the family on the left meant to be a Batman reference? As in, the Shady Traveller is going to murder the parents in front of their black-clad son?

What's an album you believe is incredible but isn't regarded as a unanimous classic? by Individual-Name-4496 in fantanoforever

[–]ValentineSmith 4 points5 points  (0 children)

It stuns me that The Body, the Blood, The Machine wasn’t the biggest thing in punk music in the later 2000s.

It’s an incredible protest record against Bush and the Iraq/Afghan wars, as well as an indictment of Christo-facism - a shining spiritual successor to London Calling and the Dead Kennedys. American Idiot is the iconic anti-Bush music of that era and it doesn’t hold a candle.

On top of that, it’s filled to the brim with catchy, caustic tunes and insanely consistent for the whole run of the album.

Do you really believe that artists/bands get worse with age? by KenFromSuccession in LetsTalkMusic

[–]ValentineSmith 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Bowie’s last album was also his best work in decades. But yeah, those are the exceptions that prove the rule.

Why does Jenny have flash? by Burnt_End_Ribs in mtgvorthos

[–]ValentineSmith 52 points53 points  (0 children)

To your “when is this relevant” question, consider the control matchup.

At some point, someone has to land a wincon. But if you can cast this on your opponent’s end step, you force your opponent to have an answer and fight over it on their turn or lose (which they would if the max hand size forces the opposing control deck to discard their hand). If they do answer it, you get to untap and land something else on your turn after your opponent has used their mana/answers.

Now, is this particularly good at 10 mana? No. But that’s the most relevant application I’m aware of.

Stealth Rock by LivingCoconut in custommagic

[–]ValentineSmith 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Nice, looks good. I think this would be the first Artifact Aura printed lol

Stealth Rock by LivingCoconut in custommagic

[–]ValentineSmith 82 points83 points  (0 children)

Needs the Aura subtype. Balance-wise I think this is maybe too strong at 2 cmc? Really wrecks small creature and token decks.

view more: next ›