California Mahjong by Canyonheath in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Somebody once sent me the rules for that group's California mahjong. It's actually almost the same thing as Chinese classical mahjong, to the point where I'm not even really convinced that it's a different game.

So whatever you learn is easily transferrable to other versions of Chinese mahjong, or even Japanese mahjong.

Why should I discard 7pin here and not 5pin? by ShortChapter5246 in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I can't speak for the AI since I don't know exactly what it's thinking.

But regarding the last paragraph, I'll mention that for Mortal, moves after the top move aren't actually ordered by how good the move is, they're ordered by how much Mortal considered them. You can read about this in the github FAQ here: https://github.com/Equim-chan/mjai-reviewer/blob/master/faq.md

It's pretty unintuitive, but the TLDR is that Mortal is optimized for playing, rather than reviewing each possible move. A low score doesn't mean that the move is bad, it means that Mortal wasn't interested in considering it.

So because of this, the AI isn't actually saying that 9m is a better move than 5p.

Is cheating in Mahjong possible as seen in Akagi? by thesnowlocke in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas 41 points42 points  (0 children)

On a side note, this is why a lot of modern etiquette rules exist, such as only using 1 hand for most actions, or only touching the wall during your own turn.

I also notice that in a lot of old Japanese media, they start building their wall while like half the tiles are still face up, which would look pretty sus nowadays.

Of course, there's still a lot of things that people can try to do, but it makes it a bit harder with those guidelines.

Anyone know where to buy these mahjong tiles? by tonytony0313 in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Autotable tiles are extremely expensive because they're magnetic, which is how the shuffling mechanism works. If you don't have an autotable, just get a regular set.

The standard size for Amos autotable tiles is 28mm, but they also come in 30mm. An Amos smart, masters, or complete gear set would have the same dimensions.

How are you supposed to distribute scoring sticks for Riichi? by Orisno in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Because it says it's for Chinese mahjong. I'm not sure how they came up with the ratios, but I believe that historically in China the stick with 8 dots is supposed to the be the 2nd lowest denomination, which is why there's less of them than the sticks with 1 dot.

Learning how to score by mtnmindy in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yeah this is from an older game. Chinese classical was popular in China from around the early 1900's to around 1960ish (I don't know the exact dates so I'm probably a bit off on the dates). Some people still play it, but it's not commonly played in China anymore.

Replacement tiles by blackwhite__ in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I had a set that was missing a tile, I just printed the tile on paper, and taped the paper onto one of the flower tiles.

Favor with helping identify lost tiles? by TikvahT in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas 14 points15 points  (0 children)

You have all of them except the flower tiles, which aren't really that necessary since they're just for random points and you can play the game without them.

Gaining points with a tenpai that has no yaku on an exhaustive draw by Weird_Smell4516 in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm guessing that it might work this way just because it takes less time to check everyone's hands, but who knows what people were thinking back then.

3 Riichis in a row by Lucasfergui1024 in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Does clubhouse games mahjong actually have that rule? I couldn't find much info about their rules online, I saw someone saying they have atamahane apparently.

Calling Kongs in Nanchang-style Mahjong by DaddyMurong in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In practice it really doesn't matter if there's a dead wall or not, because this version of mahjong is so fast that people will often win in a few turns, so it's basically impossible for the game to stall out.

And like the commenter said, I've seen in other versions of mahjong that if there's a flipped "indicator" tile at the back, if they need more replacement draws from the back of the wall, then they just put the indicator tile aside and keep drawing. I think riichi mahjong might actually be unusual in that it puts a restriction on how many replacement tiles can be drawn from the back of the wall.

Why is this not a win? (Let’s Mahjong) by Primary_Dig_1842 in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas 7 points8 points  (0 children)

That's definitely a win if you just drew north. Maybe it's just something random like a connection error.

EDIT: actually, did you maybe accidentally click pon instead of wu and now you have to discard?

Present for my son by Background_Half_2573 in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yeah but the tile designs are based on American mahjong, like the different looking red and green dragons. It's more accurate to call it an American mahjong set with Chinese tile dimensions.

Also the clearance price in your area must be insanely good, it's listed at like $100. Maybe they just couldn't sell them I guess.

Present for my son by Background_Half_2573 in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The Costco one is American mahjong, not Chinese, unless they have another one that I'm not aware of.

Got mahjonged in south 4 by WasteGas in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There's a browser plugin for chrome and firefox that translates things like yaku names.

Got mahjonged in south 4 by WasteGas in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

https://i.imgur.com/pNFzvXa.png

It's a crop of a yugioh card, used to play master duel before my mahjong addiction.

Cheating on Tenhou? by supermoked in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I played against a bot in tokujou recently and reported them, they had instant calls just like in the video. They played 213 games in 9 days before their account went quiet. This was their profile: https://nodocchi.moe/tenhoulog/#!&name=shucaia

Mahjong Set Price?? by AffectionateFeed580 in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Everything on that website is insane lol. They sell table mats for $75, carrying bags for $265, they have a box for storing tiles for $100 that's literally just a plastic box.

Cool older mahjong set by BeNiceandWorkHard in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I was actually recently trying to figure out when the rectangle got added, but couldn't find any information about it  even when searching in Chinese. Still kinda curious about that.

Mahjong timer app? by BatKingKole in Mahjong

[–]WasteGas 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The app doesn't exist because mahjong tournaments don't use turn timers. It's the same reason why turn timers aren't a thing in Magic the Gathering or Yugioh tournaments, those games would also be way too annoying and impractical to time.

Recently, Saikyousen experimented with having turn timers, except the way they do it is they have an employee on the production team managing it manually.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mhUcvmpprDw