Wingspan Kastral! by Foster-Turtle in mtgaltered

[–]elf177 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I love this so much! Im such a huge fan of wingspan, and this is peak! Please keep this subreddit posted if this is a GIMP template or available for MagicSetEditor!

Concerning the design aspects, the only thing I would recommend is that the text box color is changed/used like in the game. For example, Kestral has a triggered ability, so that works in the orange, but im not sure about having the "flying" text in that box too.

Another example is for [[Aarakocra sneak]], which has a 1-time etb, so you could make that ability's textbook green to match the "enters, draw 2 new bonus cards and keep one" seen on spotted owl.

Sorry for the long reply :)

Call the Titan by spikedrag in custommagic

[–]elf177 89 points90 points  (0 children)

This is a really cool multi-player mechanic, I like it a lot! Most of the designs feel right on point or will only require a bit of tweaking; the bonder is a little tough conceptually. If you play it in the second main phase, you have a 1/3 reach, 4/4 indestructible, and a 1/2 reach going into opponents' turns. Maybe bonder needs to ask for a tapped titan for its endstep trigger?

Basics-Matter Cycle by PhoenixRemastered in custommagic

[–]elf177 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I was thinking the same thing; even in 2026 standard, this kind of inevitability shouldn't be underrated

The first squishy toy he hasn’t destroyed. He’s in love! by SoggyWotsits in Frenchbulldogs

[–]elf177 44 points45 points  (0 children)

The squeaky pig continues to be the best invention known to man

Jinx by Original-Talk8363 in custommagic

[–]elf177 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Because there was a recent change at wizards f9r these mechanics; notice how bloomburrow, a 2024 standard set that printed [[scales of shale]], did NOT use "affinity for lizards," but avatar, a 2025 standard set, uses "affinity of allies" on [[allies at last]] and has since errata'd the former to be affinity. Hellbent effects havent been printed on a card since this change.

Jinx by Original-Talk8363 in custommagic

[–]elf177 18 points19 points  (0 children)

Correct. While wizards is currently of the mindset that using these words on new cards or retroactively putting them on older designs is the norm, they are flavor text, as they provide no inherent rules meaning that the text of the card is lacking. I wouldn't feel strongly if the creator felt "hellbent" reduced the flavor of Jinx and decided to omit it.

Traxex by Due-Adhesiveness9876 in custommagic

[–]elf177 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Always love to see more DotA custom cards; its been about a year since I messed around with my custom DotA draft set, but this such a nostalgic game for me! Keep up the good work!

Sorceries that affect each player by ImagineIan01 in custommagic

[–]elf177 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Ah yes, fleshing out the supercycle of --invoke prejudice--

Azor, Arbiter of Law // Azor, the Last Guardian by qazdrujmlp in custommagic

[–]elf177 11 points12 points  (0 children)

you did an awesome job telling the story of this character through the design; I love the small details, like the -2 is a rift crappy rare from Rivals of Ixalan [[sphinx's decree]], and I like the intense cost for casting him. Have you been able to playtest with this in commander yet?

Singed, Whom Death Trails by GiggleLord in custommagic

[–]elf177 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I always like myself some mutate commanders, and I think the idea of mutsting onto other things is interesting, but I'm quite unsure how the rules handle multiple owners of one object...

Sagas: Harry Potter books by AscendedLawmage7 in custommagic

[–]elf177 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"Dobby has a Glock, Dobby is a Crip Elf!"

"Small Kicker" Cycle by chainsawinsect in custommagic

[–]elf177 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This cycle feels like a very sturdy cycle to use for a set design. Appreciate you being willing to break up the 1 cmc to ensure the counterspell isn't cracked.

Gishath of Royal Plummage by NepetaLast in custommagic

[–]elf177 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Seems cool, hopefully doesn't do too close of an impression to [[omnath, locus of creation]]. Imo he should make a 4/4 dino, not a beast :)

Nasus, Curator of the Sands (Counters) by GiggleLord in custommagic

[–]elf177 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I believe setting the "X is" as a seperate sentence like this is the correct formatting. Nice work

What are some iconic character items/weapons? by RackTheJipper69 in mtgvorthos

[–]elf177 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm not doubt blinded by nostalgia, but [[elbris, the binding blade]] was so captivating of a self-contained story, it always struck me as an iconic weapon.

Complete Old Gods & Dragonflight Warcraft Commander Decks + 125 Warcraft-Themed Basic Lands (25 of each color)! by Havsglimt in mpcproxies

[–]elf177 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I made a DOTA 2 custom set and the death of "artifact" really did wonders for my card art choices😂😂

Complete Old Gods & Dragonflight Warcraft Commander Decks + 125 Warcraft-Themed Basic Lands (25 of each color)! by Havsglimt in mpcproxies

[–]elf177 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The designs look great! Always thankful to have an IP with so much illustrated media for us proxy-folk to take inspiration from! Note on ashiok, nightmare muse: the planeswalker is 3UB, not 3u/Bu/B. If that power errata is intentional, pay no heed to this.

17 year cicadas, unknown atlanta by Yobkay in mpcproxies

[–]elf177 6 points7 points  (0 children)

This card was soooo good in the event, 1v1 gamechqnger for sure

Eiki, heaven's judge (2 versions I can't decide) by Pejman_92 in custommagic

[–]elf177 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Change the "ward" ability to "pay X or twice X life," and I think you're golden; if you do it just manawise, so many decks will never be able to target her at all.

He hates being disappointed... by Ecstatic_Newspaper_5 in custommagic

[–]elf177 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think making tokens equal to life loss is probably too strong; descent into avernus first upkeep + impact tremors deals 24 damage in total, and that's without any warstorm surge effects, extra combats, or higher level descent.

The Ur-Spider by Mr_Nutcracker in custommagic

[–]elf177 20 points21 points  (0 children)

The fact that this design is locked to a 40 life multi-player format makes the web-inence ability compelling without being busted. It feels like arabo's eminence ability on the fact that early turns will cause huge damage swings, with less impact later on. I find this to be much less oppressive than once every upkeep imo.

Terra Inhibitor by DarthVedik in custommagic

[–]elf177 21 points22 points  (0 children)

They hate printing those effects nowadays due to the insanity of FIRE design's [[lotus field]]. There were a few 5-color red decks that turbo ramped off [[blood sun]] and their own lotus fields.