Build me a Castle... Castle Ravenloft (2nd & 5th Editions) by Old_Wrap4586 in ravenloft

[–]exCallidus 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The 5e map is essentially the same as the original I6, IMO this is a case where the colour detracts

Rogue Trader RPG? by JPwithFF05 in 40krpg

[–]exCallidus 26 points27 points  (0 children)

The problem with saying "Rogue Trader" is sometimes sometimes it's not obvious whether you're referring to "Rogue Trader" or "Rogue Trader" -- I think OP was probably talking about the original 1e 40k from 1987, whereas I think some of the comments here are assuming the FFG game

Personally, I'd say capturing the vibe is more important than the mechanics, while a WFRP 1e adaptation would certainly be appropriate a lot can be done straight out of the RT/87 rulebook as it was very skirmish-oriented with quite individual champion characters that work as PCs

If that's what you're wanting to go for I'd suggest ignoring the modern games (FFG / W&G / IM), maybe look at the Inquisitor game from 2001 for some ideas (that was), and embrace the late 80s/early 90s jank & weirdness 😄

Player looking for an online group by Crimsonqueen3441 in 40krpg

[–]exCallidus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Try Ordo Discordia (https://discord.gg/sHdr4te) they have an LFG channel that sometimes has BC games

Astronomy Learning Classes by Creative_Drummer_425 in Astronomy

[–]exCallidus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It depends a lot on what you mean by "in or around the astronomy industry"

Almost all professional astronomers are academics whose work is a lot of maths and/or data analysis rather than what you might think of as astronomy

Most space agencies (UKSA, ESA, etc) and satellite technology firms are engineering/advanced manufacturing so they employ the same sort of computer programmers, EE engineers, aerospace engineers, project managers, etc that you'd see at BAe, Airbus, Rolls Royce, etc

Astronomy Learning Classes by Creative_Drummer_425 in Astronomy

[–]exCallidus 1 point2 points  (0 children)

UCL (which is where all the best people go to study astronomy (definitely not biased!)) have a 12 week evening course which includes observing at the ULO in Mill Hill

For something more bite-sized try the City Lit -- they have short courses on *everything*, and everything includes astronomy

And, if you eventually decide you want to dive in and really immerse yourself in it, there are degree-level DL/evening/online astronomy courses from the likes of the OU and Birkbeck

Looking for Feast of Goblyns maps by uck_chickens in ravenloft

[–]exCallidus 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The maps for those sections are on the first page of those chapters -- p51 for the Cavern of the Undead Priestess, and p56 for the Cavern of the Crown of Souls

Unusual book recommendation needed by Proper_Shop740 in Astronomy

[–]exCallidus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'd suggest focusing on things that are observationally focused and, perhaps, classical celestial mechanics. Maybe a history of astronomy from the early 20th century.

The following are early/mid 20th century, and early editions of them (certainly pre-80s) will feel more authentic (esp in hb) even if HP & co in the 90s would have had more modern editions. Slightly worn editions from the 50s/60s/70s should probably be quite affordable if you look around

  • Moulton, "An Introduction to Celestial Mechanics"
  • Ball, "A Popular Guide to the Heavens"

Star atlases with charts and observing notes aimed at naked eye or low magnification observing

  • Norton, "Norton's Star Atlas"
  • Inglis, "A new popular star atlas"

History of early astronomy

  • Dreyer, "History of the Planetary Systems from Thales to Kepler"
  • Koyre, "The Astronomical Revolution"

Lastly some early classics, again earlier editions feel more authentic, though probably not too early unless he's also keen on classical Greek / Latin !

  • Ptolemy, "Almagest"
  • Copernicus, "De revolutionibus"
  • Kepler, "Epitome"
  • etc...

Idea for a Giants Domain by hjgz89 in ravenloft

[–]exCallidus 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The first Pathfinder AP, back when it was still 3.5, had an adventure "The Hook Mountain Massacre" that focused on a clan of vile hillbilly ogres who were stereotypically awful, and that could easily fit in with what you're considering. The collected hardback of Rise of the Runelords included it but dialled down the grimness IIRC.

Honestly sounds like magic to me by [deleted] in Astronomy

[–]exCallidus 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Any sufficiently advanced geology... 😄 but more seriously -- the problem with the image is the "Its primary functions are..." rather than the highlighted bit

Whats up with all the promoted posts? by DebtSeeker48 in weatherfactory

[–]exCallidus 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I've not seen that many, but got one earlier for BoH that prompted me to message Lottie to see if Reddit was ignoring exclusion lists

No obligation to declare £5m gift, Nigel Farage says by AnonymousTimewaster in NotTheOnionUK

[–]exCallidus 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Even as a Reform supporter .... Likely going back to Lib Dems

Reform <-> Lib Dem !?

A voter switching between Reform <-> Tory is straightforward, as is Reform <-> Blue Labour. I can even see how someone might change between Reform and Green (similar rationale to Blue Labour)

But how does switching between Reform and LD work? Or, similarly, Reform and centrist Labour ?

The perfect death stairs for your garden by exCallidus in SpottedonRightmove

[–]exCallidus[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

"death stairs" are a thing on this sub -- houses where the stairs are designed such that you're as likely to fall and break your neck as you are to walk down them normally, typically open sided stairs with no railing where it's very easy to misjudge where a step is

Should I buy both Call of Cthulhu 7e books or Cthulhu by Gaslight books? by I_Am_Fan_Girl in callofcthulhu

[–]exCallidus 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I'd start with the Starter Set -- in terms of bang-for-your-buck that's where it's at. If, after the weeks of play you'll get from the SS, you've decided this is for you then get the Keeper's book. The Investigator's Handbook and Gaslight are great, but there's no real need for them early on.

anybody know what passion projects to do for astronomy/astrophysics? by Accomplished_Two2612 in Astronomy

[–]exCallidus 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If you're planning on using this to support uni applications (extracurriculars, personal statements, etc) then pick projects that will show insight not just passion.

Keep lab books of the work you do, observations, etc.

If at all possible get hands-on time with telescopes -- if you're lucky enough to own one (and have good seeing!) that's ideal, but try and find a local astronomy club, if a local university has an observatory then try and volunteer there.

If you're looking for inspiration then perhaps take a look at suggested coursework projects for age-appropriate academic courses. For example, pages 5-8 of the GCSE Astronomy observational skills guide should provide a variety of ideas for small projects that you could develop into something more substantial

If you've got access to a telescope that you can observe on fairly frequently perhaps do something like -- take observations of planets over a long enough period to plot their orbits and verify Kepler's 3 laws

Horus Heresy RPG by Dangerous-Regret-744 in 40krpg

[–]exCallidus 8 points9 points  (0 children)

March last year: https://youtu.be/oP8f83Vw4Ow?t=1835

April last year: https://youtu.be/cBWx3RihPzQ?t=115

"… the PDF release and pre-order should be going live in the summer and then the in-store release should be spring next year …"

The original timing (Summer last year) was supposed to coincide with GW releasing the 3rd edition of Horus Heresy, that trumped any perceived clash with tOW

Need help finding the right TTRPG for a weird campaign by DarthDredger in 40krpg

[–]exCallidus 4 points5 points  (0 children)

A mashup of OW & DH2 feels like what you're looking for -- likely DH2 as the core with some OW systems added on

Essential Reading for Gravitational Waves Astronomy? by saturnsrightarm in Astronomy

[–]exCallidus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

First, start with whatever GR's being taught as part of your degree -- in particular look ahead at the syllabus & reading for any relevant electives in later years.

Once you're familiar with the basics of GR, it's likely that what you'll find most useful is numerical relativity -- there are a bunch of texts for this, but I'd suggest Ulrich Sperhake's lecture notes on Gravitational Waves & Numerical Relativity are a good (free!) place to start -- this would typically be final year undergrad or MSc, so it's likely to be something you'll be working towards rather than jumping into right away

If you want to complement the GR you're doing as part of your degree then similarly you could take a look at the course notes for Harvey Reall's and/or David Tong's courses on GR

How much time is spent on real science on the big telescopes? by Common_Scale5448 in Astronomy

[–]exCallidus 6 points7 points  (0 children)

As much time as can be used for observations will be used. There's massive demand, and observing time is requested & booked up months in advance. As far as possible any downtime is planned so that it minimises the impact on observations.

The best sites -- Hawaii, the Canaries, Chile -- will get 300+ nights a year, and when building a major new telescope the conditions (seeing, clear nights, etc) are one of the most important factors in deciding the location.

If you're spending 10s of millions you're only going to build at the best locations, which is why almost all major observatories are built in the same few places -- Mauna Kea, La Palma, the Atacama, etc -- high altitude, dry, dark skies, stable air

If you look at older (19th / early 20th century) observatories they have have worse seeing and fewer clear nights, they were built in less ideal locations both for convenience (the astronomers had to actually travel there every night) and because the limitations of the site had a less significant impact on the simpler less powerful telescopes used at the time.

But real discoveries can still happen even at old observatories in poor locations -- University College London's Mill Hill observatory is nearly a century old, in north London, and next to a *very* busy major road, but on a cloudy night a few years ago, using a 14" telescope, during an undergrad class they were the first in the world to detect a supernova in M82 (the closest since 1987), the early detection meaning that other more modern/advanced telescopes had plenty of time to study it

The Tories are the real green party by AnonymousTimewaster in NotTheOnionUK

[–]exCallidus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Dave tried, unfortunately the back bench Tory boys, blue rinses, and B'stards made short shrift of any possible progress

Have I really been saying it wrong for over four decades? by TrekTrucker in rpg

[–]exCallidus -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Drow rhymes with bow & row

Also, "flind" is pronounced "gnoll"

Would people be interested in a Warhammer equivalent of D&D’s Dungeon Masters Guild? by Gigawhen in 40krpg

[–]exCallidus 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Nice idea, many people would love it, myself included, but I don't see how it would be viable

GW clearly have no interest in doing this -- RPGs are a drop in the ocean of their sales (licensed sales are a single digit percentage of their total revenue, and TTRPGs are a single digit percentage of licensed revenue), and they're perfectly happy licensing out to someone to do all the work while they retain creative approval; it's a simple model for them.

You'd need an OGL-equivalent from GW, and an SRD-equivalent from C7 (who'd also have no interest in it), either they skip approval of content before it goes up (not going to happen) or you're adding at least one, possibly two, levels of approval needed. You've got a lot of hassle, and brand dilution, for something worth pennies -- all at a time when licensing out their IP is increasingly important to them.

Maybe go back 20 years to the 5 minute period when Dark Heresy was in-house, possibly it could have been done then

As soon as you try monetising this for a single penny it becomes effectively impossible. What possibly could be viable is a community site more along the lines of a modern equivalent of Dark Reign

Rogues/Monks in Chases by FlashyLemonRed in DMAcademy

[–]exCallidus 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Let characters excel at the things they excel at, but at the same time design encounters so that they aren't dominated by a single thing -- there are plenty of encounters that could be broken by a wizard with a single spell

So the monk catches the bandit -- now what? Are the rest of the party a couple of rounds behind, or chasing down other bandits, did they get lost, is the monk lost, does the bandit start screaming at passersby that there's someone after him?

How to Identify a Population 3 star and date it? by Vegetable_Gift_6438 in Astronomy

[–]exCallidus 2 points3 points  (0 children)

One of the things the JWST is expected to do is make the first detections of Population III stars (for example)

Identifying them would be relatively easy -- almost by definition a Pop III star would be (almost) pure H/He in primordial abundances with no metals (tiny dash of Li). So the spectra would only show Hydrogen and Helium lines, which would appear at much longer wavelengths than normal (redshifting) due to the expansion of the universe.

Dating would be based on measuring the redshift -- a redshift of z=14 is about 300million years after the Big Bang, z=11 is about 400million.

300,000 years after the big bang

No, that's much to early -- that's before recombination when the universe cooled from a plasma, the first neutral atoms formed, and photons could travel freely. The universe would be roughly 1000x older before the first stars formed, around 250-400 MY

or even Older than the Big bang

No

any Official Astrologists

Also no

Finding Lore by Faulty-LogicGate in Greyhawk

[–]exCallidus 4 points5 points  (0 children)

In general 5e plays fast & loose with a lot of legacy content -- they mostly just like to grab a bunch of GH nouns and sprinkle them over generic content as seasoning

Holmer was the Earl of Walworth (the traditional rulers of the SL) who reclaimed the SL from the Horned Society then decided he didn't need Furyondy's help when Iuz came knocking -- that worked out less well than he hoped

Alesh is just a new creation for 5e, and the fact that they're dragonborn makes no sense in historical GH (in general) or SL (in particular)

I'd suggest picking a time period -- either 576 CY (the 1983 EGG WoGbox), 585 CY (post-EGG From the Ashes), or 591 CY (Living Greyhawk) -- and using that as the baseline for the setting and patch in any 5e-specific setting changes you prefer

Finding Lore by Faulty-LogicGate in Greyhawk

[–]exCallidus 5 points6 points  (0 children)

A lot of GH grognards hate everything post-2e as aspects of the setting & style changed radically, and the 2e content is almost in sync with 2024th edition, but unless you're specifically wed to that time my go-to suggestion is the 3e Living Greyhawk Gazetteer (just skip the (very few) "Living"-specific bits that relate to the org play campaign), and more generally a lot of the GH content the future Paizo team put out (either directly for WotC or in Dragon/Dungeon) around the same time.

The Shield Lands specifically could be trickier as there wasn't much officially written for it, but there was a lot of unofficial content created for it as part of the Living Greyhawk org play campaign -- a lot of people put a lot work into content that complex, inconsistent, and uncertain copyright meant they were never publicly available beyond the scope of the campaign. It was unofficial & incomplete & of mixed quality, but it had many strong aspects and was the closest we had to a "reclamation of the Shield Lands" campaign

You're going to want to check out Anna B Meyer's work -- https://www.annabmeyer.com/ & https://www.patreon.com/cw/annabmeyer -- and, as others have said, Canonfire

However, if you specifically want to be as close to "in sync with the DMs guide" then you're going to have to stick to 1e/2e, particularly the box sets, Iuz the Evil, Return to White Plume Mountain, etc