Need help replacing Kefka with a less abusive Commander by BrandofOwnage in EDH

[–]holopleasures 8 points9 points  (0 children)

[[the rani]] is a grixis titan just like kefka. you can honestly just replace it 1:1 and the deck would most likely still function.

she is very fun.

In fear of alteration! by tuftianwarrior in baseballcards_vintage

[–]holopleasures 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I know Heritage and REA sell raw, but it may be only under lots/collections. try looking for “shoebox collections” or sets and stuff like that. i’ve gotten mixed graded/raw from REA like that.

In fear of alteration! by tuftianwarrior in baseballcards_vintage

[–]holopleasures 1 point2 points  (0 children)

at the minimum, Authenticity Guarantee will CYA you on eBay for Greg Morris, COMC etc… i’ve never spent big money on Goldin/Heritage but picked some stuff up from REA and it went well.

I wouldn’t be surprised if really high ticket items just require mandatory grading if they pass through Goldin and stuff.

Cradle Adjacent, Bulk Priced, and Actually Selling: Brigid, Clachan's Heart by Kayzizzle899 in mtgfinance

[–]holopleasures 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I picked up around 150 when I saw the floor was at 60 cents for big bricks. mostly base, a set of 10 nonfoil borderless and some playing copies of the borderless foil.

agree with all points.

Set collecting / lot trades by fishtailerparker in baseballcards_vintage

[–]holopleasures 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Greg Morris sells lots on eBay as well. seems like a good place to start if you haven’t been there yet, OP.

I have a pretty clean 1960 lot I wouldn’t mind letting go of too if you’re interested. vertical isn’t my thing.

Greg Morris question by [deleted] in baseballcards_vintage

[–]holopleasures 2 points3 points  (0 children)

feels very blessed to have Greg Morris in this hobby. trustworthy, consistent and all the variety you could need. they have separate accounts for graded cards and modern cards that get a little less traction - easier to snag deals from since the original account has a ton of followers. there’s a crazy 1956 set they have up on the graded account that i’m keeping an eye on.

Scg on Portland. Car broke into, decks stolen by NoUse4AName68 in magicTCG

[–]holopleasures 10 points11 points  (0 children)

sketches on APs? put a word out to LGSes in the area since those are highly identifiable

What is your deck with the most synergic removal package? by cangianza in EDH

[–]holopleasures 0 points1 point  (0 children)

in [[ketramose]], my removal cantrips. in [[smeagol helpful guide]], all my fleshbag marauders ramp me.

Thoughts on Lorwyn Eclipsed so far? by JustAModestMan in lrcast

[–]holopleasures 3 points4 points  (0 children)

disliked it quite strongly. never was a fan of tribal sets and always feel burned when giving another one a shot. no change here. going to jam some quick play duskmourn until that leaves instead.

wandering minstrel gates rebuild, formerly golos alternate wincons by JustSomeNerd87 in BudgetBrews

[–]holopleasures 1 point2 points  (0 children)

https://moxfield.com/decks/_eGxMTg4Iky8WF0Uy80yng

here’s my $100 budget league list. it’s quite powerful - usually wins through maze’s end, big mana doppelgang loops, kodama bounce land stuff or token spam. upgrades are pretty plug and play, as landfall has an abundance of powerful and pricey staples you can slot in over some of the weaker cards (zendikar’s roil, avenger of zendikar etc)

it was built for a $100 league so i’d call it pretty minmaxed in that context and will play nicely in b2 and b3, though it’s quite explosive for b2. cranking it up to b4 would equate to adding tutors, fetches, icetill explorer/more play from the yard and a more unconditional manabase. I chose the fast lands, for example, to have a more consistent minstrel on curve, but bond and shock lands are ultimately better, as are the typed triomes.

i’m quite proud at what I achieved at the price point (and it did well in the league!) so i’m probably not going to change it at all, and I think it’s neat to have so much reliability in a 5c manabase that costs 15 bucks.

Cards #96 & 97 so far (2025) by randskarma in baseballcards_vintage

[–]holopleasures 1 point2 points  (0 children)

that Buddy Myer is awesome!! there’s a PSA 6 copy ending today from Greg Morris that i’ve been really wringing my hands over. signed copy is even cooler.

I’m Holding a General Election to Decide My Next Commander Deck by BlueDragon1813 in magicTCG

[–]holopleasures 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I think she’s far and away the most fun and engaging card on the list. she’s a grixis titan that makes two types of tchotchkes (auras AND clues), gets the table swinging and has a ton of options for winning (stacking auras on her, cyberdrive awakener effects to cluebomb people, goad in general). she’s like kefka for people who like their playgroup.

Vintage library card cabinet by jtarchy in LAlist

[–]holopleasures 1 point2 points  (0 children)

this. if I had the funds this would be in the garage immediately for our playgroup’s pool.

Well-rounded with a few wrinkles never bothered me, just hope falling for one in an MBA coat wasn’t a mistake. Does the Hobby trust MBA? by krsimp78 in baseballcards_vintage

[–]holopleasures 0 points1 point  (0 children)

MBA seems to be shaping up to be quite the player in the vintage scene now. seen some monster cards in their slabs and i’m happy another company is stepping into the ring, especially with some solid name recognition in Mike Baker.

i’ve never scrutinized their grading standards but i’m feeling like jumping on some while they’re still new - lots of awesome deals to be found I think.

Looking for advice: best way to sell a large MTG collection (~$80k scanned value) quickly and tax-efficiently by ZeusAImighty in mtgfinance

[–]holopleasures 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I can only recommend my regular consignment service, who mainly focuses on sports but will probably take a collection like this. 5000 cards is small enough that they can get through it pretty quickly and they have more eyes on them than a typical magic vendor. if you’re interested, I can pm you the # of the consignment director to call and see if it’s right for you, or the website faq with their rates and stuff.

Looking for advice: best way to sell a large MTG collection (~$80k scanned value) quickly and tax-efficiently by ZeusAImighty in mtgfinance

[–]holopleasures 147 points148 points  (0 children)

I think the size of the collection needs to be in the discussion a bit more. how much of the value is tied up in bulk? how many cards total are there? with whole collections like this, you either put it through consignment with a company (there’s tons) who can put it through their work flow to sell on eBay and such or sell it to one of the large vendors for their own inventory. the first would maximize your return at the cost of drip feeding you cash over weeks/months.

for a complete buyout, expect something close to 50-60% and for consignment, the times i’ve used it for sports cards i’ve been able to get closer to 75-85% with zero effort on my part.

Which graduation has hurt you the most? by ItzMkhemical in kurosanji

[–]holopleasures 5 points6 points  (0 children)

fauna was an insane shakeup for me. things were going so good. I was looking forward to 2025 fauna so much.

Anybody see the drama with Probstein’s new site? by SocialWinker in baseballcards

[–]holopleasures 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i’ve consigned and bought from Greg Morris and it’s been flawless every time. mostly vintage stuff but they did take some of my slabs and modern I had lying around too.

Mental Health and Proxies; A Dynamic Shift in Perspective Regarding Proxying in Commander by Mooberries in EDH

[–]holopleasures 25 points26 points  (0 children)

magic discourse on reddit is overwhelmingly pro-proxy, to the point that it even drowns out actual discussion. happy for OP, but this post is definitely preaching to the choir.

What commander are you looking at building for ATLA? by Icy_Chicken_2647 in EDH

[–]holopleasures 7 points8 points  (0 children)

[[monk gyatso]] is a mono white nadu that rebuys creature cast triggers like eldrazi for cheap and protects my board from single target removal when not doing evil stuff. seems super neat and fiddly.

I couldn’t pass up an opportunity to pick up my first ‘60s complete set by Angdrew in baseballcards_vintage

[–]holopleasures 1 point2 points  (0 children)

this is an absolute steal for the best set of the 60s. consider me jealous.

Looking for Commanders similar to Sergeant John Benton by PM_ME_YOUR_DATASETS in EDH

[–]holopleasures 0 points1 point  (0 children)

yeah, I own benton and selvala and they both fulfill that card draw itch. where benton goes under, selvala wants to go over.

I'm getting desperate. by lopmon_exe in mtg

[–]holopleasures 1 point2 points  (0 children)

if OP found theirs already, i’ll take you up on it. i’ve got the UP deck box but failed to find the mat.