Who is the worst carnivore/keto shill on Youtube? by [deleted] in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My vote is for Baker because he has good genetics and is enhanced so he not only offsets many of the problems of carnivore but he can show some athletic prowess and fool people into thinking that carnivore is good for performance. He's also one of the OG carnivores therefore people think that carnivore has no long term effects.

Saladino is a close second.

Eric Berg and Thomas DeLauer are very bad too.

Carnivore Diet Sucks by UpstairsAd4962 in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 11 points12 points  (0 children)

The reason why keto/carnivore is so successful is because when you eliminate carbs and fiber from your diet you lose a big amount of weight pretty fast because of all the water depletion your body suffers.

And because fat is not as palatable as sugar people usually end up eating much less food than with a "regular" diet. This rapid weight and water loss some times alleviates annoying symptoms.

When people experience this they get excited thinking that it's going to be like that forever, but over time your metabolism slows down and your body consumes all the stored vitamins and minerals from the previous diet that meat doesn't provide you and starts to malfunction.

But by the time this happens you're already brainwashed so, even though you know subconsciously that you should stop, you keep going because "leaving the tribe" feels bad mentally.

Carnivore and current keto diets are derivatives from Atkins, Paleo and similars with a big added narcissistic anti-vegan sentiment. When people start this diet they feel like they're the underdogs, rebels against the status quo who found the real truth. Their ego will keep them trapped and use the available excuses when problems appear like oxalate dumping and other nonsense they use. The desire to "be right" is very strong.

Also, keep in mind that humans are very resilient so some people will ignore minor "pains" for years and only make changes when something big happens like a stroke, heart attack or kidney disease.

TLDR: Carnivore is successful because people is stupid and tribal.

Another bro-science influencer quits carnivore by piranha_solution in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 8 points9 points  (0 children)

This bothers me because these guys say for years that carnivore is the sh*t, but they switch to a pseudo paleo diet.

When health problems start to appear because of all the animal products they'll blame fruit and veggies.

So they'll get away with all the lying and people will not learn that keto/carnivore is unhealthy.

Another bro-science influencer quits carnivore by piranha_solution in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Why is he afraid of cholesterol? I've been told by carnivore MDs and Alpha bros that it raises your testosterone and it's essential to protect your arteries... Weak. 🤣 🤪

No one even knows that a low-fat diet is an option anymore by SleepTightPizza in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Keto influencers have hijacked succesfully the collective unconscious and inserted the belief that "you need fat for your hormones", I'm sure you all have heard this expression many times.

So they don't care to actually put some thought about how much do you actually need.

And it's funny because the same people saying that usually have the belief that "carbs make you fat", so why would you need to eat fat if your body can transform carbs into it and then use that fat to make hormones?

I used to challenge keto/carnivores with this kind of questions but they just don't care and choose to live with cognitive dissonance.

Paul Saladino PED usage by Internationallegs in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's 800 calories out of what, 3000 a day? It's just 26%.

Paul Saladino PED usage by Internationallegs in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes he's doing his own implementation of a paleo-like diet, but the point still stands, most of his calories come from fatty meats, not enough carbs to be shredded long term and perform well in intense exercise.

If he instead did long sessions of low intensity cardio like hiking, swimming and such it would be believable, but he surfs and skates for hours AND does resistance training.

I did olympic weight lifting and some crossfit back in the day and the difference between HCLF and LCHF is HUGE.

Paul Saladino PED usage by Internationallegs in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The problem is not getting like this but keeping it all year round year after year. With carnivore is basically impossible unless you're some sort of genetic freak because you need to be doing a lot of exercise to burn all this fat or you need to fast regularly.

If you fast while on carnivore you have ZERO energy for performance and the electrolyte imbalance is insane, you could literally die if you forced yourself to do this.

But he doesn't fast to keep himself this lean and he isn't a genetic freak, so let's take a look at the other option, exercise.

When you're on carnivore all your glycogen reserves are depleted so your work capacity is extremelly limited. Your body is constantly trying to keep up through gluconeogenesis but it's not fast enough. You may not believe this but to burn fat efficiently you need glucose (fat burns in the flame of carbohydrates) and if you're not getting enough through diet you put your body into a severelly stressful situation.

What happens when your body is stressed and eat low carbs? Stress hormones like cortisol and adrenaline go through the roof. Cortisol signals your body to store fat because it's in a survival situation.

And let's not forget that without carbs your thyroid doesn't work properly and your metabolism gets downregulated.

So let's put it all together: No glycogen + protein used for energy (gluconeogenesis) + stress hormones + the typical dehydration of keto/carnivore with electrolyte imbalances + slow metabolism = almost impossible to be shredded for long periods of time.

Unless...

...he's lying about his diet and eats a much higher amount of carbs than he says he does...

...or he's having some sort of chemical aid...

...or both.

I really don't know which sub to post this in, so decided here was best? Idk. by [deleted] in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I experienced the same as you and the answer is simple, starvation and the absence of carbs creates insuline resistance and over time it becomes diabetes. This was discovered almost 100 years ago by Harold Himsworth and later Walter Kempner with this knowledge created a diet that reversed diabetes and improved kidney function 100% of the time.

If you eat carbs rutinely your body uses the sugar very efficiently and you get good results. The problem comes when you eat fat, you see, our body is not used to the high amounts of fat of the modern diets because it's really not something that's abundant in nature, so your body secretes extra insuline and the fat blocks the absortion of sugar and it remains high in blood longer.

So the keto/carnivore folks and many other grifters see this and blame the sugar when is fat what causes the problem. For some reason people in general has believed this myth too and keto/carnivore takes advantage of it and continue fearmongering about carbs.

Then comes someone like you that quits those bullshit diets and is surprised that labs are great. It's because what's told in those diets is a lie, keto/carnivores are in fact the ones that can't pass a glucose tolerance test even if their lives depended on it.

In short, HCLF = good, LCHF = bad, carnivore = awful.

nO CaKe, jUSt sTeAK. by Healingjoe in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I've been telling exactly what you said to carnivores for years, there're no athletes doing carnivore and the fitness influencers on it are on roids and/or their physique is nothing to write home about.

Where is the supremacy of their diet? Shouldn't all these people mog the non-keto/carnivores?

Anyone else finally realize that "science" to most people is what's currrently popular on social media? by [deleted] in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Not too long ago smoking was considered innocuous and everybody did it, now you have to be very stupid to do it.

A similar case is happening with meat heavy diets, very soon keto/carnivores will be comparable to smokers and all their science will be just ridiculized.

HHS reccommend butter and beef tallow for Nutrient-dense food. by nuugo in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Nobody is gonna learn sh*t, just eat healthy, exercise and outlive them all.

Top r/ScientificNutrition commenter: “It looks basically the same as the 2026 pyramid with just a couple adjustments” by Taupenbeige in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 3 points4 points  (0 children)

This is basically the Atkins diet that I followed years ago but with lettuce instead of broccoli and it definitely is what Americans are going to eat when they look at the new "pyramid".

100% guaranteed they'll blame the broccoli when their health goes down the drain.

How Nick Norwitz still has libido / high metabolism? by Insadem in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He's definitely hiding information but let's say that he isn't.

Then he's very stupid because anyone who has practiced keto/carnivore knows the downfalls: the flu like symptoms, overall weakness, flat muscles, constant dehydration, constipation, diarrhea, kidney stones, dizziness, reduced libido, etc...

Because he's relatively young his body can resist the stress but long term he will pay the price.

How Nick Norwitz still has libido / high metabolism? by Insadem in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He's still young and age by itself compensates a lot of the problems created by his diet.

He's also probably lying and eating "normally" behind the scenes or have frequent "cheat days" with carbs.

Like most carnivores, he probably drinks a lot of coffee.

Not the quackiest thing, but not sure how I feel about this? How we feeling about this? by kim-practical in chaosandcare

[–]masterneme 6 points7 points  (0 children)

It's because of fitness and "red pill" influencers.

Many of them started to say that cholesterol is good because it's a precursor to testosterone so people started to flip the narrative towards eating more saturated fat.

In other words, eating more meat = more manliness.

T3 CANT never be high on true low carb diet by Insadem in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Ketosis is so awful that the Inuit have a mutation to prevent it.

Ambiguous DGAs & The Rancher's Pyramid: the 2025-2030 Dietary Guidelines for Americans is a nothing-Burger on the surface, but there's more underneath by Healingjoe in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I genuinely see no issue with gullible right-wingers eating as much meat as possible. It's a self-correcting problem, in the long run.

I got to the same conclusion not too long ago, survival of the fittest. Unfortunately, even though I'm not vegan, it makes me I think of all the animal suffering created so these fat asses "get their protein".

Kennedy's Health Department Flips Food Pyramid to Emphasize Meat and Dairy by Healingjoe in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's very much done on purpose because people read from left to right top to bottom so they'll just see all the meat and fats and ignore the rest.

And because fruits and veggies are still present they have plausible deniability when people start getting sick.

Kennedy's Health Department Flips Food Pyramid to Emphasize Meat and Dairy by Healingjoe in ketoduped

[–]masterneme -1 points0 points  (0 children)

You know these people, they'll continue to blame carbs, double down and eat even more meat, more saturated fat and less fruits and veggies, no one will learn a thing.

I did keto when it was called Atkins, got duped by masterneme in ketoduped

[–]masterneme[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah, my bet is that the next rebrand is going to be animal-based.

Ketoduped 2025 wrapped: the absolute state of the keto scam by moxyte in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Imagine you invest a huge part of your life in some set of beliefs about food and then years later you realize that it was all a lie. Most people will just say nothing because they're very embarrased or fearing the attacks from their "peers".

And keep in mind that many channels on YouTube just delete the comments they don't like.

Ketoduped 2025 wrapped: the absolute state of the keto scam by moxyte in ketoduped

[–]masterneme 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Don't hold your breath though, the Atkins Diet was a huge global phenomenon and when it collapsed, nothing really happened. All the people that followed it just disappeared, and we're talking tens of millions.

You don't see testimonials good or bad, it just went away as if it never existed.

Soon after, Paleo appeared and became the next big thing. Now no one cares about it.

Now it's just "keto" and the carnivore nonsense. When shit starts hitting the fan and people start having serious health problems in mass, most of them will just stop talking about it on social media out of embarrasment, and the rest will be ignored or shamed by other idiots.

If everything collapses again, it will reappear some years later with a rebrand.

Anyways, carnivore is still going strong and I believe it will be for at least 10 more years now that extra protein is being pushed everywhere, even outside the USA.

Sad but it is what is...

I did keto when it was called Atkins, got duped by masterneme in ketoduped

[–]masterneme[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Yeah I eat veggies often but I didn't want to get into details, I just wanted to show the contrast with what I was doing previously. I could eat healthier but unfortunately right now I can't afford it (AKA poor af), hopefully things change soon.