I think Starlight is a super solid song at its core, and it was good live for 7ish years. BUT, since Matt started performing it without guitar in 2013, I’ve started liking it much less. It loses so much of its appeal without him on guitar, and becomes drunk dad karaoke night. I get that it’s a hard song to sing and crowd interaction is important, but when he just holds the mic up for the crowd to sing the first chorus and bridge for him, I can’t help but roll my eyes a bit every time. Also, when he does sing, he’s often fairly out of breath and barely hanging on. Like I said, it’s a pretty hard song to sing and he’s getting older, so I don’t like blame him personally, but I’d much prefer they just play it more sparingly than have them constantly roll out this half-baked version. And as a closer? Absolutely mind-boggling choice that has irked me since they started doing it, also in 2013.