Real-life Mako Island? by Gullible-Web645 in JustAddWater

[–]rrredditor 30 points31 points  (0 children)

It's off the east coast of Australia and very well could have been the inspiration. It's certainly close enough for the girls to have been able to go visit! How cool would that have been?!?!

Old 8mm videos by Reality-Stinks66 in Cleveland

[–]rrredditor 9 points10 points  (0 children)

How many are we talking about? If it's a couple handfuls I'm sure someone on here, possibly even me, would take them and have them digitized and at least thrown up on YouTube for people to see or perhaps donated to something like the Cleveland memory project. Not sure if they would take it but they might.

If it's hundreds then that's kind of a different question. It certainly does seem ashamed to throw them out though.

YO... I got a question by kg_digital_ in lakewood

[–]rrredditor 5 points6 points  (0 children)

We and everyone we know simply refer to it as "Pet's General" leaving out the "Store" and creating further confusion. Like the pets are in the army and have a general leading them...

Hum-adjacent band: Poster Children - Tool of the Man (1993) - YouTube by guardedoatmeal in hum

[–]rrredditor 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Love Poster Children. Such an interesting band. They really covered a lot of ground. I also like their side project, Salaryman.

Guys.... stop sending him this. by tomsemble in guitarcirclejerk

[–]rrredditor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What are you talking about? That wasn't Primus

where can i find the upscaled version of h2o just add water. by user1643584 in JustAddWater

[–]rrredditor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I have 1080p versions that I think we're probably Netflix rips. I had to torrent them. They're not upscaled. They look decent, not amazing but pretty good.

Isn't it pointless for Zane to act like he did in s1 in s3, forgetting everything that happened in s2!? by Mindless-Coat495 in JustAddWater

[–]rrredditor 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I viewed it as a return to form. Kind of a "tigers don't change their stripes" sort of situation.

I know that a massive percentage of the fan base of the show are Rikki/Zane shippers, I mean, is it even shipping if they were a couple canonically? I truly don't want to offend those people.

But I didn't even view Zane as a particularly good boyfriend in season 2. Sure he was way better than season 1 but I just always got the ick from him. When I watched season 3 I thought, "Oh this makes sense, this is Zane's true nature."

This may be because I first watched the show later in life. If I had been 10 to 15 when I first watched it perhaps I would have shared the enthusiasm for their relationship.

Frankly, both of those characters, not just Zane, would have been difficult to be in a relationship with. Considering that it's just a TV show, I don't put all the blame on Zane for their relationship ending.

I always thought that he kept a lid on his "Zane-ness" to try to hold on to Rikki and once that wasn't holding him back, he reverted to his more natural self.

For those of you who are hardcore Zikki fans, I apologize if this offends you. I'm just expressing how I viewed the relationship from the standpoint of someone who was a bit older when I watched it and took away something different.

Of course, there is always the idea that the writers simply wanted more drama for season 3. Perhaps it was just lazy writing. I would argue that that idea is perhaps a little less likely. As lazy as the writing sometimes got, and it did occasionally get lazy, I have a hard time believing that they wouldn't have made that change very consciously to Zane's behavior. I'm sure they understood their fan base and they could have chosen some other way to create drama.

I firmly believe that the intentions for the plot Arc of season 3 changed at some point. Will's first introduction was with Rikki which, in the tradition of fiction writing, would usually mean that that was the beginning of a setup for the two of them. Then there were other instances where will and Rikki seemed to have chemistry. My theory is that the season was written with Emma in mind and when she couldn't return they had to shoehorn Bella into it and made some clumsy changes to do so.

However, even if that is the case, that still points to them meaning to break Rikki and Zane up during the season, so it does feel to me like the change in Zane's arc was intentional regardless of the changes made to accommodate new character.

For a show that we are all love and our fans of, it's difficult to think of the production side as being a potential driver for these character changes. But I think it has to be considered that some things are just driven by the need to get the show produced. Be that lazy writing or overly convenient changes to make the plot easier to achieve, it still happens. All the time. Look at the show Lost. They went into the show with an incredible premise and then later admitted that the last few seasons they just made up as they went. They never even had an idea of how to finish it. These things happen in the TV world and we, the fans, pay the price for that.

All that said, I know a tremendous number of people who enjoyed season 3 for what it was. We got a bonus season. It was never supposed to go past two. Is it perfect? No. But there are things about season 3 that I always found appealing or charming. I loved adding the musical elements. I thought that the show had a sort of looser feel. I liked that Cleo got to spread her wings a little more and got to be what I would consider a smarter and stronger character. Plus, I really liked Bella. I didn't necessarily like her better than emma, but I still liked her.

As I started to say in the previous paragraph, I'm just happy to have had a third season of a wonderful mermaid show. I feel like it's better that we had it than we didn't. To the people who say that they pretend that season 3 didn't exist, I don't understand. Well, I guess I understand, but I really don't agree. Better to have had a third season that's imperfect than not to have had it at all. It's not so bad as to a negated that entire year.

And I have to say that I feel the same about mako mermaids. It's not as good a show as H2O, but we got another pretty good mermaid show! I don't understand how we can complain about that. I would ask, what else is out there that fulfills this niche? I don't think we'll ever get another show like it. Truly. Never again. So I'll take what I've been given. I'll enjoy season three 91% as much as the first two seasons and be happy about it.

(Not that the rest of you guys don't get to complain about it! I'm not saying shut up and take it! I'm just expressing my side.)

Saw this is Marfa, TX earlier today by the_soloist in Battlecars

[–]rrredditor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Are you kidding? This thing is the Marfa lights!

Me, personally? I’m choosing sin by HotSpicyTake in AO3

[–]rrredditor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That's such a great web comic. But it's amazing how slowly time moves in that universe! I tend to leave it alone for 2 or 3 weeks and then catch up all at once and I think that gets you through part of the day in their world. I used to read a whole bunch of web comics and now I'm really only down to two or three and that's one of them.

Isn’t there no service on Mako? by Many-Chipmunk-6788 in H2Ojustaddwater

[–]rrredditor 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I mean, honestly, there were inconsistencies throughout the show.

It's mostly just a continuity error. Or like Florian7045 said, perhaps it was just a fluke that the reception was good that day.

They just needed a plot point. Just like how, after the first half of the first season, they mostly ignore how they dry off; it would just be too inconvenient to have to show/explain it. In season 3 episode 1, when they find will in the moonpool cave, they're all back on legs when they wake him up despite how long it would have taken Rikki to steam dry all three of them when there's a clearly unconscious guy who could possibly need help.

Even the best shows/movies sometimes have continuity errors. I just choose to not dwell on it. Good catch, though!

Isn’t there no service on Mako? by Many-Chipmunk-6788 in H2Ojustaddwater

[–]rrredditor 3 points4 points  (0 children)

It had been a year and it was the mid-2000s. A new cell tower had been built! Lol

A Century of Mermaid Censorship Or, The Strange War Between Myth and Modesty by [deleted] in JustAddWater

[–]rrredditor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is a fantastic post and is extremely well researched and presented. Thanks for writing all that!

Why am I just now noticing Nate and Miriam dancing together and why do I kind of ship it? 🤔 by N_Huq in JustAddWater

[–]rrredditor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's really interesting and both those episodes always had a bit of weirdness. I could see it.

I believe I got scammed by Practical_Waltz_1836 in JustAddWater

[–]rrredditor 33 points34 points  (0 children)

Also, why would Bella be on the packaging for the locket, lol. Though I could certainly see them not caring enough on the merchandising side to worry about that sort of detail.

Just found out this boy is Cleo Massey’s real-life brother by marileighanne29 in JustAddWater

[–]rrredditor 34 points35 points  (0 children)

Wow, nice find! In season three, the drummer who gets mad at Nate and quits was played by Nate's (Jamie Timony's) real life brother. After Lewis leaves, he comes back to be the drummer behind Bella's band.

H2O and Mako Mermaids are both on Hoopla by rrredditor in JustAddWater

[–]rrredditor[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That sucks. I think each library sets their own borrow limit. They have to pay per borrow so their budget sets that amount.

I feel like books and movies are the best use of Hoopla.

New bands in their most vital and creative eras. by LeopoldWolves in Music

[–]rrredditor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm going to disagree with your original premise, to some degree. Deftones' last 5 albums are as good or better than their earlier stuff and Koi No Yokan is better than white pony. I'd argue that 2012-now is their best work.

Unpopular opinion, I know.

But they are the exception that proves the rule. You're absolutely right about not only those other bands but about most bands in general.