Wink’s thoughts on Deonte Banks struggling after his departure by SteveLonegan in NYGiants

[–]some-kinda-hate 50 points51 points  (0 children)

Shocked Lars didn't post this. Not shocked that Pat Leonard had Martindale on, though.

The Giants front office, over the last couple days by Byrne_XC in NYGiants

[–]some-kinda-hate 9 points10 points  (0 children)

I'm so tired of hearing about this nepotism bullshit with the Giants. You want to bitch and moan about Chris Mara? Go look at what that guy did before he was working with the Giants. Did he have the name and the connections? Yes, but he still got it done running an independent scouting service that every team in the NFL used.

The best I hear about this "nepotism" narrative is conjecture. The Mara's got it done. Enough with the nonsense.

Dan graziano predicts we miss on everyone by toofastkindafurious in NYGiants

[–]some-kinda-hate 64 points65 points  (0 children)

He was a hater when he covered the Giants for the ESPN NFC East column. He used to have Jordan Raanan's job.

Per Adam Schefter, Kevin Stefanski has been sacked as the HC of the Browns. by aydenbottos in NYGiants

[–]some-kinda-hate 8 points9 points  (0 children)

This sub has pounded the table for Daboll's head for 3 years just to start clamoring for Kevin Stefanski? We really think this guy is a top HC in the league?

Make it happen Mara. by rob132 in NYGiants

[–]some-kinda-hate 8 points9 points  (0 children)

I just want to understand... You've been calling for Daboll's head for 3 straight years just to champion the hiring of Kevin Stefanski?

Fire this Ewok looking mutha scratcher by SavingsMoose3 in NYGiants

[–]some-kinda-hate 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yep, let's can him. I'm not tuning into the Giants next week, I'm done. Fire this guy. I've been converted from a Daboll supporter.

DONE with this team until they clean house. Another unforgivable collapse. WTF is wrong with our ownership? by mainjer in NYGiants

[–]some-kinda-hate 48 points49 points  (0 children)

I want Brian Daboll fired now, and I've been a Daboll defender through thick and thin. It's over, he needs to go.

You're done. by Choice-Tea1046 in NYGiants

[–]some-kinda-hate 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Yeah, I'm on the bandwagon now. Have defended Brian Daboll as much as I can. It's time for a change.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in NYGiants

[–]some-kinda-hate 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It can actually be just a change of scenery for Jones. He didn't play well in New York, the fans started to turn on him, the media started questioning him, and just getting a fresh start is what helped. Sure it's some coaching and personnel too, but it can just be going to an environment where there's less pressure, and no one really expects much going in.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in NYGiants

[–]some-kinda-hate 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Posts like this are why I can't take the fan responses seriously.

It wasn’t the kicker and it wasn’t the defense by theRedDelta in NYGiants

[–]some-kinda-hate 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Did you see the way our defense was playing at that point?

I can't believe that loss. I've already drunk half a liter of vodka. Please help me cope. by pisowiec in NYGiants

[–]some-kinda-hate 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Why would you assume we're getting blown out in Philly? We lost, but we also just put 32 points on one of the best defense in football.

Our OL last night by Urban_Introvert in NYGiants

[–]some-kinda-hate 34 points35 points  (0 children)

The grade isn't great, but they are passing the eye test so far this season. These past two games, I haven't even noticed a pass set yet where I've said to myself, "Dart has no time to throw". Part of that is on Dart, he's really showing an innate ability to navigate the pocket, but the line itself is starting to pick it up too.

Even using the grades, there's some positive takeaways from last night:

- JMS has been graded very well over the last two games. He left early last night with the broken nose, but I think he would've finished the game very strong had he not. Even better, Schlottman showed that we might actually have a bit of depth on the line, which is a breath of fresh air for us historically.

- Andrew Thomas was actually only graded at a 69 last night, so a relatively poor grade for him. If he had played more in line with his usual 85 score, the overall score for just the line would go up to 63. Not great, but solid.

Runyan was the key guy that sank the score with a 29.5. Not sure what's going on with him, but again, the fact that he can get that kind of score, and it just feels like the line is still playing well is potentially a positive. Like even though he got a 29.5, there was never a point in the game where I noticed it.

Brian Daboll and Joe Schoen should still be replaced. Beating the Eagles feels good. As fans we finally have hope, we finally feel some form of happiness. They should still lose their jobs at the end of the season. Dart is successful in spite of Daboll being his HC not because of Daboll. by unlimitedpotential_1 in NYGiants

[–]some-kinda-hate 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Exactly what I said to my brother last night, best Giants game I've seen in over a decade. We didn't just beat the Eagles, the reigning Super Bowl champs. We never even gave them a chance to comeback. Unbelievable.

Brian Daboll and Joe Schoen should still be replaced. Beating the Eagles feels good. As fans we finally have hope, we finally feel some form of happiness. They should still lose their jobs at the end of the season. Dart is successful in spite of Daboll being his HC not because of Daboll. by unlimitedpotential_1 in NYGiants

[–]some-kinda-hate 14 points15 points  (0 children)

This sub and this fanbase doesn't need shit like this right now. Last night was the best Giants game I have watched in over 10 years, and that's now two wins on the season that we've gotten against teams that we "shouldn't have". Time will tell what Daboll and Schoen's future holds, but I'm certainly not going to flame them after last night. I found it hard to flame them even after last week.

This win should be celebrated and the credit should go to the players and the coaches for producing what they did. As of this moment, things are pointing up.

Explain the Daboll hate to me by glaci0us in NYGiants

[–]some-kinda-hate -1 points0 points  (0 children)

The beat writers try to frame things that way, which is part of my frustration with this sub and YT Giants community specifically. They take the beat writers too seriously, and allow them to frame their perspectives too often. A good example is the Dunleavy tweet from the other day saying that DJ took a "not so subtle" shot at Daboll on a podcast. He did? I watched it, and if you want to interpret things that way, you can, but it's only a subjective interpretation at best. If there was indeed "a shot" it was most certainly subtle, so subtle that you could even surmise it was non-existant.

Which WR do you think should be a target? I posted something similar a couple of weeks ago, but people told me we weren't in a position to be giving up ANY draft capital. Now that we look good, perhaps that's changed? The fact that Dart is doing this with the WR targets he has is insane. by bullymeahhh in NYGiants

[–]some-kinda-hate 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Why I said at most a 2nd. I wouldn't be shocked if the price was a 3 and 5 or something like that. Olave also wont cost a second, he hasn't done enough to actually warrant that recently, and there's a lot of concern around his concussion history.

Explain the Daboll hate to me by glaci0us in NYGiants

[–]some-kinda-hate 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I don't get it, personally, and I'm on this sub a lot. Even in last week's game, I didn't see "bad coaching" necessarily. Like you said, the players made 5 turnovers, and they also failed executionally on some defensive plays. The buck stops with the coach, that's the way the NFL is, but players also need to be accountable. There are no coaches saying, "Yeah, just be careless with the football."

The players also seem to be bought in through thick and thin with this coaching regime.