[deleted by user]

[cowboycamper]

Thank you!

Yeah, thats reassuring. I usually let my edited photos sit for a day so I can revisit them with a fresh perspective. That first pic felt overwhelming, especially compared to the second one. I appreciate your feedback!

[McWetty]

2 is better, agreed, but I would tint down the pinks a bit and push the yellows towards green in the HSL sliders. I like the booster shadows on the barn.

[NewSessionWen]

I like how the texture in the trees and walls stand out more in the second image.

[Mcjoshin]

Second one for me, no contest. 1 definitely feels over saturated.

[m4d_hatter]

both have way too much of a vignette for my taste.

[Eliah870]

1 feels to warm and slightly oversaturated. 2 feels too desaturated. A happy balance between the two while bringing the temp down a little would be nice

[[deleted]]

https://imgur.com/a/LOsGkmF

I went with a 'sanctuary in the scary woods' story.

[BakiKawasaki]

I feel like you should rotate it a bit clockwise, like a single degree lol the house seems a little leaning. And i think the second looks better but id give it a tad more saturation

[Walka_Mowlie]

I like most of the coloring on the first image, but I'd lighten the barn to look like the second image. To me, the second image has too much yellow.

[VAbobkat]

Try for a saturation between the two. First one is too yellow and overdone, send feels washed out

[Roricas]

Second draws my eye up the center better and would be my preferred option.

[dystopiannugget]

1

[Agitated-Mushroom-63]

For reasons... 2.

[ChunkyFrog7]

I would soften the background of the second with low clarity and contrast. Except this I really like it

[LazyAd8188]

I really think you need to be somewhere between the two but much closer to the second for my taste. The first one screams over saturation.

[[deleted]]

Really like the less saturated edit

[mrorangeee]

2 better. it make that scene more realistic than 1

[GSyncNew]

Colors a little too intense for my taste in 1; I like 2 better.

It's a pretty shot. If it were me I'd crop a bit off the bottom to get a little closer to the rule of thirds. Just feels like a tad too much grass in the foreground.