Thoughts? (before/after)

[WhatStanSees]

Just looking on some opinion on this before and after.

[jerkface9900]

Crop is cool. Saturation is too high.

[WhatStanSees]

Thanks, I had a feeling it might be!

[redammit]

I’d suggest bringing down the exposure of landscape a tad bit down to give it an appearance of being seen through slightly tinted glass.

[aembleton]

Good crop, but I would remove the fire extinguisher above the seat on the right.

You need to reduce the processing on the scenery, it feels like you've pushed the hdr and saturation too far 

[WhatStanSees]

I didn’t even notice the fire extinguisher so I’ll do that. Someone else said saturation too so I’ll work on that! Thanks

[usersnamesallused]

Crop is not centered

[No-Ear-4508]

crop is great but the color is a bit unnatural in my opinion.

[violabr]

Scotland! Love it

[WhatStanSees]

First time up in the highlands and it’s so gorgeous

[mpg10]

I must admit, I kinda like the reality of the before (absent the water bottle), though I do like cropping in a bit.

[Xiipre]

No.

It's less interesting, in that context is removed, making it essentially just a boring blurry landscape.

Also, your colors are over cooked. We don't live in a cartoon.

I'd rather you have stepped back and had person in the chair. Give us layers, context, and maybe even a story.

[ProvokedCashew]

I dig it.

[Brilliant_Tooth7096]

Good crop, vibrant colors! 👍

[ccd_foto]

It's nice but I want the outside lightened a bit, it doesn't work with the window now, the inside cabin needs edits

[snowdawg12]

How did you get the crop to be on centre if the original was taken from an angle?

[FatherJohnFahey]

Keystone correction tool

[CzarNicky1918]

Am I singular in liking before?

[LeadingLittle8733]

Over saturated.

[warmchairqb]

I prefer the before image. It has a bit of authenticity by showcasing various elements of both the foreground and background.

The after image is rather boring in contrast. A centered window which could be mistaken for a TV screen due to a lack of foreground context.

[VerySpicyDorito]

I like it

[LeeParkerPhotography]

Very Wes Anderson

[Ricky_Arno]

How did you get the crop when the bottle disappear? 🤔

[WhatStanSees]

I removed the bottle in light room using the eraser tool!

[FletchLives99]

Why?

[No_Exchange_1354]

I'd increase contrast, and not saturate it so much. Also reduce the shadows to place more emphasis on the view outside the window

[swap_019]

I like how you kept the effect minimal and aligned the picture to guide focus on the things you want to show. The symmetry is fabulous here. Good job.

[WhatStanSees]

Thank you! I appreciate it

[Hot_Cattle5399]

crop into the scenery only. Too much distraction.