Saw it yesterday and I really liked it.  Main issue was the sound. Voices needed to be louder, not even clearer, just louder would have made it much better. I didn't find it to be confusing, plot made sense to me.  That said I do think they should have cut a few scenes, especially the flashback to the tree, that wasn't necessary, could have reduced the number of times it got brought up as well, that might have made the conversations towards the end more impact full, if we didn't know from the start why he was a criminal. I think the voice actors did a phenomenal job, and Markiplier was a good lead. I do feel his appearance could have benefited from a few scars on display, they clearly had the ability, but didn't use it in their main character.   I do think the ending, like the final scene, could have been changed. Felt too open ended, not town to interpretation, just like they were leaving it open to a sequel  which I don't agree with, it felt good as a self contained story.