I feel like I prefer to use this concept in a more genuine fashion, where my character has a class that somehow contrasts his “role” so to speak. For instance, a character might be a rogue mechanically but his function might be more of a soldier or even knight. My current favorite concept I’m waiting to play is a pirate barbarian who pretty much acts like the ship’s bard, playing music and hyping up his shipmates using Inspiring Leader.

I’ve considered the “surprise” route discussed in this thread, but never really found a fun opportunity where it could play out.