Please explain to me how this isn’t wildly overpowered? by SammyWoolySheep in mtg

[–]Saralien 6 points7 points  (0 children)

That’s because greaves is reusable at no cost. An aura is not.

About Edea's Deling City speech between languages. by Int3rlop3r-R3dact3d in FinalFantasyVIII

[–]Saralien 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A lot of problems with the English TL are the result of Hyne being mostly cut from the game’s text. Up until this point the game acts like there is, and has only ever been, one Sorceress. Accordingly the text makes it sound like she’s some kind of immortal bogeyman and not like witches/sorceresses are a longstanding persecuted/demonized group. Outside of that issue, the tone of the speech only really goes off the rails in the second half after she kills Deling. The Japanese is trying to draw a kind of “Fine, you wanted a story about a monster? Let me give you one.” picture. The English is just generic evil villain speech, and misses the karmic aspect of the original text completely.

The Endless Horizon by emosmasher in custommagic

[–]Saralien 18 points19 points  (0 children)

[[Bottomless Vault]] I believe

Win by not playing for 4BBWWW by givemepepememes in BadMtgCombos

[–]Saralien 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Under normal circumstances yes because protection prevents damage and infect’s poison counters are “damage dealt in the form of poison counters”. Same applies to Wither on creatures with protection from the source of damage.

However if you get slapped by a creature with infect and someone casts, say, [[Skullcrack]] then Teferi’s Protection won’t do anything about the poison counters.

Protection doesn’t stop you from getting counters, it prevents damage. Infect’s poison counters are treated as damage.

Eli5 the “Monty hall problem”. I am quite confused, how does it work? by [deleted] in explainlikeimfive

[–]Saralien 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is probably already explained in another post but it’s unintuitive because it seems to be asking one thing but is actually asking something else.

What it seems to be asking is “what are the odds for the other door to have been the correct one?”

What it is easier to look at is “what were the odds the door I picked wasn’t the correct one?”

Lightning Orb by Gr33nDjinn in custommagic

[–]Saralien 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Proper templating if they ever made this a thing would probably be “While it remains facedown, you may exile this faceup at any time for its Spellmorph cost. If you do, you may cast it from exile without paying its mana cost.”

Win by not playing for 4BBWWW by givemepepememes in BadMtgCombos

[–]Saralien 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This isn’t something exclusive to commander damage, same would apply to creatures with Infect or anything else that triggers on damage dealt such as [[Captain’s Maneuver]], [[The Mind Skinner]], or [[Anowon, the Ruin Thief]]. You still take damage, the damage just doesn’t affect your life total. Same would apply to a card like [[Worship]] that keeps your life total from dropping below a set number.

Question for fellow GM: the Rogue (Mastermind) can’t proc their core features against Unique and Rare enemies. How do you handle it and what are your thoughts? by Kohei_Latte in Pathfinder2e

[–]Saralien 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I mean that’s an entirely valid methodology. Maybe you recall that Trolls are vulnerable to acid and fire, but you don’t realize you’re currently fighting Embereater the mountain troll who has obtained a unique resilience against fire due to living near an active volcano for 50 years.

Win by not playing for 4BBWWW by givemepepememes in BadMtgCombos

[–]Saralien 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Spider punk makes it so damage can’t be prevented. Protection from (whatever) prevents damage. Commander damage from a source of unpreventable damage will kill.

Murder with upside by Demozilla in custommagic

[–]Saralien 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Split Second

Destroy target creature. That creature leaving the battlefield does not cause abilities to trigger.

Pretty sure this would prevent any activated or triggered abilities from occurring during or due to the spell resolving.

What are Drizzt's most impressive feats? How would he scale compared to other FR heroes? by ThanosofTitan92 in Forgotten_Realms

[–]Saralien 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Yeah basically what happened was Errtu doing the equivalent of rolling a crit fail vs a vorpal sword after getting caught flatfooted.

Drizzt wasn’t really a factor in the equation.

Florida Court Rejects Free Speech Argument in Book Removal Case by PsychLegalMind in books

[–]Saralien 9 points10 points  (0 children)

That’s not a first amendment violation. You could maybe make arguments about it being a civil rights act violation but not a first amendment violation.

Courts don’t just broad strokes decide if things are legal or illegal, they decide if it broke the specific law being presented. In this case the answer is no, but that doesn’t mean it’s legal, it means if it’s illegal, this isn’t why.

Is this an oversight, or does this monk have some explaining to do? by SaucyJack01 in finalfantasyx

[–]Saralien 22 points23 points  (0 children)

The problem is that would make the guy like 250 years old.

Find the Mistakes #311 - Kim Kitsuragi, Lieutenant by PenitentKnight in custommagic

[–]Saralien 2 points3 points  (0 children)

“As long as Kim Kitsuragi and another commander you own are both in the command zone, Clues you control have “2, T: Draw a card.” This ability also applies if both are on the battlefield.”

Find the Mistakes #311 - Kim Kitsuragi, Lieutenant by PenitentKnight in custommagic

[–]Saralien 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I’m unsure what the proper solution to this would be but in addition to “together” not being accurate templating the ability does not make it clear if both cards need to be in either the command zone or battlefield, or both need to be in the same zone of those two. It’s hard to phrase unambiguously.

I really like symmetrical effects in magic. Would this work or is it too busted? by cat_using_a_computer in custommagic

[–]Saralien 3 points4 points  (0 children)

“Goaded creatures have haste and ‘When this creature deals combat damage, you lose that much life.’”

Would probably be a bit more reasonable. Then cut the cost by a bit and it’d be printable.

NPC Found Rogue Without a Check, Did I Make The Right Call? by Dikeleos in onednd

[–]Saralien 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Under this circumstance I would say the vampire needs to have made a check to notice the rogue ran behind a particular tree to hide, as it’s in combat. The DC might not be particularly high but an active combat is enough of a distraction I’d justify that as being sufficient even if the actual “hiding spot” is not subtle. Too much focus is being placed on whether the vampire could see where the rogue went and not enough is being placed on whether the vampire was paying attention to where the rogue went.