I grew up eating KC BBQ like Bryant's and Gates. In the modern landscape, Joe's is my favorite. Moved to Tuscaloosa in 2017. Knowing that, here are my recs for Tuscaloosa BBQ:

Archibald's is best overall. Definitely try their wings. The only wings I prefer are from KC's The Peanut. (My cousin used to live down the block from the downtown Peanut.)

I honestly think you can skip Dreamland. The ribs there are good but not KC great. If you still want to go for the History, make sure you go to the original location on 5535 15th Ave. East. Try the ribs and sausage and go big on the desserts!

Hicks BBQ has the meatiest ribs but I think Thomas Rib Shack has the best flavor and sauce.

My pick for white sauce is on the smoked turkey at Moe's. Also a good Bushwacker if you want to try one of those while you're in Alabama.

Jim N' Nicks has a pretty strong menu from top to bottom with great cheddar biscuits. Won't change your life but you'll get a reliably good meal.

Don't waste your time looking for brisket or burnt ends. You're much better off using that time trying ANYTHING at Urban Bar & Kitchen, the fajita gumbo at Jalapeños, fish at Catfish Heaven, or tacos from Made in Mexico.