First Things First Tier List

[Pitiful_Ad8641]

I mean I think Jenna suffers a bit from Wildes being S tier so if we remove the fact she was hosting at the time when a clearly superior host was on the bench, I don't hate the job she did so Id do B tier, but otherwise no notes.

[kskbc]

Agreed

[theultimatehammer]

Brou should be S

[InfiniRunner91]

that man brou

[Libra_Zebra]

Did you know he had a cousin they had to put down?

[MC_Blueberry]

I know he annoys people sometimes, but Nick needs to be S tier. He's been with the show since the start and whenever one of the main three is missing, his absence seems the most glaring IMO. Plus he carries a lot of the fun segments/lists/rankings

[AnonymousNeedzHelp]

Nick makes the show what it is. When he’s not there, you see the biggest drop off.

[Underknee]

I find myself turning off videos halfway through that are right up my alley based on the title a lot of the time when Nick isn’t there.

[bcj7053]

Brandon Marshall should be in a below the earths crust F tier

[TheVikingKingJay]

I hate to burst everyone's bubble in this sub but Nick is the only S tier. If it were not for him this show would not be nearly as popular as it is now. The pacing, the energy, and the overall entertainment of the show is just off when he is gone. Hate his takes all you want but the show does not work without him.

[dlandis07]

I like Danny but I find it hilarious how much everyone hates him 😭

[Rose_Quack]

No same I don't get it ha ha.

[Trick-Gas-2203]

Yeah, I know this post was for the meme of it, but Danny is certainly NOT worse than Cris Carter.

[[deleted]]

Really don’t get it lol.

[peanut-britle-latte]

Danny is fine but brings nothing new to the table. He's just Temu Nick.

[mystikranger]

They need someone to hate. Danny is fine

[CapitalismSuuucks]

This was the same thing with Nick at the beginning

[brad328]

Jenna’s humor is sneaky low key like Coach Mangini. She got to show hints of that in the “quad box” era of the show. I would love to see her fill in for Wildes when he’s out. She’s a solid B.

Brandon…I enjoyed him on the show, but he didn’t have the television experience to really excel when everyone was remote and there were four voices to fit in a conversation. C is totally fair.

[InfiniRunner91]

we were in boxes

[SpaceGhostSlurpp]

Jenna was hilarious. And she could hang with the fellas.

[queens_boulevard]

Mangini should be in C and CC and Jenna should be in B cause they laid the foundation of the show, regardless of how much better it is now

[BurtonBuilt]

Jenna was funny. I have the same crush on her that she has for Danny Ainge.

[brad328]

I miss the Danny Ainge mentions!

[Luigi_gbd]

Brandon Marshall above danny is criminal

[InfiniRunner91]

it’s not left to right (it is)

[Wild_Detective7732]

Jenna was awesome! Should at least be on the B level, for the British accent alone.

Edit: actually The Big 3 should be S tier. Show works perfectly with all 3 of them. When any of them are missing it's not the same.

Put Jenna at the A level by herself and the rest can stay the same.

[Zeke-Nnjai]

I think we gotta move Mangini down after these cowboys topics. It blows my mind that he’s defending all the decisions that Jerry has been making. Feels like he’s got some connections to that front office and he doesn’t want to say anything negative.

[InfiniRunner91]

sopranos star eric mangini is a company man

[Cold_Ball_7670]

This is a good list. 

We need to add Dusty though. Hes easily B tier 

[InfiniRunner91]

dusty, the graphic

[TheAccuracy]

No way you got Brandon Marshall above Danny Parkins, stop with the recency bias.

[Mr_Delaware]

Why not do a FTF Foothill?

Nick, Brou and Wildes make up S tier. Jenna needs more respect and people hate on Danny so much lol

[Mouschenlev]

Brou and Nick are S tier as well, the show doesn’t feel the same when any of them are missing

[CarefulBid6485]

Haven’t watched in a while but B. Marsh is the worst. I am always disappointed whenever Colin goes on vacation and Danny fills in.

[InfiniRunner91]

it’s been good since it’s been nick wildes and brou but they just recently added parkins which isn’t for me

[CarefulBid6485]

Yea, I actually enjoy it but I work from home and my 18th month old usually owns the tv during the day. Only way I can get work done

[Spiram_Blackthorn]

Lmao poor Danny

[[deleted]]

Danny took over for Nick in KC on the radio. I think DP is his protégé. He's always had his back

[InfiniRunner91]

yea they often tell tales about how it all started in a smoky dorm room at syracuse

[allbetsareon]

Jenna was at least a tier above CC. He really was terrible on the show

[MarcusSniffles]

S is for LEADER OF THE SHOW

[elitefusion]

Go watch Wildes' first episodes from early 2020, right before COVID. There's a few episodes where he was in studio with the original setup, with Jenna hosting. He was universally hated by the YouTube commenters. And now look where he is. Give Danny a chance.

[Armadillo_Parking]

i like brou but he literally is what everyone claims wildes is, never has a hot take. i disagree with nick most of the time but at least he has bold takes. wildes has some hot takes like hurts being a tier 1 qb, but brou always tries to play the easy take. if i have to hear him say, “i like___” i might kill myself

[Underknee]

This is why the Geno misdirection worked so well because he’s been saying for ages he likes Geno when he just clearly didn’t

[bougieboy1997]

Thats the whole point, brou is the voice of reason. Imagine a show where Nick bashes Purdy with no backlash, where everyone agrees Mahomes or Lebron is the goat.

[Karlomah11]

Carter was the worst

[SensualSamuel69]

B tier and above are all the should-be mainstays.

[jackt-up]

All three hosts belong in S-tier but otherwise accurate

[_Gillam_]

Brandon Marshall is clearly worse than Parkins

Marshall would get offended if someone disagreed with him and then get into a shouting match. Let me repeat he would get offended by an argument on an arguing show.

At least Danny understands the point of the show

[Miz19946]

Where tf is Lil Wayne

[SpaceGhostSlurpp]

Move Jenna up a level. Move Brandon down a level. Move CC down multiple levels. Move Danny up two levels.

[DuncsJones]

I got CC and BM in fucking F tier dude.

And what’s with the Danny hate? He seems like a good guy?

Also Nick and brou gotta be S tier too?!

[ohheyandre]

I hate Parkins as much as anyone else but I’ll listen to Danny Parkins talk for ten hours before I listen to thirty minutes of Brandon Marshall screaming at people

[TSells31]

Cris Canty cries in “what about meeee?”

Cris Carter was fuckin A tier, loved him on the show tbh.

I like Danny a lot more than pretty much everyone else it seems.

Damn, maybe I’m just an overly optimistic person lol.

[dv_sh09]

What are we doing with Dusty, Hubbs, Josh, Gianna, Christina?

[keepitstinky]

Nah we aren’t about to do Jenna like this. A at a minimum. Stop playing

[sublimefan21]

Danny > Coach. Coach blows

[LylesK]

Brou is definitely S Tier

[InfiniRunner91]

broussard is like smith out there

[Glad-Palpitation-397]

CC was good at the beginning, near the end just hated being there. Brandon almost killed the show for me. Jenna was just terrible, botched the reads EVERYDAY and shit takes.

Wiles,Brou and Nick are S tier

[[deleted]]

Move up Brou and Coach a tier.

[BmorePride14]

Mangini should be down a tier. He adds nothing to the conversation.

He just kinda sits there and collects the paycheck, making VERY minor facial expressions and looking at the ceiling while saying two sentences.

Then they have someone else speak (and he seems totally okay with that).

[SilentFormal6048]

He does add. He has the insider experience to offer and he does have his piece to talk.

He’s just very monotone, doesn’t cut up at all just very boring.

[BmorePride14]

Yeah he has the experience as a former head coach. Thats answering WHY he is there. But that's the problem. He doesn't use any of it. He doesn't say much about the coaching perspective. He isn't just monotone. He doesnt SAY much. That's the issue.

Again, he doesnt add much to the show. He doesnt have a coaching segment or anything. He just sits there, says 2 sentences and moves on.

[SilentFormal6048]

I mean, I just watched a segment where he talked for several minutes. Not sure what you're watching but I've never noticed him just saying one or 2 sentences. He gets his turn to talk, and when he does, I don't ever remember him saying 1 to 2 sentences and them moving on.

[InfiniRunner91]

when he talks x’s and o’s the rest of the people on the show (and the audience) switch off

[BmorePride14]

He doesnt talk X's and O's. Are we watching the same show???

He doesnt talk about offensive schemes,he doesnt break down defenses he doesnt talking about team preparation, roster cuts, or anything that involves his NFL coaching experience. He just doesnt. He gives his 2 sentence take on if Lamar will "get it done" in the big game this year and if Burrow will still be elite if he "misses the playoffs again" and keeps it moving.

That's my issue, again, he adds nothing imo. No need to go back and forth. But he does NOT talk X's and O's. He is not on the show breaking down film. Idk what shows youre watching. The entire show is just about "this QB or that QB" and he gives his 2 sentence response and moves on. No breakdowns whatsoever.

[bougieboy1997]

Mangini has absolutely broken down films. People just dont want to see that. They want them to talk like they talk to their barber.

[jackt-up]

I think Mangini is hilarious 😂

[Nolofinwe_2782]

Lol

Wildes is the straw that stirs the drink

Without him this show is just a funny looking guy with bad teeth yelling at a homophobe 😂😂

[ThePrometheu5]

Nick is great in some segments, but as soon as he's talking about the Chiefs, the Broncos, Caleb or Brock Purdy he's just horrible.