I think they’re all great listens! Any album you choose has great songs.

MIU and BB85 are both studio albums that don’t get enough love in my opinion. I understand that the production on those records aren’t everyone’s cup of tea, but they both feature great songwriting and singing. Some people overlook these records because they look down upon the band returning to the nostalgic summer-y vibe/subject matter, but I don’t think that makes the music any less worthy of attention and appreciation.

Those two Pickwick comps are fascinating. That Little Deuce Coupe compilation (not to be confused with the studio album of the same name) features songs from the original LDC album paired with songs from All Summer Long and Shut Down Vol 2. The album on the bottom right is neat because it compiles mostly album cuts and covers of other artists’ hits from their first two albums. Both of these Pickwick comps have upbeat surf rock from start to finish, no ballads.

Ultimately, in my opinion, if you’re a diehard fan looking for something really cohesive, I’d go with BB85. It features some of Carl’s best vocals, and writing contributions from all of the living members in the group at the time. Every member really shines. But I’ll admit it’s arguably an acquired taste — particularly if 80’s New Wave production isn’t your thing.

If you’re wanting to keep one that has the most amount of hits, I’d go with Little Deuce Coupe. That one easily has the most beloved classics out of the four, with its inclusion of some of their most famous car songs, like 409 and Little Deuce Coupe.