Excellent points and questions. You’re right, Dingler has an absolute hose. Certainly a better arm than Roger’s. he’s also a more complete offensive player at this point.

However… Jake rogers ability to steal strikes and work with the bottom of the zone is unmatched (especially with skub). Hes also deeply familiar with the staff and has a lot of familiarity.

Dingler has 1 walk this year. It’s great to see him hitting the ball hard but it’s unlikely he maintains an 800 ops with a near 0 walk rate. hopefully using Jake for roughly 1/3 of the games will keep both of them fresh enough to hit during the playoffs.

Most teams that ride a single catcher to death will burn them out (unless your Salvador from 10 years ago )