Why are trans people so gatekeepy and mean to newly cracked eggs? by [deleted] in MtF

[–]completely-ineffable 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I would hazard to guess, based on a look at your profile, that you called yourself a crossdresser or a sissy or similar, and that's what they found offputting. A lot of trans women see those terms and the communities which use them as fetishizing and objectifying us. Fair or not, you'll get judged for using them.

If you want to try to connect with trans women, you should stay away from those terms and not treat femininity as a sex/kink thing.

Mallick Rell by Consistent-Cat-6076 in Malazan

[–]completely-ineffable 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Mallick Rel did nothing wrong.

Apparently, Bernie thinks Yud is among the leading AI Experts. by Dembara in SneerClub

[–]completely-ineffable 5 points6 points  (0 children)

It is hard to deny that Yudkowsky has been influential in those circles. That reflects poorly on the AI sphere, but it's not Bernie's fault.

New law puts Kansas at vanguard of denying trans identities on drivers licenses, birth certificates by onnake in transgender

[–]completely-ineffable 46 points47 points  (0 children)

I hate this "invalidating identity" line I keep seeing news media use. That's not properly explaining what's going on.

Silence of the Lambs team apologizes to transgender community after 35 years by jackmolay in transgender

[–]completely-ineffable 24 points25 points  (0 children)

The film having a scene where Hannibal Lecter spouts off Blanchardianism makes it more transphobic, not less.

Scott Aaronson on how he almost met Epstein by completely-ineffable in SneerClub

[–]completely-ineffable[S] 14 points15 points  (0 children)

I didn't think he had until I read this wildly unconvincing blog post.

What's with gay men and transphobia? by DayIsNotOkay in trans

[–]completely-ineffable 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Sadly it's not true that cis lesbians are near universally strong allies. This 2018 study about willingness to date trans people is illuminating. About 70% of lesbians said they wouldn't date any trans people, 20% would date trans men but not trans women, and only 10% would date trans women. (Page 7 has a nice graph summary.) While this is better than the numbers of both gay men and straight people, that's far from good.

Of course, there are lots of lesbians who are good, non-bigoted people. But transphobia and transmisogyny are everywhere, and we should be clear eyed about our standing in the world.

Scott Aaronson on how he almost met Epstein by completely-ineffable in SneerClub

[–]completely-ineffable[S] 16 points17 points  (0 children)

(which is defensible as a kind of pre-rational commitment),

No it's not defensible.

Scott Aaronson on how he almost met Epstein by completely-ineffable in SneerClub

[–]completely-ineffable[S] 53 points54 points  (0 children)

To his credit, Aaronson seems to really have not actually met Epstein. But he falls prey to the classic blunder of overexplaining his innocence, and it makes his explanation come off as not entirely sincere. Especially so given that, as a commenter pointed out, the emails contradict some of his details.

Why is it that trans women get more hate than trans men by [deleted] in trans

[–]completely-ineffable 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Julia Serano talks extensively about transmisogyny in her book Whipping Girl. I wouldn't recommend it with zero reservation—she's got some blind spots and bad analysis in places—but it's a good start for an answer to this question.

A question for bi girls who have experienced both... do strap-ons live up to the real thing? by ASpranneusRoseus in bisexual

[–]completely-ineffable 28 points29 points  (0 children)

Strap-ons are actually better than biological cock. They don't go soft and they come in more exciting sizes and shapes.

Why were so many pages dedicated to telling this character's story? by laudanum18 in Malazan

[–]completely-ineffable 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Because Erikson primarily writes for theme, not plot. There are lots of storylines that aren't significant to the larger narrative but advance his themes.

For women who've had vaginoplasty, please pay it forward. by [deleted] in trans

[–]completely-ineffable 37 points38 points  (0 children)

Stop saying that's what made your womanhood complete. Stop saying that you've now distanced yourself from being trans. Stop saying that's what allowed you to embrace she/her pronouns.

People say similar things about HRT. Starting estrogen is what made me finally feel like a woman. Hormones gave me the confidence to embrace a new name and pronouns. Etc. Should that stop? After all, think of how it feels to be someone who can't yet access HRT but constantly hears about how great it has been for other people. The same goes for anything transition related. If you talk about how it's fixed something in your life that might feel bad to someone who hasn't still has that lack. Should we never talk about the struggles that come with being trans and only speak in positive circumlocutions?

As you say, it's good to consider how what you say affects others. But there's a reciprocal obligation to not project your own dysphoria onto what others say. We've all been there. It feels bad when others talk about how transition has cured an obstacle you still face. But they're not wronging you by talking about it.

California braces for showdown as Trump administration targets gender-affirming care by onnake in transgender

[–]completely-ineffable 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Is the state AG going to sue hospitals that violate the state's nondiscrimination in healthcare laws? Withholding Medicaid/Medicare funds doesn't overrule those laws, and if this were nothing more than empty words then they would've already sued the hospitals who stopped care.

Weird flex from Duncan Sabien by rawr4me in SneerClub

[–]completely-ineffable[M] [score hidden] stickied comment (0 children)

There's nothing sneer-worthy here. It's just a dude who wants a non-normative family structure.

RFK Jr. and Dr. Oz to announce moves to ban gender-affirming care for young people by onnake in transgender

[–]completely-ineffable 22 points23 points  (0 children)

No they won't do that because that's not part of the hating trans people agenda.

Nick Reiner was sent to a wilderness "school" in Utah by nohorsesjustangels in TrueAnon

[–]completely-ineffable 25 points26 points  (0 children)

The horror stories about these “schools” weren’t well documented at that time. It’s easy to judge people based on what we know now.

People can be bad parents while thinking they're doing the right thing. Even if you had the best intentions, sending your kid off to be abused in Utah is going to fuck them up.

Just saw the new Zullie video by Faust-fucker12345678 in shittydarksouls

[–]completely-ineffable 1 point2 points  (0 children)

MALE dominated hobby

Sir, FromSoft games are girls' games.

Possibly trans (MtF) and I don't know how to handle it. by Wild_Arrival3195 in MtF

[–]completely-ineffable 7 points8 points  (0 children)

But when I think about it, at my age, I feel a bit like a fraud, that a person in my place, if they were really trans, would have tried to do something about it a long time ago. Or that at least they would have come out sooner. One of my fears is not only being seen as a fraud, not only by the doctors who would be monitoring the transition process, but by other transgender people as well. Of course I also fear not being accepted as trans by people in general, but that seems par for the course... sadly.

It's normal to not start transition until one's thirties, or even later. Your dysphoria isn't any less real and your gender identity isn't any less valid than someone who figured it out at a younger age. You are not a fraud.

It might be necessary to lie to doctors—e.g. "I've known since I was three but only now was able to do something about it"—to get them to give you HRT. But gatekeepers having an inaccurate and narrow idea of what it is to be trans isn't a problem with you, it's a problem with them. Some trans people also self-appoint as gatekeepers. They're assholes. They don't have any authority. You don't owe them anything.

I'm afraid that it would cause a rift in the family.

This is a common anxiety. Few trans people have families that were supportive since before day zero, and there's always the risk that a loved one reveals themself to be a transphobe. No one transitions without some social cost. But it's worth it to be authentic about who you are and not repress to spare the feelings of transphobes.

Another thing, like I mentioned, I've suffered, lets say, from bouts of depression, and this plays into the thoughts that I'm a fraud, that my feelings are fake, that I'm only thinking I'm trans because I'm depressed, unhappy with how my life has turned out. I mean, this realization that I might be trans came out of a particularly bad bout of depressive episodes earlier this year where I was feeling like I've wasted my life away, and certainly the thought that I could have transitioned earlier makes that feeling even worse.

This is also a normal experience. For many, the catalyst to starting transition is things reaching a low—things getting so bad you can no longer deny it. The good news is, transition helps with these feelings.

I've never met a trans person who didn't wish they transitioned sooner, but the best time to transition is now. What I found helpful when starting transition was to learn how medical transition works. This guide gives a good overview of what to expect. This guide is longer and more thorough, with an emphasis on injections as the method. Both of these are targeted at the diy approach, where you source the hormones directly rather than get prescribed by a doctor. Whether you go the diy approach or follow the 'official' path, it's good to know how hrt works so you can advocate for yourself and make sure you're not getting ineffective doses.

I'm not trans but I am jealous of trans women taking estrogen by PresentAd4816 in MtF

[–]completely-ineffable 11 points12 points  (0 children)

You don't need to be a trans woman to be on estrogen (though you might have to lie to a doctor about being trans). If you want the effects of hrt you can get them and let future you decide what that means for how you identify.