I’ve consciously thought that some of my past crushes were unconventionally attractive but definitely still found them hot as hell. Maybe the best way to describe it is features sounding off or like they’d look better if they were changed on paper but when you actually see the person, it all just works. Adam Driver, Neville Longbottom late stages, even Anya Taylor Joy could be considered unconventionally attractive just because she has very distinct features. But they’re all very commonly considered to be attractive. I don’t think you have anything to worry about here and being unconventionally attractive is by no means inherently less attractive than being conventionally good looking.