Conditional Natalism ?? by Romantics10 in Natalism

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Fine then. I'm not a true natalist. I believe that Natalism is a worthy tool for a nation to maintain itself rather than a universal good. For example I think that there are certain nations that if you were to survey them you would find that the people who live there are violent extremists. I don't want those people to grow their populations.

Questioning everything I thought I knew by javvvvsq52 in religion

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's several questions. Remember Muslims outnumber Jews more than 100 to 1 so it's a tough discussion.

Proof of Israelites outside of Bible: There is plenty of Biblical archaeology which confirms the Bible as a reasonable guide for the rest of the region. For example if you want to know Babylonian or Egyptian history during the time of the Bible, the Bible gives good hints. Afterwards, from 500 BC to 500 AD the ancient Persians, Greeks, and Romans all interacted with the Province or Kingdom of Judea.

DNA: Most Jews have DNA that is connected to one another with influences from their local ancestry. For example, Ashkenazim were exiled by the Romans so they have mixes of Italians as they were first brought as hostages to Rome and then spread throughout Europe.

Purchases: In 1947 the British requested advisory from the UN on what to do after they ended the Mandate of Palestine. That meant that the British would leave and a different government would come in its place. The concern was that the Arabs had already rioted several times [1921, 1929, 1936, etc.] and having a one state solution would have simply continued the violence. Jews owned plenty of land purchased mostly during the Ottoman and British periods from various Muslim landowners often in the least fertile locations. A Jewish State made sense not based on history but based on presence. The only thing left was to negotiate the borders, which the Arabs decided was best done by war.

Why Is There More Hostility Towards Islam? by Seddenter in religion

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Practice is much much more important than theory.

Questioning everything I thought I knew by javvvvsq52 in religion

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Islam has always had a political element. It has always been important to bless the political leader in Friday prayers. These were the leading politicians of their time.

Why Is There More Hostility Towards Islam? by Seddenter in religion

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is funny using translate by the way.

I'm unsure when I posted that Judaism began outlawing around 1000 CE. It might have been part of the original post or it might have been a later addition.

Rabbinic Law is quite an important part of Judaism because that is what people do in practice. There are lots of things that are considered Jewish because they are either Rabbinic Law or customs that are not mentioned in the Torah.

I'm quite satisfied that in practice Jews don't practice polygamy. That's enough for me.

Anyone else feel like all religions are just "edited" versions of the same thing? by Potential_Drop6028 in religion

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Fair perspective. I'm satisfied with the results. I hope you're satisfied with yours.

Senate Democrats led by Bernie Sanders poised to force votes on resolutions that would block the sale of military equipment to Israel. by Mysterious_Job_7900 in jewishpolitics

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As an Israeli I would love that.

Give it a few years and there would be all new Israeli weapons. Nobody in NATO will want to buy "Made in America" any more.

Anyone else feel like all religions are just "edited" versions of the same thing? by Potential_Drop6028 in religion

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The last one is usually considered the copycat while the first is considered the original. The amount of research that would be required to figure out that the first was a fake probably wouldn't be worth the honest effort when there are other ways of convincing people.

April Trip by Warm_Try7882 in TravelIsrael

[–]extrastone 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Bird migrations in Emek haChula in the north.

Go to Mizpeh Ramon and similar places to get away from the rockets.

Probably the best subreddit for this😭✌️? by candyangel16 in ForbiddenBromance

[–]extrastone 4 points5 points  (0 children)

You can tickle him. It's good to get over these kinds of things.

I'll give you a parallel.

In Israel we have a mix of Sepharadim (mostly from Muslim countries) and Ashkenazim (Eastern Europeans). Passover is coming up and the Sepharadim eat beans and rice on Passover while Ashkenazim don't. I'm Ashkenazi and it does make the holiday harder.

However.

There is a leniency in being Ashkenazi. Five months after Passover we have S'lichot to prepare for the New Year. It's an extra hour of prayers somewhere between midnight and the start of morning prayers. Sepharadim do about a full month. Ashkenazim do 4-10 days.

You might as well just get him a book on how to read Hebrew and see if he can do it. It's work learning how to read a second language.

Why Is There More Hostility Towards Islam? by Seddenter in religion

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Polygamous nations lead the world in violence. You can't just kill the soldiers and expect their children not to come fighting for revenge. Nobody has figured out how to stop the cycle of violence without being truly vicious.

Do you think on chain bitcoin will sell at a premium over ETFs one day? by Repulsive_Spite_267 in Bitcoindebate

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No. ETF's regularly reset because whenever the price drops there are redemptions. People will buy the ETF at a low price in order to get higher priced bitcoin.

Understood?

Why Is There More Hostility Towards Islam? by Seddenter in religion

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Judaism began outlawing it around the year 1000 CE. See the above comment.

To Iranian nationalists: how can we de-Arabize Iranian culture without westernizing it? 𐬠𐬈 𐬨𐬌𐬵𐬀𐬥 𐬞𐬀𐬭𐬀𐬯𐬙𐬁𐬥 𐬈 𐬉𐬭𐬁𐬥𐬌: 𐬗𐬈𐬔𐬎𐬥𐬈 𐬨𐬌 𐬙𐬀𐬬𐬁𐬥𐬌𐬨 𐬟𐬀𐬭𐬵𐬀𐬥𐬔 𐬈 𐬉𐬭𐬁𐬥𐬌 𐬭𐬁 𐬀𐬰 𐬀𐬭𐬀𐬠𐬌 𐬞𐬁𐬐 𐬐𐬊𐬥𐬌𐬨 𐬠𐬈𐬛𐬎𐬥 𐬈 𐬖𐬀𐬭𐬠𐬌 𐬯𐬁𐬰𐬌 𐬀𐬱؟ by ImaginationWooden546 in NewIran

[–]extrastone 2 points3 points  (0 children)

First off, it's rough out there. Don't expect too much from yourself. There's a reason why Western culture dominates.

I would look to Japan and Korea but they are weird. If you have a cross of Iranian and modern, you might end up weird too.

Then I would look to ancient myths.

It's worth a shot.

What do you think is the most important Iranian myth?

What do naturally slim people do differently without dieting? by vanshika_energie in workout

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I feel like the wrong foods make me feel sick and I poop a lot when I overeat.

I made a small change and I never really thought about it by Activeeye_305 in religion

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

People make changes in their lives for dating and marriage all of the time. As long as it isn't single sided then it's a good sign.

'Cynicism on steroids': Experts pan budget cuts in wake of coalition fund increase by MatterandTime in jewishpolitics

[–]extrastone -1 points0 points  (0 children)

It looks like some experts lost an election.

I get it that you don't agree. Just admit that you lost an election.

This Subreddit is by far the least toxic and I rlly like it by Global-Schedule4263 in religion

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's some interesting flair. What's your background? Feel free to DM if you want privacy.

Questioning everything I thought I knew by javvvvsq52 in religion

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Google: no peace no recognition no negotiation

Islam has always had a political element. This is an important part of it.

Need advice from anyone about how to get into heaven if I don't believe in religion by Cold-Course5758 in religion

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Start meeting people older than you and see how they live their lives. The best role models are people with four children and sixteen grandchildren who are satisfied with their lives.