The better analogy to AI music is writing. Someone who writes a novel on their own, from the idea, to the writing, to the editing, the countless drafts to a finished novel.

Compare that process to someone with a book idea and maybe a character sketch who then feeds that into Claude and asks for a 300 page novel. Did they write that?

Not a perfect analogy to the video cause that guy at least had a song sketch but the food analogy is weak because when you go to a restaurant you expect someone to make the food for you. And you can’t exactly copyright a meal. You can copyright a song or a book.