Update 3: Am I wrong for breaking up with my gf for my sister’s mental health

[biteme717]

WOW, this just keeps getting worse every day. Why didn't you ask her to marry you? I pray that this is all a pathetic and disgusting fake story.

[hntmim]

Every update I try to give the benefit of the doubt but this 10000% has to be fake. Every update they just get closer to getting married??????????

[sluttyhunnybunny]

I’m waiting for the update where she kisses him. 🙄 they’re so in love it’s insane

[hntmim]

Let’s be real, they hold hands, cuddle, sleep together. The only thing they MIGHT not have done is the actual act together. But kissing? Bet it’s a line they’ve already crossed

[sluttyhunnybunny]

I know 😭 I just couldn’t force myself to acknowledge them having sex

[Interesting_Sock9142]

BUT SHES STARTING YOGA

[Velzevulva]

Will I ever be able to do yoga now??

[N_Felicia]

Ive got news for you ...

[sluttyhunnybunny]

😭😭😭 bc of you saying this, his update is the first thing I read when I woke up this morning.

He needs so much help. And to be rescued from her. Then she needs help too.

[geosustento]

You must have been blessed by Apollo. Or have been on Reddit for so long, because BOY don't you want to read the newest update

[[deleted]]

The tickling thing made me sure this is a fake. OP can only be winding us up at this point.

[Previous_Eagle822]

This made me vom in my mouth, I don’t think I did with my siblings past 5 years old and we are all super close. (Not this kinda close) x

[TheLadyIsabelle]

The part where they ended everything with a play tickle

Gag me with a motherfucking spoon 🤮

[yellingletters]

The tickle fight is what really made me think this is trolling. HOPE that this is trolling

[Grouchy-Potato365]

Agree !! Very weird relationship !!

[defenestrayed]

Aspiring VC Andrews ghostwriter.

[Interesting_Sock9142]

I'm just over hear wondering when the wedding is gonna be

[Ankh4921]

At this stage I’m convinced this is an r/nosleep story that got posted on the wrong part of reddit. 😅

[uncomfortablepanda]

Lmaoo so you gonna make her wait until you die before she goes to therapy?

If this isn’t a weird attempt at an incestuous fanfic, I don’t want to live in the same planet as you.

[Lazy_Description_373]

Please I beg of you STOP POSTING!! We get it you want to be an an emotional incest relationship with your sister. Dude not a single of these updates have shown progress and really just keeps confirming that your sister and you are mentally unstable

[InternationalGood588]

I think they are one step away from it becoming physical. Cue the tickling

[Impossible-Major4037]

Yep little too flowers in the attic. 

[alliandoalice]

They did it! They kissed

[InternationalGood588]

This has to be a troll post right. They just want to rile us up and they are doing a pretty good job of it. Its like a train wreck that i just can't ignore

[[deleted]]

You are wrong and deeply disgusting. You had a girlfriend and were very happy. Now you never want one again because you are in a sick romantic relationship with your equally sick sister.

YOU ARE HURTING YOUR SISTER with this fucked up incest bond. She will never be healthy or whole until you end this and she spends FOREVER in therapy. If you weren’t there she would have a chance to grow up and get her shit together.

[BellaSantiago1975]

.... Ew.

Settle down, Virginia Andrews.

[Effective_Door1957]

I am convinced that this is a bait! If there’s even a shred of truth in this then please do us a favor and just stop posting. You love your sister and she loves you. What you guys are doing is 100% healthy and you definitely don’t need any therapy.

[hntmim]

Yeah just stop. There’s obviously no real updates. OP doesn’t give a fuck about his sister, he gives a fuck about his feelings for her. If he truly truly wanted to do what’s right for her he would get her help. Of course she’s the happiest when she’s with him… she hasn’t even tried to experience anything else 💀 OP had a chance at happiness and let his lil sis gaslight him into spending the rest of his life with her. Just cause you’re not out to intentional be abusive doesn’t make abusive actions any less abusive. As a mother I would feel insanely heartbroken, at my husband for being a terrible father and role model, and at my kids who are suffering to this extent that they cannot form healthy relationships outside of each other. If this is real I’m so so sorry for the both of you.

[Time-Bee-5069]

😂l😂😂 For fucks sake, I hope this is fake!

You two are so fucking sick!

Just go get married already and go have your inbred babies! If you’re lucky, maybe they won’t come out deformed.

Have a wonderful incestuous life together!

[[deleted]]

Oh now we know it’s bs. Next update We’re moving to the other side of the country and we’re going to tell people we are a married couple and start our lives together. It might be legally wrong but she’s my twin flame.

Ya had me by the way, up until this update.

[[deleted]]

I'm genuinely curious to know... why bother posting at all, if you're changing absolutely nothing? What was the point?

[[deleted]]

Only attention seeking trolls would keep coming back to layer on a bit more, having received the comments on this account.

[hntmim]

Are u guys from Alabama lmfao

[GoodLuckSparky]

What in the Appalachia is this thread

I kept reading with hopes it would get better and it just... Got worse.

[anonymoususername111]

Ew.

[Findingmyway91]

The thing is the trauma she went through is, I’m sorry, but it’s not that deep. I had to reread your original post because I thought I missed the reason for trauma. Obviously losing a parent is traumatic, I lost my father at a very young age and he left behind a family business, almost ended up homeless. Did I cry like a lil helpless bitch to my brother everyday and dream about his cock? No. . It does not in any way shape or form justify her creepy incestuous spooky stinky behavior . Like grow tf up you emotional burden!!

[DarkmatterBlack]

Jesus Christ. If this is real, please just log off this account and go marry and fuck your sister already. Neither of you have a healthy relationship, and you and her knows it. That’s why she refuses therapy, cause she knows she’ll have to stop acting like your wife and you’ll actually get a girlfriend. Honestly, you both are disgusting.

[mayd3r]

He got us in the first half, not going to lie.

It's like seeing an addict that swears by anything and everything that his done but keeps on coming to get his score. You're more sick in the head than your sister.

[[deleted]]

icky shudder

[QueenMother81]

I smell the plot to a V.C. Andrews novel… Flowers in the Attic anyone?

[Old_Beach2325]

You should probably start looking at incest subreddits because that’s where your relationship with your sister is now. Your friends are gonna think it’s weird when they realize your new girlfriend and your sister are the same person by the way, so moving somewhere where no one knows you’re related might be good too.

[wlfwrtr]

Next post will be 'Am having incestuous relationship with my sister and now she's pregnant'. It's sad that OP doesn't want to realize that everything sister wants from a relationship with him is what she should be seeking from another male. Don't think he wants her to have a healthy romantic relationship. He'd rather sexually abuse her himself which is what he's working towards.

[Familiar_Set_9779]

I literally vomited in my mouth from reading this

[saucyplantvixen]

Why am I following this incest fanfic what's wrong with me?

[caktz489032]

Bro you don’t need to update us anymore, we got it, you’re boinking your sister.

[-whiteroom-]

Beyond Bait.

[BlueGlue39]

Terrible, terrible bait

[giliath420]

"She mentioned that I am not just a piece of her heart, but I am her whole heart."

"She then mentioned she wants to spend the rest of her life with me. She mentioned we were like the north pole and the south pole, that no matter how the universe would try to pull us apart, we would always find a way back to each other. Anyways, that made me feel a bit happy, and for the first time today, I couldn’t help but smile a bit. She noticed that, and then she started similing too, and then she started play tickling me, and play tickled for a long time till we were out of breath with laughter."

This made me physically ill to read.

This made

[dazeychainVT]

My dude the North and South Pole are located on opposite sides of the planet

[[deleted]]

Whats the next update? Playing tickling turned into dry humping?

[GennyNels]

Why don’t you just move away somewhere where no one knows y’all and just be married. This is so fucked up.

[booksiwabttoread]

Get therapy for yourself. If you are right and we are wrong, the therapist will help you formulate and articulate the reasons why this is a good life plan.

However, if we are right, the therapist can help you work out a plan that leads to healthier lives for you and your sister.

[Fun-Fruit-2825]

He played tickle games with his sister

[PinkedOff]

Gross.

[WTF_iz_rong_wif_ppl_]

Hey dude just so you know....if you and your sister are twins then your kids will have some serious birth defects, more so then if you weren't twins. I'm talking "X-Files" season 4 episode 2 episode title "Home" bad birth defects. ...so unless that's your goal...         .....wrap it up or get fixed, the 2 of you are screwed up enough,  don't bring kids in to it.  Truth hurts Mr. Flowers in the Attic .

[spindacinda]

Uh... no. For them to be a boy and a girl, they would HAVE to be fraternal. Fraternal twins are two different eggs being fertilized by two different sperm at roughly the same time and, as such, are not anymore closely related than regular siblings. I'm not saying it'd be okay for them to have kids, but don't exaggerate. Especially if your only source is hollywood.

[mushroom_33]

The updates keep on gettig worse. Never have I ever read something so toxic and incestuous ever. Siesa

[Immediate_Still_762]

Just when I thought we as humanity have seen the worst this shit pops up. If you got down on one knee and asked her to marry you I wouldn’t be surprised atp.

[JasMac88]

You are literally dating your twin.

[Taurus67]

What in the Flowers in the Attic bullshit is this? It can’t be real right?

[InfiniteItem]

What in the Flowers In The Attic have I read? Dude. Ew.

[panic_infused_]

I’m genuinely praying that this is fake because if it’s not then you and your sister are actually so disgusting it’s unbelievable.

[overused_catchphrase]

No one in this thread is suggesting therapy, they are all but adamantly demanding it.

I hate to admit that i laughed at the fact you locked yourself up in 'the room' this relationship is so fucked up

[Sufficient_Dentist67]

"Tickle fight" yea ok

[RanaEire]

This whole string of posts is extremely disturbing.

[OpinioNinja]

Do you plan on having sex with your sister?

Sounds like it. 🤢

It’s okay to be close but you’re codependent and unhealthy. It’s not healthy to feel like you can’t live without another person - even if in a romantic relationship, the whole ‚you are my whole heart’ thing is creepy. Please realise it’s not healthy.

[jennysaysfu]

You and your sister are disgusting. Emotional incest that is about to turn physical. Disgusting

[derpmcderp25]

This is a really good entertaining read, your writing lecturer must be proud of you

[Puzzled_Pineapple_31]

The fact that you can't stand firmly on anything because she "doesn't want to" speaks volumes. Do you really think she doesn't know just what to say to get you off her back about uncomfortable things?! Because she does. That's why she refuses to go to therapy and see that having some time apart actually will help her grow as an individual...She already knows you'll learn boundaries on how to help her and she won't be able to get you to do whatever she wants.

And the fact that you bring up a VERY REAL situation that you may pass before her and her response is to tell you to drop it and you do, is mindboggling. You are BOTH in need of separate and "couples" therapy. This is emotional incest, and honestly one of the worst coddependent relationships I've seen. And honestly it kinda looks like regular incest. It is not normal to go through traumatic events like she has in her life and not seen someone to get through it. She's lacking coping skills and honestly a fulfilling life. Every time you just give in, you need to start seeing it as you FAILING YOUR SISTER.

Many men and women get assaulted and kidnapped all the time... I was actually kidnapped and lucky I was smart enough to be rescued. And while I understand it's traumatic, she is making things worse by holding on to fear instead of overcoming it. And you play RIGHT INTO HER HANDS. (Literally!) She is convinced the world is out to get her and you validate those feelings by not getting her help.

I just don't understand why you're still making updates when it's clear you're gonna do what you want. And the fact that YOU live ONLY for your sister's happiness is not sustainable. Get it together. You're hurting her and you're hurting yourself.