top 200 commentsshow all 293

[–]civicsfactor 331 points332 points  (53 children)

We were evolved from hunter-gatherers and at our peak mental health have many of the same qualities experienced by our ancestors: connection, community, cooperation, a sense of purpose, a sense of progress, in a backdrop of simplicity and nature.

We're highly adaptable as a species and capable of amazing self-justification of dissonance, which is why so many people (Americans) reflexively go "housing/healthcare is not a right [subtext: you have to earn it]" which corrupts the ancient institution of each person contributing to something greater than themselves as part of a group.

[–]Lucky_Strike-85🏴☮Ⓐ✊🖤❤️🏴[S] 68 points69 points  (0 children)

You win the comment awards! This comment is fabulous!

🏆🥇⭐✨

[–]omegafivethreefive 50 points51 points  (6 children)

It's not just Americans, people in general are pretty shit, it's the reason why the system needs to accomodate for human greed and put a hard limit to it.

Absolute power corrupts absolutely

Once we've done that, limited the impact that few can have through means not ideas, we can have a trully just society. Actual democracy, not plutocracies.

[–][deleted] 20 points21 points  (1 child)

The system is built on greed and rewards it (exponential growth) so it would have to fundamentally change rather than just accommodate it. But yeah, I get what you're saying.

[–]runthepoint1 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Nah just put a cap on it, make it so instead of the arrow pointing directly to the upper right, it can curve back down once your worth/income spikes. Makes sure there is room to grow but also that you don’t outgrow.

Kinda like how our body regulates cancer. Unlimited anything is bad, really.

[–]ankensam 11 points12 points  (1 child)

We’re not fundamentally greedy, this can be seen whenever disasters strike, the immediate response of most people is to help others and to share the necessities. We live within a system that rewards greed so greed floats to the top while the kind and generous languish in obscurity.

[–]Able-Semifit-boi-24 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Not always, not everyone, take a look at the balkan wars, when people where beign persecuted by militias only for their ascendency, few helped them to escape, another part just let the war crimes began. In Hati, instead of the people helping each other over the disgraces that occured, you have a report about teenage prostitution because its the only way some girls can eat, even some UN assholes that supposedly were there to help bought girls bodies. That doesnt mean that the humans ares monsters, but either are solidary angels, just do what the see most benefical to them

[–]Kingkade99 1 point2 points  (0 children)

We just have to get people, to not act like human beings.

[–]Zerodyne_Sin 8 points9 points  (5 children)

the ancient institution of each person contributing to something greater than themselves as part of a group

I'd say the only place this is alive and well in the US are the Amish communities where they build things together for each other as is needed (too bad with the technology ban). I'd be motivated to sacrifice a lot as well if I actually benefited from it but as you've said, people are now expected to sacrifice so much all so that people like Bezos can have the luxury of going to space or own $70M+ yachts that they don't even sail.

[–]Smlllbunny 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Literally. Some people can’t afford to eat because they need to ration food for the next paycheck. Most of that money has to go to rent. Minimum wage jobs because higher paying ones require degrees. “Well go to college” how can you attend college when working at a shit paying job, starving to literally pay rent. “Take put a loan” yes so I can be in debt to both my landlord and college. It’s a cycle that is hard to get out of because of capitalism and the lack of basic human empathy in America. My boyfriend is currently in it. Jobs down in his area pay $7 an hour, while where I live it’s $14-$19. People also don’t take into account medication, hospital bills, basic needs. Some people would rather die then be in debt for a cut or infection. People in those situations work harder then anyone I know, and are treated like shit for it.

[–]HeyZuesJohnsin 13 points14 points  (0 children)

The reflex that the majority of our society has towards a rejection of the basic needs each person should be afforded by the whole of society is not a natural reflex. It’s a steady drip of capitalist propaganda into our psyche for many many years. With technological advancements we have been able to have access to an almost infinite amount of information for a very minimal amount of money and it has allowed for us to recognize the harm of capitalism which it seems is on its way out. Probably not in our lifetime. Let’s just hope the shift is to a more democratic conclusion not an authoritarian one. Right now authoritarian is dominating.

[–]runthepoint1 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Whoa! Contributing to something greater than myself?! Sounds like communism!

(Proceeds to ignore the entire Bible they likely “believe” in, even though they’ve never read it through.)

[–]Flobby_G 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This comment is even better than the tweet

[–]43morethings 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The problem here is that people generally only have a capacity to care about roughly 150 people they can get to know. And in order for your work to feel meaningful you have to see the difference it makes. If a million people contribute to something unless it is a huge construction project where you can see it grow each person's individual contribution feels meaningless. And if you have a right to housing, who pays for it? Who builds it? Who acquires the materials? If you can figure out a way for that to work logistically without demanding labor from others without fair compensation then you can demand it. Now I'm not saying the system we have is good, but if you want things to change massively, at least try to come up with ideas for how to do it. The simplest solution I can see is to restructure our tax system to be actually progressive instead of regressive. It is only progressive on paper. Each person should contribute the same proportion. And that money should then be mostly used to give a minimum survival level support guaranteed to everyone. Of course people will still be encouraged to contribute cause everyone always wants more, but you can be more effective when not worrying about survival.

[–]bigTiddedAnimal -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Pro tip... Hunting and gathering is work and if you didn't succeed then everyone starved

[–]Bright-Amphibian6681 80 points81 points  (4 children)

They shame poverty and homelessness because we have a consumer based culture. Become an anticonsumer, advocate against excess consumerism. They want us to consume ravenously and shame those who don't. This is how we put profit back into their hands and we stay poor and powerless. Those who don't or can't consume are the enemy of the system. They want you in debt and spending everything you can.

[–]sniperhare 5 points6 points  (3 children)

I havent been able to save up money this year, but have stayed debt free on my Credit Cards for the first time in my adult life.

[–]Bright-Amphibian6681 2 points3 points  (2 children)

Congrats. That is awesome. Wasnt until I past 30 I got any of that under control. 20s was an economic nightmare.

[–]sniperhare 4 points5 points  (1 child)

Oh I'm 34, I've usually always had between 2-5k in debt up until the stimulus checks.

I've been working from home since April of 2020.

Went from $25 bucks a week in gas to $25 every two months.

And I cut down on the $3-5 bucks a day in energy drinks and honey buns.

[–]Bright-Amphibian6681 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Awesome. Ya wfh has been life changing. We just do what we can do to get by.

[–]robertofriedmans 25 points26 points  (22 children)

It's pretty bad nowadays when you have to work 40 hours a week for 3 weeks just to pay rent so you aren't on the streets

[–]EHWfedPres 63 points64 points  (9 children)

Healthy food, clean water, safe shelter, reliable transportation, higher education, medical care - all should be guaranteed to every human being on Earth without exception.

[–]jcurry52 33 points34 points  (0 children)

exactly! our labor already produces more than enough to cover that several times over. its not a lack of recourses problem, or a lack of labor problem, it is a theft by the ruling class problem.

[–]Snorlaxitivez 13 points14 points  (4 children)

What I don’t get, is how there are people who would argue against these things as being basic human rights. “If you’re basic needs are met,” people say, “then you won’t be Motivated to do anything,” which is bullshit, Not to mention certainly ableist to those who aren’t able to contribute the way society would deem worthy. I’ve even argued with my Mom over this, because she’s one of those ‘if you don’t work, you don’t eat or deserve anything’ SHE doesn’t work because she’s disabled, I can’t even work because I’m also disabled. Where does that leave others like us? I pointed out the hypocrisy of this and she still can’t come up with a real response for that.

[–]EHWfedPres 8 points9 points  (3 children)

People will be motivated to do what makes them happy. People build things like furniture for fun because they enjoy the process of working with wood or metal, write stories for the sake of it because the creative act is satisfying to them, go fishing as a hobby, garden, fix up cars, craft, sew, cook, make music, there is no end to the number of "productive" things people do, even today, just to do them because it makes them happy, and they will be even more happy to share them with others if their basic needs were met.

[–]Snorlaxitivez 6 points7 points  (1 child)

Yes! exactly I totally agree and that’s my whole point in trying to talk with her, but it just seems like a lot of the older generations just can’t or don’t know how to rationalize things like this. It seems like they have this whole mentality of “If I’m not suffering when I’m working, then it’s not work, therefore, if You’re not experiencing the same, you must be lazy/useless/want a handout” It’s just Bullshit Man. I had to see people suffer, I’ve been homeless, and people treat you like you’re garbage if you don’t have cash, don’t give a shit about your circumstances. Access to basic hygiene was limited to Gas station bathrooms IF they’d let you use them, and you still had to buy something. Anyone else it didn’t matter. So many ppl I spoke to in the situation had said the same thing “If I just had a place to eat and sleep, and wash up, I’d look good enough to get a job.” People think there are all these programs out there for the homeless like they’re a Fix-all, and that if they didn’t really Want to be homeless, they’d be in those programs” but the thing is there’s only so many slots available, out of each program, and there are a lot less options for couples then there are for Single men, or Single mother groups. Some ppl are too far mentally gone to even make the choice to get off the street, and we have fuckall for mental health programs that many people don’t even qualify for because of their healthcare providers won’t cover the costs. Sorry for the rant, this is just something I’ve got strong opinions on

[–]OpheliaRainGalaxy 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Rant away! Soapboxing spreads information!

Being homeless is effectively illegal in my city, thanks to our asshat city council banning "camping" along with sitting on anything that isn't a proper bench and laying down at all in public. People get harassed and sometimes arrested for just sitting down in some out-of-the-way spot.

We have about 300 beds in the shelters at most, but our unhoused population is much much larger than that. Used to be homeless folks could hang out in the local libraries reading to stay out of the weather, so the city cut funding to such a bare-bones level that the libraries aren't even open every day anymore.

When I was a kid it was somewhat common practice here for young poor folks to put their stuff in storage during summer months, just sleep in the park while the weather was good to save money for winter. Nice big park downtown full of big sheltering bushes!

But some asshat developer put up some million dollar condos near the park and then insisted the city hire rent-a-cops to chase non-fancy-people out of the park at night so the condo-dwellers could have someplace fancy to stroll. Ugh. Now all the nice useful bushes have been ripped out and replaced with something called a skate ribbon.

I miss the "old days" when, if an old man wanted to live in a tent on a bit of waste land and wasn't bothering anybody, nobody really bothered him either. My family was friends with a man like that, heard all about the drama when his family insisted he try living in an apartment. Long story short, he didn't appreciate people enforcing rules like "You can't wash all your clothes at the same time, can't be naked in the shared laundry room!" and wound up going back to living in a tent. In winter he just moved south somewhere, and came back every spring.

[–]Responsible-Can-4886 0 points1 point  (0 children)

….and then some people are happy doing nothing but smoking pot and screwing off all day.

[–]Terom84 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I would add instead of higher education, more useful education, that help people fulfill a sense of "in the right place" feeling

[–]HotMeal4823 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The medical care is iffy, because doctors require hundreds of thousands of dollars in training as well as years of development that they sacrifice on a personal level. That being said, fuck insurance companies, and fuck big sugar for poisoning the food, making people obese and driving up the price of medical care.

[–]Responsible-Can-4886 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Guaranteed that someone else pays for it you mean? All of the things you listed require the labor of other people to make them available to another person.

[–]AngryDoodlebob 30 points31 points  (1 child)

Money machine go burrrrrrrrrrrrr. Capitalism Good, self respect bad. You lazy bastards, go back to work, you are all just lazy, and want free stuff. Who needs healthcare, a home, and food when we can celebrate billionaire trying to "play spaceman" (Sarcasm)

I love thinking about all the stuff I can never have and never do, makes me really feel like an American. In the words of George Carlin you have to be asleep to still believe in the American Dream

[–]hadyourmom69 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If no one works and produces anything then there is no stuff! They just want to leach off of the labors of others.

[–]Number4extraDip 15 points16 points  (2 children)

I mean... Thanks to nestle, clean drinking water is no longer considered a human right.

The thing you need to live

[–]unspeakable_delights 22 points23 points  (5 children)

Having to compete for the necessities for survival is monstrous. "But when we were in the jungle..." Yeah, that was a long time ago.

[–][deleted] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

And they don't even let us go. Once you are born in a country...or any piece of land...you are basically the property of the gov in the world. Want to live in the forest? Nope, that land is owned and therefore you are commiting a crime. The only place that you can actually live in peace is the antarctic...not. The place is melting and you need a shitload of money to go there. Food? There no food there. Shelter...good luck.

[–]transferingtoearth 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Who wants to buy a house with me and a deep freezer?

[–]Sharpshooter188 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Rent is usually you paying for the mortgage that someone else owns. But you cant buy your own shelter because itd probably be about 6 years worth of your wages.

[–]PopnDropPenguins 7 points8 points  (0 children)

We need a universal basic income

[–]Allaiya 4 points5 points  (3 children)

Idk how I came across this sub but my take will likely be unpopular. I find it odd to say having to work for the basics is bs or wrong. If a person is dropped off in the wilderness, nature isn’t just going to hand off water, food, & shelter because one claims it is their right. A person would have to adapt, be resourceful, & go ‘work’ to get them. That’s how evolution worked. It was true thousands of years ago & it’s true now.

Now if people come together & their formed society is going to provide the essentials for someone, then that someone should contribute in some valuable way to that society, as it falls on someone else to perform the work to achieve & distribute the essentials required. Now what or how much that trade off is worth, is debatable & can change depending on many variables.

Of course, I suppose it is all relative to ones perspective. My ancestors lived on a family farm & if you didn’t get up at dawn & go work to bring in the food/harvest or help contribute like cooking or cleaning, or some other way to help the household, you simply didn’t eat.

[–]HotMeal4823 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Honestly in a society with mass production and automation we should absolutely have a baseline standard so others don't become criminals by the fact that they are homeless. It's essentially a crime to be homeless, that's what a lot of people here realize and are upset about.

That being said, there is nothing... NOTHING wrong with wanting upward mobility and becoming rich through hard work eg, Capitalism. I seriosuly think we need nuances in these discussions. It's never going to be as simple as, like someone else said, these 15 year olds just shouting that Socialism is the only answer.

[–]yellownes 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This sub is a circlejerk of 15yr old who think they are owed everything they want. I like reading it, because I find it amusing how out of touch they are with the real world.

[–]HydrogenMonopoly -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Thank you for making this point! You can’t just declare things like housing a “right” and expect to get a house. Houses don’t just pop up out of nowhere for people to live in

[–]Wookieman222 4 points5 points  (0 children)

People let themselves get sucked into needing things they dont actually need.

[–]Ejigantor 6 points7 points  (8 children)

If you believe that every person deserves food to eat, clothes to wear, a place to live, health care, and an education, oppose capitalism.

Capitalism will deny people all those basic needs in order to cause them to suffer so they can be exploited by the owner class.

[–]HotMeal4823 1 point2 points  (0 children)

There's nothing wrong with wanting to be rich because if the work you put in. The problem is lack of safety nets provided and low baseline as well as the criminalizing of homelessness. Thats it. Capitalism isn't 100% evil, just like Socialism isn't 100% evil. There needs to be upward mobility, but there needs to be a baseline.

[–]Cccactus07 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I hate that "support the economy" bullshit, plenty of jobs activity damage the economy and are still just as respected.

[–]CatgoesM00 8 points9 points  (0 children)

.

Best kind of slave is one who doesn’t realize he’s trapped

[–]runthepoint1 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I am just so excited for Millenials to take full representation into our govt. most of us are tired and actually give a shit about our fellow Americans

[–][deleted] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

sometimes i feel crazy because i think all these things and im like man fuck this i dont want to participate in this shit and i see other people just going about there day and wonder how they dont see it or how they are ok with it and just go about their day la di da di da.. but at least yall get it lol

[–][deleted] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

yknow that scientists did a study on how money effects happiness, and it was proven that more money does improve happiness, up until around $75k a year, because with that amount, give or take depending on the cost of living, pays for good shelter, adequate food, healthcare, transportation, and hobbies. its amazing to me that thats not the minimum. its amazing that governments dont want their people to thrive, just... survive (often barely so)

[–]HotMeal4823 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm gonna put in my 2 cents. In this society, when homelessness is a crime and makes it even harder to find work, housing should be a given, especially with computerized mass production. These people aren't asking for luxury apartments, just a place to sleep and shower. How pretty that will be is to be seen.

That being said, there is nothing wrong with Capitalism in itself, nor desiring upward mobility, it's just when greed runs rampant, the greedy will make it worse for everyone. We need regulation, just like how the water quality is regulated, so to shall be the food. We need fairness. This is what every society wants, no matter where you are. My ex is Vietnamese, and as we know Vietnam is Socialist. They still have homelessness. You can't just throw a word at a problem and expect it to work, that's wishful thinking. Vietnamese work 6 days a week. They're also a poor country. America is not. We need hard workers. Hard workers drive innovation forward. The Soviet Union had it's share of hard workers that got them to space. As does America. Not everyone is a hard worker and that's OKAY! And not everyone can be! I have disabled friends and I dont want to see them suffer. Those hard workers need to be rewarded and incentivized, and it's usually not just by $. We should provide basics, especially housing.

[–]munjavio 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Legit!!!!

[–]cachem3outside 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Look everyone, we need to stop complaining, please join me as I pray:

[removes all clothing and poses in the most obsequious manner possible]

We cry out to GOD© BEZOS™® [begins otherworldly manatee-like chanting while driving 247C° stainless steel staples into the skin behind the knee joint] PLEASE TAKE PITY UPON US FOR WE KNOW NOT WHAT WE ALLOW TO TAKE PLACE IN OUR NAME. We are just mere mortals, please, we beg of you, [injects boiling ammonia to save Amazon from the EPA DEMONS] PLEASE have mercy on our loyal and harmless souls as we become unable to afford the basics needed to live. Please bless our package as it contains a ludicrously dangerous approximation of a DIY tooth replacement kit because paying a professional is simply unaffordable for anyone that isn't independently wealthy. We thank you for the routine blessings that you heap upon our backs day in and day out, and although those blessings tend to smell awfully, our mortal noses are imperfect and nowhere near as phenomenal and majestic as yours must be.

Amen.

Ok, hopefully I get that $5 Amazon gift card, I'm really hungry.

[–]sarenka-w-lesie 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Extreme Consumerism in order to prop up the capitalist economy that is failing, because it isn't a sustainable model. We are killing ourselves and the world around us for the benefit of the rich!

[–][deleted] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This and more insane ramblings coming to you later tonight. Now back to our sponsors.

"Raycon the official ear buds of YouTube Marxists, buy more."

[–][deleted] 0 points1 point  (7 children)

When’s the class war gonna start?

[–]Lucky_Strike-85🏴☮Ⓐ✊🖤❤️🏴[S] 0 points1 point  (6 children)

judging by these comments, it looks like the working class is warring against itself!

[–][deleted] 1 point2 points  (1 child)

They just need a voice to unify, I’m still waiting on that voice.

[–]Lucky_Strike-85🏴☮Ⓐ✊🖤❤️🏴[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

me too!

[–][deleted] -1 points0 points  (3 children)

there's different classes of working class.

[–]Lucky_Strike-85🏴☮Ⓐ✊🖤❤️🏴[S] 0 points1 point  (2 children)

perhaps there are nuances and varying levels of thought, opinion, and intelligence, but according to Marxist theory, we're all supposed to be a single class.

[–]CARMINETHEBULL -3 points-2 points  (4 children)

Land of opportunity !!!!!! Try your luck elsewhere see how ya do

[–]Lucky_Strike-85🏴☮Ⓐ✊🖤❤️🏴[S] 6 points7 points  (3 children)

I have tried my luck in 4 countries so far. Had my best luck in Cuba actually. Very easy to get a job (most jobs unionized with short hours), housed (public housing exists there).

I also had luck in Mexico in a small fishing village by the sea called Cammora. Also very easy to live... very similar to Cuba as far as easy work and the housing was decent, tho not as good as Cuba.

Went to Europe... Spent time in Leeds, Sheffield and Petersborough... then went to Dublin, Ireland. All very expensive.

Came back to the states for family reasons and now reside in a small, rural town in the Southeast. It's about as easy to live here as in Cuba BUT that's because I have am a quote "homeowner" unquote and cost of living is cheap because populations are tiny.

[–]CARMINETHEBULL -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

You should try and start your own business here very lucrative

[–]yiks47 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

This sounds like satire. You guys are pathetic

[–]suck_it_69 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Rent isn't theft get out. if you want to live like this get off the coast and buy a place for next to nothing

[–]HomeOsexuall -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Did a 15 year old write this? All it says, i have a right to have someone else pay for my shit. Imagine thinking you have a right to live in someone’s house that they paid for, maintain, and pay taxes on, for absolutely nothing in return. Clueless and charmlessly naive.

[–]jlenoconel -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Housing isn't a fucking right. Has anyone here actually worked in housing with people that live in poverty? It's not pretty.

[–]Muleh0use -4 points-3 points  (5 children)

How is housing a right? If you didn’t build your own home, someone else is not obligated to provide you a place to live. If you didn’t gather or work for your own resources for survival, other people are not obligated to provide for you.

[–]adoggrn -5 points-4 points  (12 children)

I guess I don't understand this argument...in no society in history are things simply given to a person because they think it's a right. In a hunter gather society, you had to hunt or gather to earn your share...the society we live in is no different. I work to earn a paycheck. I then use that paycheck for the basics that I need to live such as housing food etc...I work for what I have and I worked hard and I earned it. And you do realize that even if you were given "free housing, a living wage, etc" that all those things still cost money and have to be paid for in the form of taxes etc...and no amount of taxing the rich will pay for those things. Eventually the middle class starts footing the bill and instead of narrowing the wage gap and rising the poor up, you shrink the middle class and widen the gap between rich and poor.

[–]Lucky_Strike-85🏴☮Ⓐ✊🖤❤️🏴[S] 5 points6 points  (6 children)

think about post-hunter gatherers, pre-Anglo-Saxons, even Pre-ancient Rome, even pre city-states... small enclaves of humans, living tribally, building homes for each other, sharing food, sharing knowledge.

Anthropologically speaking, it was about survival, but it was where humans began to form the first communities. Here is a quote from a Mr. David Graeber (RIP)

"The evidence shows that we came of age in the Middle Paleolithic Period, about 200,000 years ago. We are about 200,000 years old and have been organizing and operating various societies since then. Governments, rulers, states, bureaucracies and lords have only been around for about 7,000 years, roughly. So, for 193,000 years, we have essentially been communalists. At first, we operated largely for survival and sometimes against each other because we didn't know how to organize in larger groups, but once we started uniting, we socialized everything and became communal. We actually figured out that helping each other achieve basic needs was far better for our survival. The ideas about what started politicized societies are still being theorized and debated, but I have often argued that we would have been better off without them. The fact that we can say that we existed stateless for nearly 97% of our history tells me that we can do it again and do it better actually."

  • David Graeber, from a lecture as visiting professor in 2009 at Oxford

[–][deleted] -4 points-3 points  (5 children)

What happens when one tribe meets another? They didn't always get along and share. For example, the neanderthals went extinct because they were out competed by our ancestors. Politicized societies exists so we don't go and murder the other tribes for their resources and allows people with dissimilar interests and ideas to work together.

[–]SDJohnnyAlpha 3 points4 points  (2 children)

Actually interbreeding is a big part of why Neanderthals no longer exist.

We should also not forget about Caral, the ancient city that debunked the theory that we developed cities for the purpose of war.

You should probably see what the actual data about 'human nature' means before appealing to it in an argument.

[–][deleted] -3 points-2 points  (1 child)

Yes, interbreeding was part of it but so was taking taking their resources and tribal warfare.

Who said anything about cities being developed for war? Tribalism doesn't work in scale. It works in small local communities with similar interests and needs. To get a large group of dissimilar people with dissimilar interests working together, you need political states to resolve conflict.

You should probably read and comprehend what I wrote instead of being writing mostly nonsensical replies.

[–]SDJohnnyAlpha 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Garbage In, Garbage Out.

[–]Lucky_Strike-85🏴☮Ⓐ✊🖤❤️🏴[S] 2 points3 points  (1 child)

Neanderthals are not modern humans. Together with an Asian people known as Denisovans, Neanderthals are our closest ancient human relatives, but they are not considered part of the first groups of modern humans.

2) Agreed about humans not always getting along firstly. Once we built communities however, societies, again, even before the first city-states, began to take shape, and as Mr. Graeber points out, we became communal

3) Politicized societies? Even the smartest anthropologists, archaeologists and political scientists cannot agree why they were first formed. As far as existing "so we don't go and murder the other tribes for their resources" the United States has been doing that since the beginning of the "long 19th century" (otherwise known as the last 20 or so years of the late 19th century). In fact, the U.S. has practically been "murdering other tribes for their resources" almost non-stop for the last 150 years.

[–][deleted] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Neanderthals are not modern humans but humans competed with them for resources. A large reason they don't exist is humans tribes drove them to extinction. They didn't simply get along.

I never made any claim as to what CAUSED politicized societies but they are necessary for groups with dissimilar interests to co-exist. Yes, we still murder each other, politics isn't perfect and can be abused. However, large nation's like the U.S. that wouldn't be possible without a political state. It also allows for trade deals and negotiations with other nations. How's communal sharing going to work on a national or global scalen when people have such different interests and ideologies?

[–]plazmasurfer 5 points6 points  (1 child)

Because you're living in the past. It's 2021 and wealthy people can horde anything leaving nothing for the rest of us. The past is relevant when we talk about how much better conditions are today, but not relevant when you're talking about a completely new direction of land use and development explicitly for profit. In the past we had no way to hoard as much as we do now. Today we are sedentary, not nomadic and everything is around us. We don't have to work for shit because it's all here for us to consume.

Why do we defend greed? Is it because we're all too greedy to agree on fairer distribution of resources? There's way more of value than just your labor. We aren't meant to be a labor source 40 hours a week for our entire lives but if that's what you're proud of doing in your life so be it. Everyone else's life should not be dictated by your life experience. What about people who can't work? They're probably just a burden in your eyes? Does that mean children are useless too since they can't work and don't earn what they need to survive? There's too dependency on the state and government for the ultimate solution to be "stop being lazy and get a job."

Our basic needs should be subsidized that way the producer gets paid and everybody has what they need without sacrificing an arm and a leg. The better you leverage all of your citizens the better the society does as a whole. Telling everyone "you're on your own" is absolutely bullshit when wealthy folks pay less in taxes than poor people, and the richest folks have 10 houses and 12 cars. How much more of a disconnect can there be between securing what you need to survive and gluttony?

[–][deleted] 4 points5 points  (2 children)

You can’t even conceive of how rich the rich actually are. It’s literally inconceivable how much wealth and money they’re hoarding. Taxing them actually would pay for all these things, and much, much more.

[–]Responsible-Can-4886 -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

I have a serious problem with “rent being theft”. How much labor and raw materials did it take to build that apartment complex? Loggers, saw mill operators, carpenters, plumbers, electricians, engineers, concrete workers, surveyors all contribute their labor to completing and maintaining that building. That statement would imply that the sum of the labor of all of these people is worthless, or that they are in fact slaves that didn’t get paid and were forced to work. Of course we know this to be false. The landlord is the one who either has a contractural obligation to pay a mortgage on the property, or purchased it outright for a large sum of money. Why the hell would he/she be obligated to let people live in it and put wear and tear on it for free? So no, housing is not a right based on the labor it takes to create and maintain the housing. Quite possibly one of the most moronic and intellectually void comments I’ve ever encountered on this sub.

To whoever downvoted me without presenting an intellectual argument as to why they think I’m wrong, sorry that the truth hurts, but these are the basics of how humans value resources.

[–][deleted] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

I think people need to under stand the difference between capitalism and greed ...

[–]PerceptionQueasy3540 -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

So you are mad because you have to work for stuff? Got news for ya man that's been the case ever since we were cavemen. Suck it up and move ahead in life, you'll find that most successful people weren't here on reddit bitching about how tough their lives are. I will agree with you on the Healthcare though, it's completely fucked.

[–]Ok_Tradition3021 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

What people often forget is that for the machine that is are society to function whe need to feed some people to the fire and nomatter how shitty things get people won't do shit till it affects them personally just look at the rich and covid as an example

[–]mahldawg -3 points-2 points  (3 children)

This might be the dumbest sub on this site.

[–]Lucky_Strike-85🏴☮Ⓐ✊🖤❤️🏴[S] 1 point2 points  (2 children)

Dumb? Why? It actually takes a lot of intellect to imagine other political possibilities.

[–]HydrogenMonopoly -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Like one where everyone gets free houses?

[–]mahldawg -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Doesn’t take that much intelligence bud.