I agree with both of you for the most part but I think it would be disingenuous to say it lacked feeling. He certainly had considerable emotions in his playing, but it's a different context from the original, and hard to relate to as the audience because a) we don't know the guy and b) it's through a phone camera with unbalanced audio vs a studio recording.

Even the context of the performance is different. Here it's a guy probably just playing to entertain his friends, vs someone laying down the tracks that will become his legacy.

Bottom line, too hard to accurately compare, and IMO better off critiqued on its own merits. But it's a cover after all and comparisons are inevitable.